Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 8;12(6):e052227. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-052227

Table 4.

Analytical themes and subthemes from included studies, with summative findings

Analytical theme Descriptive theme Data theme Summative findings
Analytical theme 1: Preparation—organisational readiness for implementation Theme 1.1: Clarifying need and advantage of independent prescribing Clarifying clinical/service need for independent prescribing
Establishing service pathway gaps
Role clarity
Theme 1.2: Managerial leadership and support Role of managers
Recognising value
Culture
Theme 1.3: Interprofessional environment Inter-professional relationships
Communication & collaboration
Analytical theme 2: Training—optimising practitioner readiness for independent prescribing Theme 2.1: Selecting the right practitioners Selection
  • Adoption was impeded by inconsistent candidate selection policies and lack of workforce planning.141 143 Individual practitioner expectation of professional/personal benefit remained a key driver for IP adoption.128 130 131 136 137 139

  • Skills requisite to IP (eg, physical assessment and communication skills) were important factors influencing service user and team acceptance of IP.133 134 138 142 144 146 148–150

  • Motivational barriers (eg, lack of remuneration, fear of litigation and competing professional or personal commitments) disincentivised training uptake.136 141 143

Skills and aptitudes
Motivation and commitment
Theme 2.2: Preparing and supporting practitioners during training Expectations of training
  • Lack of information on NMP training and support for managing competing work, personal/ academic commitments negatively influenced student learning experiences.127–129 143 146

  • Standardised allocation of study leave/backfill/protected time and prepared practice mentors were essential to support learning.127–129 132

  • Additional training buddying schemes helped students better manage the competing demands of training while working.129.

Study leave
Designated Medical Practitioners
Analytical theme 3:
Transition—ensuring early prescribing support
Theme 3.1: Transition as a point of vulnerability Self-confidence
  • Transition was a point of high vulnerability for new prescribers with an initial lack of confidence often under-recognised by teams.135 137 139 140 146 147

  • Delineating a minimum scope of practice by restricting formulary and/or using guidelines/protocols facilitated early growth of competence and confidence.136 137 139 140 147 149

  • Early exposure to prescribing opportunity, time and structured support systems with medical supervision were essential in transition.127 130–132 134–137 139 146 147

Theme 3.2: Nurturing confidence and competence Minimum competence
Experience and exposure
Theme 3.3: Transition support needs Informal and formal support systems
Analytical theme 4: Sustainment—maximising and developing independent prescribing Theme 4.1: Service delivery Impact on workload
  • IP could increase workload and imposed time constraints.130 135–137 139 140 146 150 Role underuse was a risk in community settings if infrastructural requisites (eg, electronic prescribing/IT clinical record access) failed to be implemented.130 132 139 140 146 147

  • IP for service redesign and sustainability was facilitated by competence development, CPD opportunity and medical/managerial leadership.130 131 134 137 139 140 142 144 146 147 149 150

  • CPD provision and formal evaluation of IP implementation was inconsistent and lacked standardisation in primary care.130 136 140 147 150

  • ‘Enhancement’, ‘substitution’ and ‘role specific’ implementation models based on the maintenance or change in prescribing competence, service reconfiguration and/or substitution of services were identified.130 137 139 140 142 144 146 147 149

Theme 4.2: Supporting role development Role/service expansion
Continued professional development
Evaluation and reflection

CPD, continued professional development; DMPs, designated medical practitioners; GPs, general practitioners; IP, independent prescribing; NMP, non-medical prescribing.