Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Jun 15.
Published in final edited form as: J Chem Theory Comput. 2022 May 10;18(6):3654–3670. doi: 10.1021/acs.jctc.2c00230

Table 1.

Parameterization Results, RRMS, and Molecular Dipole/Quadrupole Moments of Water Fitted with Four Electrostatic Modelsa

RESP RESP-ind RESP-
perm
RESP-
perm-v
QM
Charges/a.u.
H 0.3401 0.5182 0.7576 0.7441
O −0.6802 −1.0365 −1.5151 −1.4882
Permanent Dipole Moments/a.u.
H–Oa 0.0753 0.0773
O–Ha −0.2761b −0.2577
H–Ha −0.0121
RRMS
0.2051 0.1244 0.0391 0.0404
Dipole Moments/Debye
μ c 1.9141 1.9417 1.8668 1.8660 1.8470
Quadrupole Moments/Debye Angstroms
Qxx d 1.0444 1.5151 1.8549 1.8803 1.8389
Qyy d −0.1858 −0.3198 −0.2467 −0.2841 −0.2418
Qzz d −0.8586 −1.1953 −1.6082 −1.5962 −1.5971
a

Each permanent dipole moment pABloc is named in the format A–B, corresponding to the CBV points from atom A to atom B.

b

Negative value indicates pointing in the reverse direction of CBV.

c

Dipole moment relative to the center of mass.

d

Quadrupole moments along the principal axes.