Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 2;10:868928. doi: 10.3389/fbioe.2022.868928

TABLE 1.

Outline of the gait event identification methods adopted in this study.

Feature Marker trajectory References Method Component Initial contact detection Final contact detection
Position mHEEL, mTOE, and mPELVIS Zeni et al. (2008) M1 AP Local maxima of mHEELAP from mPELVIS Local minima of mTOEAP from mPELVIS
mHEEL and mTOE Desailly et al. (2009) M2 AP First maximum between high pass filtered mHEELAP and mTOEAP Last minimum between high pass filtered mHEELAP and mTOEAP
Velocity Mid-point between mHEEL and mTOE O’Connor et al. (2007) M3 V Local minima Local maxima
Additional constraints: timing constraints, and threshold on vertical marker position Additional constraint: timing constraints
mHEEL and mTOE Ghoussayni et al. (2004) M4 AP and V Sagittal vHEEL lower than 0.5 m/s a Sagittal vTOE higher than 0.5 m/s a
Enhanced M4 M5 3D Rearfoot contacts: 3D vHEEL lower than 0.5 m/s b 3D vTOE higher than 1.0 m/s and then refined when the vHEEL decreases after its local peak b
Forefoot contacts: 3D vTOE lower than 0.5 m/s
M4 modified as suggested by Bruening and Ridge (2014) M6 AP and V Sagittal vHEEL lower than 0.78 * walking speed c Sagittal vTOE higher than 0.66 * walking speed c
Enhanced M6 M7 3D Rearfoot contacts: 3D vHEEL lower than 0.5 * walking speed b 3D vTOE higher than 0.8 * walking speed c and then refined when the vHEEL decreases after its local peak b
Forefoot contacts: 3D vHEEL lower than 0.8 * walking speed b , c
Acceleration mHEEL and mTOE Hreljac and Marshall (2000) M8 AP and V Local maxima of aHEELV Local maxima of aTOEAP
Additional constraints: relevant jerk is null Additional constraints: relevant jerk is null
mHEEL and mTOE Hsue et al. (2007) M9 AP and V Local minima of aHEELAP Local maxima of aTOEAP
Position and velocity mHEEL, mTOE, and mPELVIS Combination of M1 and M7 M10 3D Events initially detected using M1 and then refined according to the M7 conditions Events initially detected using M1 and then refined according to the M7 conditions
a

Velocity threshold increased from 0.1 m/s to 0.5 m/s as suggested in Bruening and Ridge ( 2014).

b

Velocity thresholds adapted to the observed 3D velocities.

c

Walking speed calculated for each test as the average stride speed; initial contacts detected with the method M5.