TABLE 3.
Classification results of the SNN in iEEG, ECoG and scalp EEG.
Classification task and EEG modality | Seizure outcome prediction in patients implanted with iEEG. (HFO area resected →seizure freedom; HFO area not resected → seizure recurrence) | Seizure outcome prediction in patients implanted with ECoG. (max HFO rate ≥ 1 HFO/min → seizure recurrence; max HFO rate < 1 HFO/min → seizure freedom) | Active epilepsy prediction (seizures/month > 0) using scalp EEG recordings from pediatric patients (mean HFO rate > 0.25 HFO/min → active epilepsy; HFO rate < 0.25 HFO/min → seizure freedom) | ||||
|
|||||||
SNN architecture used for HFO detection | Morphology detector | Core SNN in Brian 2 | DYNAP-SE hardware | Spectrum detector | Core SNN + in-band artifact rejection SNN in Brian 2 | Spectrum detector | Core SNN + in-band artifact rejection SNN + artifact detection SNN in Brian 2 |
Specificity = TN/(TN + FP) | 100 (54 100%) | 100 (54 100%) | 100 (54 100%) | 100 (63 100%) | 100 (63 100%) | 67 (57 98%) | 100 (69 100%) |
Sensitivity = TP/(TP + FN) | 0 (0 71%) | 33 (1 91%) | 33 (1 91%) | 100 (63 100%) | 100 (63 100%) | 86 (57 98%) | 71 (42 92%) |
Negative Predictive Value = TN/(TN + FN) | 67 (30 93%) | 75 (35 97%) | 75 (35 97%) | 100 (63 100%) | 100 (63 100%) | 67 (22 96%) | 71 (42 92%) |
Positive Predictive Value = TP/(TP + FP) | – | 100 (3 100%) | 100 (3 100%) | 100 (63 100%) | 100 (63 100%) | 86 (57 98%) | 100 (69 100%) |
Accuracy = (TP + TN)/N (%) | 67 (30 93%) | 78 (40 97%) | 78 (40 97%) | 100 (63 100%) | 100 (63 100%) | 85 (62 97%) | 80 (56 94%) |
TP True Positive; TN True Negative; FP False Positive; FN False Negative; N = TP + TN + FP + FN = number of patients.
To find HFO in the iEEG dataset, we first used the SNN simulator Brian 2 and the toolbox Teili (Milde, 2018), to simulate our SNN and then we mapped the SNN in hardware using the neuromorphic processor DYNAP-SE (Moradi et al., 2018).
The numbers in brackets are the 95% confidence intervals (CI).