TABLE 1.
Feature | Marker trajectory | References | Method | Component | Initial contact detection | Final contact detection |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Position | mHEEL, mTOE, and mPELVIS | Zeni et al. (2008) | M1 | AP | Local maxima of mHEELAP from mPELVIS | Local minima of mTOEAP from mPELVIS |
mHEEL and mTOE | Desailly et al. (2009) | M2 | AP | First maximum between high pass filtered mHEELAP and mTOEAP | Last minimum between high pass filtered mHEELAP and mTOEAP | |
Velocity | Mid-point between mHEEL and mTOE | O’Connor et al. (2007) | M3 | V | Local minima | Local maxima |
Additional constraints: timing constraints, and threshold on vertical marker position | Additional constraint: timing constraints | |||||
mHEEL and mTOE | Ghoussayni et al. (2004) | M4 | AP and V | Sagittal vHEEL lower than 0.5 m/s a | Sagittal vTOE higher than 0.5 m/s a | |
Enhanced M4 | M5 | 3D | Rearfoot contacts: 3D vHEEL lower than 0.5 m/s b | 3D vTOE higher than 1.0 m/s and then refined when the vHEEL decreases after its local peak b | ||
Forefoot contacts: 3D vTOE lower than 0.5 m/s | — | |||||
M4 modified as suggested by Bruening and Ridge (2014) | M6 | AP and V | Sagittal vHEEL lower than 0.78 * walking speed c | Sagittal vTOE higher than 0.66 * walking speed c | ||
Enhanced M6 | M7 | 3D | Rearfoot contacts: 3D vHEEL lower than 0.5 * walking speed b | 3D vTOE higher than 0.8 * walking speed c and then refined when the vHEEL decreases after its local peak b | ||
Forefoot contacts: 3D vHEEL lower than 0.8 * walking speed b , c | — | |||||
Acceleration | mHEEL and mTOE | Hreljac and Marshall (2000) | M8 | AP and V | Local maxima of aHEELV | Local maxima of aTOEAP |
Additional constraints: relevant jerk is null | Additional constraints: relevant jerk is null | |||||
mHEEL and mTOE | Hsue et al. (2007) | M9 | AP and V | Local minima of aHEELAP | Local maxima of aTOEAP | |
Position and velocity | mHEEL, mTOE, and mPELVIS | Combination of M1 and M7 | M10 | 3D | Events initially detected using M1 and then refined according to the M7 conditions | Events initially detected using M1 and then refined according to the M7 conditions |
Velocity threshold increased from 0.1 m/s to 0.5 m/s as suggested in Bruening and Ridge ( 2014).
Velocity thresholds adapted to the observed 3D velocities.
Walking speed calculated for each test as the average stride speed; initial contacts detected with the method M5.