Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 21;8:82. doi: 10.1186/s40798-022-00472-5

Table 1.

Studies included within meta-analysis and systematic review

Authors Participants (training status) Type of activity during the trials Performance measure Experimental beverage Control beverage Primary outcomes Results
Rowe et al. 2021 [31]* 11 M (well-trained) 120 min treadmill running at 68%V˙O2max 5 km time trial 1.5 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose + SA + P 1.5 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose Performance, substrate oxidation, blood metabolites

Sig faster time trial and higher CHO oxidation

No difference in plasma glucose concentration, lactate or NEFAs

Pettersson et al. 2020 [27] 12 (sex not reported, endurance-trained) 180 min cycling at 55% Wmax None 1.6 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose + SA + P

(1) 1.6 g min−1

Vitargo Pure® + Vitargo electrolyte® (starch + electrolytes) + amylopectin

(2) 1.6 g min−1

Isostar Endurance Plus® (Maltodextrin + sucrose)

Oral health, ExCHO oxidation, substrate oxidation, blood metabolites

Sig higher ExCHO oxidation with experimental beverage

Sig lower blood glucose concentration 40 min after cessation of CHO feeding with experimental beverage

Attenuated decline in teeth pH

McCubbin et al. 2020 [24]* 9 M (recreational and elite) 180 min cycling at 60%V˙O2max Time to exhaustion 1.5 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose + SA + P 1.5 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose Performance, substrate oxidation, blood metabolites No sig differences
Flood et al. 2020 [29]* 7 M, 7 F (recreational) 90 min cycling at 45% V˙O2max in 32 °C and 70% relative humidity Work completed in 15 min 1.5 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose + SA + P 1.5 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose Performance, substrate oxidation, blood metabolites, intestinal integrity

No sig difference in performance, substrate oxidation, performance or intestinal integrity

Greater gut discomfort with experimental beverage

Myrick et al. 2019 [32] 1 (sex and training status not reported) Treadmill running at 12 min mile−1 until exhaustion Time to exhaustion Microgel dispersion + 39 g glucose Commercial sports drink containing 39 dextrose AUC blood glucose absorption kinetics Higher AUC glucose absorption kinetics with microgel dispersion
Mears et al. 2019 [25]* 8 M (well-trained) 120 min cycling at 55% WMax Time to complete set work 1.1 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose + SA + P 1.1 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose Performance, substrate oxidation, blood metabolites

No sig difference in performance

Sig higher RPE and stomach fullness with experimental beverage

Barber et al. 2019 [28]* 9 M (trained) 120 min treadmill running at 60%V˙O2max None 1.5 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose + SA + P 1.5 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose ExCHO oxidation, substrate oxidation, blood metabolites No sig differences
Pettersson et al. 2019 [33] 12 (6 M, 6 F, trained) 120 min treadmill skiing 69% V˙O2max in − 5 °C 2400 m (males) or 2000 m (females) time trial 2.2 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose + SA + P Non-caloric placebo (sweetened water) Performance, ExCHO oxidation, substrate oxidation, blood metabolites Sig higher ExCHO, total CHO oxidation and sig lower fat oxidation with experimental beverage. No sig diff in performance
Baur et al. 2019 [26]* 9 M (trained) 98 min varied intensity cycling 10 maximal sprints 1.3 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose + SA + P 1.3 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose Performance, substrate ox, blood metabolites No sig differences
Sutehall et al. [30]* 8 M (well-trained) 105 min treadmill running 70%V˙O2max None 1.2 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose + SA + P

(1) 1.2 g min−1 maltodextrin + fructose

(2) Water

ExGluc oxidation, substrate oxidation, blood metabolites No sig differences

M, male; F, female; V˙O2max, maximal oxygen uptake; %WMax, percentage of max Watts; SA, sodium alginate; P, pectin; ExCHO oxidation, exogenous carbohydrate oxidation rate; ExGluc oxidation, exogenous glucose oxidation rate; AUC, area under the curve

*Included within meta-analysis