Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: Transplant Cell Ther. 2022 Mar 11;28(6):294–302. doi: 10.1016/j.jtct.2022.03.006

Table 1.

Characteristics of the 19 Studies Included in the Systematic Review

CHARACTERISTICS NO. OF STUDIES (N=19) REFERENCES
Year Published
2017–2019 6 Gust 2017,9 Gofshteyn 201828, Santomasso 201810, Shalabi 201820, Karschnia 20198, Rubin 201912
2020–2022 17 Belin 202021, Cordeiro 202013, Gajra 202033, Maziara 202032, Ruark 202014, Rubin 202024, Sokolov 202029, Strati 202022, Wudhikarn 202030, Gust 202123, Holtzman 202131, Brown 202134, Maillet 202125, Yuen 202135, Greenbaum 202126, Beuchat 202236, Wudhikarn 202127
Sample Size
< 50 7 Shalabi 201820, Karschnia 20198, Ruark 202014, Sokolov 202029, Holtzman 202131, Brown 202134, Yuen 202135
50–99 8 Gofshteyn 201828, Santomasso 201810, Belin 202021, Cordeiro 202013, Wudhikarn 202030, Maillet 202125, Beuchat 202236, Wudhikarn 202127
100–199 6 Gust 2017,9 Rubin 201912, Maziara 202032, Strati 202022, Gust 202123, Greenbaum 202126
≥200 2 Rubin 202024, Gajra 202033
Age
Pediatric and young adult cohort (mean, SD)* 4 Gofshteyn 2018 (11.5y, 4.3)28, Shalabi 2018 (17.9y, 6.9)20, Gust 2021 (cEEG-14.3y, 7.5; rEEG- 10.7y, 8.2)23, Brown 202134
Adult cohort (mean, SD)* 15 Gust 2017,9 Santomasso 201810, Karschnia 2019 (56y, 16.3)8, Rubin 2019 (54.6y, 12.3)12, Belin 2020 (51.7y, 12.8)21, Cordeiro 2020 (51.7y, 11.5)13, Gajra 202033, Maziara 202032, Ruark 2020 (51.3y, 12.3)14, Rubin 2020 (60y,12.5)24, Sokolov 202029, Strati 2020 (54.3y, 14.4)22, Wudhikarn 2020 (55.7y, 15.5)30, Holtzman 2021(53.7y, 12.2)31, Maillet 2021(58y,14)25, Yuen 202135, Greenbaum 202126, Beuchat 2022 (60y, 11)36, Wudhikarn 202127
Study Design
prospective cohort 8 Gust 2017,9 Santomasso 201810,Shalabi 201820, Belin 202021, Rubin 202024, Strati 202022, Gust 202123, Maillet 202125, Greenbaum 202126, Wudhikarn 202127
retrospective cohort 9 Gofshteyn 201828, Karschnia 20198, Cordeiro 202013, Gajra 202033, Maziara 202032, Sokolov 202029, Wudhikarn 202030, Holtzman 202131, Brown 202134, Yuen 202135, Beuchat 202236
mixed prospective and retrospective cohort 1 Rubin 201912
cross-sectional 1 Ruark 202014
Cancer Type
Diffuse large B-Cell lymphoma (DLBCL) 11 Shalabi 201820, Belin 202021, Gajra 202033, Strati 202022, Wudhikarn 202030, Holtzman 202131, Brown 202134, Maillet 202125, Yuen 202135, Greenbaum 202126, Wudhikarn 202127
Acute lymphocytic leukemia (ALL) 8 Gofshteyn 201828, Santomasso 201810,Shalabi 201820, Cordeiro 202013, Ruark 202014, Sokolov 202029, Brown 202134, Beuchat 202236
Non-Hodgkins lymphoma (NHL) 4 Cordeiro 202013, Maziara 202032, Ruark 202014, Sokolov 202029
Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) 4 Karschnia 20198, Cordeiro 202013, Ruark 202014, Sokolov 202029
Lymphoma (not classified) 4 Gust 2017,9 Rubin 201912, Rubin 202024, Beuchat 202236
Leukemia (not classified) 2 Rubin 201912, Rubin 202024
Follicular Lymphoma 2 Belin 202021, Sokolov 202029
Hepatocellular Carcinoma 1 Karschnia 20198
Multiple Myeloma 1 Beuchat 202236
Sarcoma 1 Rubin 201912
CAR-T Cell Target
CD19 17 Gust 2017,9 Gofshteyn 201828, Santomasso 201810, Karschnia 20198, Belin 202021, Cordeiro 202013, Gajra 202033, Maziara 202032, Ruark 202014, Rubin 202024, Sokolov 202029, Strati 202022, Wudhikarn 202030, Gust 202123, Holtzman 202131, Brown 202134, Maillet 202125, Yuen 202135, Greenbaum 202126, Beuchat 202236, Wudhikarn 202127
CD22 1 Shalabi 201820
BCMA 1 Yuen 202135
Not indicated 1 Rubin 201912
CAR-T Product
Axicabtagene ciloleucel 3 Rubin 202024, Strati 202022, Holtzman 202131
Tisagenlecleucel 2 Gofshteyn 201828, Maziara 202032
Axicabtagene ciloleucel and Tisagenlecleucel 4 Gajra 202033, Belin 202021, Wudhikarn 202030, Brown 202134
*

Mean and SD was calculated using formula by McGrath et al using minimum, maximum and median when mean was not provided.8,1214,2123,28,30,31 Mean used when provided.20,24,25