Table 4.
Trait | Trait description | Trait class | Timea | Year 1b | Year 2 | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Field study | |||||||
HT | Plot height | Stem growth | 1, 2 | −0.82 | *** | −0.53 | ** |
STN | Stem number | Stem growth | 1 | −0.41 | * | – | n.s. |
MDIA | Mean stem diameter | Stem growth | 1, 2 | −0.47 | * | −0.40 | * |
DIA | Stem diameter | Stem growth | 1, 2 | −0.54 | ** | −0.51 | ** |
MSA | Mean stem area | Stem growth | 1 | −0.41 | * | – | n.s. |
SA | Stem area | Stem growth | 1, 2 | −0.51 | ** | −0.47 | * |
VOL | Stem volume | Stem growth | 1, 2 | −0.53 | ** | −0.52 | ** |
LFL | Leaf length | Leaf growth | 2 | – | n.s. | 0.45 | * |
LFP | Leaf perimeter | Leaf growth | 2 | – | n.s. | 0.5 | ** |
LFR | Leaf ratio | Leaf growth | 2 | – | n.s. | 0.42 | * |
LFF | Leaf shape factor | Leaf growth | 2 | – | n.s. | −0.51 | ** |
SLA | Specific leaf area | Leaf growth | 1 | 0.58 | ** | n.s. | |
CDIA | Basal crown diameter | Architecture | 1, 2 | −0.40 | * | −0.65 | *** |
FORM | Crown form | Architecture | 1, 2 | 0.46 | * | 0.65 | *** |
DEN | Wood density | Composition | 2 | – | n.s. | −0.41 | * |
DVOL | Wood density × stem volume | Biomass | 1, 2 | −0.56 | ** | −0.58 | ** |
Greenhouse study | |||||||
SDW | Stem dry mass | Biomass | 70 | −0.52 | ** | ||
LDW | Leaf dry mass | Biomass | 70 | −0.57 | ** | ||
RDW | Root dry mass | Biomass | 70 | −0.73 | *** | ||
AGB | Aboveground dry mass | Biomass | 70 | −0.56 | ** | ||
TBM | Total dry mass | Biomass | 70 | −0.65 | *** | ||
HT | Plot height | Stem growth | 42, 21–56 | −0.68 | *** | ||
MSL | Mean stem length | Stem growth | 42, 21–56 | −0.60 | *** | ||
TSL | Total stem length | Stem growth | 42, 21–56 | −0.59 | ** | ||
SA | Stem area | Stem growth | 70 | −0.48 | ** | ||
VOL | Stem volume | Stem growth | 70 | −0.60 | *** | ||
SLA | Specific leaf area | Leaf growth | 70 | 0.31 | * | ||
PHE | Vegetative phenology | Leaf growth | 11, 13 | −0.52 | ** | ||
SPAD | Chlorophyll content | Leaf growth | 14 | −0.39 | * |
Time in years since coppice (field study) or days after planting (greenhouse study).
Asterisks ***, **, * denote significant at P-value < 0.001, P < 0.01, and P < 0.05, respectively.