Table 2.
Diagnostic index | Description of assessment | Benefits | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|
EASI | Validated scale utilizing 7-point assessment of disease extent in 4 defined body regions, with severity of 4 clinical signs on a 4-point scale, to a maximum score of 72 |
Evaluates both extent of eczema and lesion severity Good to fair intra-evaluator reliability |
Less sensitive in patients with very low %BSA Inter-evaluator variability lies in the dimension of induration/papulation Patient-reported symptoms are not evaluated |
SCORAD [65] | Clinically validated scale assesses disease extent based on the rule of 9s, intensity based on 6 clinical signs rated on a 4-point scale, plus patient-reported pruritus and sleep loss | Evaluates both BSA and lesion severity | Measures such as pruritus and sleep loss can be influenced by factors other than AD |
PO-SCORAD [99] | Patient self-assessment scale developed based on SCORAD criteria, but optimized for use by patients and their families by the inclusion of images and other assessment support |
Evaluates both BSA and lesion severity Patients can monitor AD symptoms between clinical consultations |
Measures such as pruritus and sleep loss can be influenced by factors other than AD |
BSA | Disease extent assessed as a percentage of total BSA |
Difficult to evaluate in patients with less severe lesions, especially in the presence of xerosis Does not assess lesion severity |
|
IGA [63] | 4 or 5-point scale of global disease severity based on morphological appearance of lesions, e.g., V-IGA, a validated global assessment score | Facilitates easy, rapid assessment of AD | No standardized ISGA, with variable definitions and implementations in clinical studies |
POEM [66, 100] | Validated score assessing 7 symptoms over the preceding 7 days using a 5-point scale system (to maximum of 35) |
Specifically developed for AD Scores are correlated with disease severity Appropriate to assess clinical trial populations Easily utilized in routine clinical practice Increasingly used in AD studies and clinical trials |
High utility in clinical studies but low utility in a dermatology clinic |
AD atopic dermatitis, BSA body surface area, EASI Eczema Area and Severity Index, IGA Investigator’s Global Assessment, ISGA Investigator’s Static Global Assessment, POEM Patient-Oriented Eczema Measure, PO-SCORAD Patient-Oriented SCORing Atopic Dermatitis, SCORAD SCORing Atopic Dermatitis