Table 3.
Comparison of evaluated results on IEEE CEC 2020 function suite
| Function- id |
DE | jDE | SaDE | SHADE | LSHADE | LSHADE-EpSin | LSHADE-SPACMA | LSHADE-cnEpSin | ELSHADE-SPACMA | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F11 |
avg sd bst |
100 2.64e−15 100 |
100 2.64e−15 100 |
100 1.17e−09 100 |
100 9.15e−15 100 |
100 1.18e−14 100 |
8.73e+02 1.35e+03 1.01e+02 |
100≈ 0 100 |
100 4.51e−14 100 |
100≈ 0 100 |
| F12 |
avg sd bst |
2.36e+03 1.24e+03 1.11e+03 |
1.55e+03 1.49e+02 1.30e+03 |
1.28e+03 1.12e+02 1.11e+03 |
1.12e+03 3.17e+01 1.10e+03 |
1.14e+03 5.33e+01 1.10e+03 |
1.21e+03 7.93e+01 1.11e+03 |
1.17e+03 7.28e+01 1.10e+03 |
1.23e+03 7.02e+01 1.11e+03 |
1.13e+03 4.87e+01 1.10e+03 |
| F13 |
avg sd bst |
7.35e+02 1.52e+01 7.24e+02 |
7.30e+02 3.05 7.23e+02 |
7.23e+02 1.08 7.21e+02 |
7.23e+02 7.93e−01 7.21e+02 |
7.23e+02 9.49e−01 7.21e+02 |
7.08e+02 2.75 7.02e+02 |
7.24e+02 2.32 7.21e+02 |
7.26e+02 5.75 7.10e+02 |
7.23e+02 8.13e−01 7.22e+02 |
| F14 |
avg sd bst |
1.90e+03 2.41 1.90e+03 |
1.90e+03 2.89e−01 1.90e+03 |
1.90e+03 6.31e−01 1.90e+03 |
1.90e+03 1.10e−01 1.90e+03 |
1.90e+03 2.55e−01 1.90e+03 |
1.90e+03 4.12e−01 1.90e+03 |
1.90e+03 2.01e−01 1.90e+03 |
1.90e+03 1.70e−01 1.90e+03 |
1.90e+03 7.56e−01 1.90e+03 |
| F15 |
avg sd bst |
1.79e+03 8.98e+01 1.70e+03 |
2.10e+03 2.87e+02 1.72e+02 |
2.64e+03 1.37e+03 1.78e+03 |
2.19e+03 2.10e+02 1.78e+03 |
2.34e+03 2.99e+02 1.92e+03 |
1.92e+05 1.01e+05 3.73e+04 |
2.55e+03 3.13e+02 2.18e+03 |
1.93e+03 100 1.75e+03 |
2.23e+03 2.37e+02 1.86e+03 |
| F16 |
avg sd bst |
1.74e+03 9.25e−13 1.74e+03 |
1.88e+03 4.63e−13 1.88e+03 |
1.63e+03 4.63e−13 1.63e+03 |
1.68e+03 4.63e−13 1.68e+03 |
1.68e+03 1.16e−12 1.68e+03 |
1.68e+03 6.94e−13 1.68e+03 |
1.60e+03 4.63e−13 1.60e+03 |
2.05e+03 9.25e−13 2.05e+03 |
1.62e+03 6.94e−13 1.62e+03 |
| F17 |
avg sd bst |
2.14e+03 5.12e+01 2.10e+03 |
2.16e+03 6.93e+01 2.10e+03 |
2.23e+03 9.72e+01 2.11e+03 |
2.27e+03 9.22e+01 2.10e+03 |
2.28e+03 1.05e+02 2.10e+03 |
1.07e+05 6.56e+04 1.59e+04 |
2.38e+03 2.00e+02 2.14e+03 |
2.14e+03 3.44e+01 2.10e+03 |
2.28e+03 1.20e+02 2.11e+03 |
| F18 |
avg sd bst |
2.30e+03 2.06e−01 2.30e+03 |
2.30e+03 8.44e−14 2.30e+03 |
2.30e+03 3.43e−01 2.30e+03 |
2.30e+03≈ 0 2.30e+03 |
2.35e+03 2.63e+02 2.30e+03 |
2.30e+03 1.31e−12 2.30e+03 |
2.30e+03 6.81e−01 2.30e+03 |
2.30e+03 6.49e−13 2.30e+03 |
2.30e+03≈ 0 2.30e+03 |
| F19 |
avg sd bst |
2.81e+03 1.21e+01 2.76e+03 |
2.82e+03 5.03 2.81e+03 |
2.81e+03 7.93 2.80e+03 |
2.81e+03 3.43 2.80e+03 |
2.81e+03 4.25 2.80e+03 |
2.84e+03 7.81 2.82e+03 |
2.81e+03 5.06 2.80e+03 |
2.83e+03 6.36e+03 2.50e+03 |
2.82e+03 8.14 2.81e+03 |
| F20 |
avg sd bst |
2.91e+03 3.67e−02 2.91e+03 |
2.91e+03 1.69e+01 2.91e+03 |
2.94e+03 2.69e+01 2.91e+03 |
2.92e+03 1.29e+01 2.91e+03 |
2.91e+03 2.27 2.91e+03 |
2.91e+03 9.15e−01 2.91e+03 |
2.92e+03 1.58e+01 2.91e+03 |
2.91e+03 7.63e−02 2.91e+03 |
2.91e+03 8.91e−01 2.91e+03 |
Bold numbers in the table indicate superior values