Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 20;22:800. doi: 10.1186/s12913-022-08194-w

Table 1.

Characteristics of the included studies and frequencies of occurrence of defensive medicine

Authors/Publication year Country Study population Study design Sampling methods Sample size (n) Occurrence (%)
Passmore et al./2002 [27] England Psychiatrists Postal survey Census 154 75.0
Studdert et al./2005 [14] USA Emergency medicine, General surgery, Orthopedic surgery, Neurosurgery, Obstetrics/ Gynecology, and Radiology Mail survey Randomly 824 93.0
Hiyama et al./2006 [18] Japan Gastroenterologists Survey Randomly 131 98.0
Asher et al./ 2012 [28] Israel Internal medicine, Pediatrics, General surgery, Family medicine, Obstetrics/ gynecology, Orthopedic surgery, Cardiology, and Neurosurgery Survey Randomly 889 60.0
Nahed et al./2012 [29] USA Neurosurgeons National online survey NS 1028 36.0–72.0
Elli et al./ 2013 [30] Italy Gastroenterologists Survey NS 107 94.0
Ortashi et al./2013 [31] UK Medicine, Surgery, Obstetrics /Gynecology, Pediatrics Survey Convenience 204 78.0
Sathiyakumar et al. /2013 [32] USA Orthopedic (trauma and non-trauma) National Survey Randomly 1214 84.0–86.0
He et al./ 2014 [33] China Internal Medicine, Surgery, Obstetrics/Gynecology, Pediatrics Survey Randomly 504 80.6
Moosazadeh et al./ 2014 [17] Iran General practitioners Survey Census 423 79.2–99.8
Solaroglu et al./2014 [21] Turkey Neurosurgeons Survey NS 404 72.0
Ramella et al./ 2015 [34] Italy Radiation oncology Survey NS 361 75.0
Reisch et al./2015 [19] USA Breast pathologists National online survey NS 252 88.0
Ali et al./2016 [20] Sudan Obstetrics/Gynecology National Survey NS 117 71.8.0
Panella et al./2016 [35] Italy General Surgeons, Anesthesiologists, Internists, Pediatricians, Psychiatrics, Emergency, Radiologists, Cardiologists, Urologists, Pathologists, Neurologists, Rehabilitation Doctors National online survey Randomly 1313 59.7
Silberstein et al./2016 [23] Israel Plastic and Aesthetic Surgery Prospective survey NS 78 51.3
Yan et al./2016 [36] Canada, South Africa, USA Neurosurgery Online survey NS 1142 64.5–89.1
Din et al./2017 [37] USA Neurosurgery Online survey NS 1026 84.6–89.2
Panella et al./2017 [12] Italy Physicians National survey Randomly 1313 59.8
Reuveni et al./2017 [22] Israel Psychiatrists Survey NS 213 62.1
Yan et al./2017 [38] Netherlands Neurosurgeons National online survey NS 45 6.7–64.4
Tebano et al./2018 [39] 74 countries Infectious diseases and Clinical microbiology doctors International online survey NS 830 76.0–85.0
Zhu et al./2018 [15] China Obstetrics/Gynecology National online Survey NS 1486 62.9
Al-Atram et al./2018 [40] 9 Middle Eastern countries Psychiatrists Survey NS 92 30.0
Renkema et al./2019 [41] Netherlands Anesthesiology, Colon, stomach and liver diseases, Gynecology, Internal medicine, Neurology, and Surgery Electronic Survey NS 214 42.0–89.0
Borgan et al./2020 [42] USA Internal Medicine Residents Online survey Convenience 49 40.0–91.3
Calikoglu et al./2020 [2] Turkey Anesthesia, Obstetrics/Gynecology, Ear Nose Throat Physician, General Surgery, Urology, Eye Diseases, Orthopedics, Cardiovascular, Surgery, Neurosurgery, Plastic surgery, Thoracic, and Pediatric Survey All practicing physicians 190 94.2

USA United States of America, UK United Kingdom, NS Not Stated, UAE Unite Arab Emirates