Table 1.
Mental health predictions and outcome data to date.
prediction | outcome |
---|---|
‘The current pandemic increases the risk for suicide in at least four ways that require a far greater investment in suicide science, along with new approaches to suicide screenings and imminent risk assessments across all types of clinical care'. | COVID did not lead to an increase in suicide [32–36]. According to Aknin et al. [32, para. 7], ‘real-time data from official government sources in 21 countries showed no detectable increase in instances of suicide from April to July 2020, relative to previous years; in fact, suicide rates actually declined slightly within some countries, including the USA'. |
‘Social isolation and ongoing media coverage focusing on social-environmental threat may result in increased rumination and worry that drive biological processes such as inflammation. Social isolation and stay-at-home orders also may interfere with the ability to experience positive affect, apply social strategies for regulating affect, and use rewarding experiences to offset negative emotions'. | There were only modest changes in people's ratings of loneliness and social connectedness [37–40]. |
‘It is thus reasonable to assume that the pandemic will be associated with a substantial, sustained, and potentially severe “mental health curve” that, like the prevalence of the virus itself, will also need flattening'. | There is no evidence of a full-blown mental health crisis [29]. Ratings of life satisfaction did not decrease [32,41]; the average satisfaction rating for the COVID year was identical to the previous year. |
‘Many adolescents have increased their already remarkably frequent use of digital media to compensate for the loss of in-person social interactions, yet emerging research suggests that digitally mediated social interactions may be distinct in form and psychological function from face-to-face experiences'. | Digital technology use during COVID-19 was not associated with depressive and anxious symptoms or suicidal ideation at the within- or between-person levels [42,43]. Also, there was a general downward trend over the course of the pandemic in pornography use [44]. |
‘Anxiety and depressive symptoms are likely to increase during the COVID-19 pandemic…the COVID-19 pandemic is also likely to precipitate substantial increases in depression'. | Despite disruptions in school and greater social isolation, adolescents did not report increases in suicidal thinking [45] and their levels of depression and anxiety were fairly stable [46]. There was even some evidence that teens have experienced decreases in depression and loneliness during the pandemic [47]. |
‘Older adults are uniquely vulnerable during COVID-19, both physically and psychosocially. This abrupt physical threat and loss of social resources may increase risk for loneliness, isolation, and depression among older adults'. | The elderly did not report the greatest increase in mental health symptoms [45]. A number of studies showed that negative mental health symptoms were less prevalent in older adults than younger adults [38,42,48]. |
Omission of prediction in this case. This finding was not anticipated. | Young females with children under 5 years of age reported the most mental health distress [49–51]. |