Skip to main content
. 2022 May 4;11:7. doi: 10.4103/jos.jos_152_21

Table 4.

Risk of bias assessment

Study Randomization of specimens Prior Sample size calculation Similar size specimens Manufactures’ instruction followed Intervention defined Control groups defined statistical analysis considered Blinding of observer Loss of any specimen reported All possible outcome reported Overall risk of bias assessment
Redlich et al. (2008)[13] No No Unclear NI Yes Yes Yes NI No Yes Moderate
Samorodnitzky et al. (2009)[14] No No Unclear NI Yes Yes No NI No No High
Muguruma et al. (2011)[15] No No Yes NI Yes Yes Yes NI No Yes Moderate
Krishnan et al. (2012)[16] No No Yes NI Yes Yes Yes NI No Yes Moderate
Kang et al. (2015)[17] No No Yes NI Yes Unclear Yes NI No Yes Moderate
Zhang et al. (2016)[18] No No Yes NI Yes Yes Yes NI No Yes Moderate
Behroozian et al. (2016)[19] No No Yes NI Yes Yes Yes NI No Yes Moderate
Shah et al. (2018)[20] No Yes Yes NI Yes Yes Yes NI No Yes Low
Gracco et al. (2019)[21] No No Yes NI Yes Yes Yes NI No Yes Moderate

No- not taken into consideration/insufficient information; Yes- sufficient information provided regarding the specified domain; NI- no information provided regarding the specific domain