Advantages and difficulties of peptides, small molecules and therapeutic proteins in drug development1–6.
Small molecules | Peptides | Therapeutic proteins | |
---|---|---|---|
MW < 500 Da | MW ∼ 500–5000 Da | MW > 5000 Da | |
Advantages | • Low cost in production and price on market | • Automated synthesis | • Very high target affinity, potency, specificity and selectivity due to large interaction site |
• Ease of synthesis | • High target affinity, potency, specificity and selectivity | • Long half life | |
• Membrane permeability achievable, oral bioavailability and intracellular targets accessible | • No toxic metabolites | • Drug safety, no toxic metabolites | |
• Known guidelines for drug design, Lipinski rule of 5 | • Chemical synthesis enables easy structure modifications | ||
Difficulties | • Often hepatic metabolism via CYP enzymes: prone to drug–drug interactions | • Proteolytic instabilitya | • Expensive in production and on market |
• Drug safety issues due to non-mechanistic-based toxicology (low affinity or selectivity) | • Rapid clearance, short half-lifea | • Complex (often recombinant) production, no easy chemical modification | |
• Targets with need for large interaction sites precluded | • Low membrane permeabilitya due to high polarity, no intracellular targets, no CNS targets, no oral absorption | • Immunogenicity | |
• No guidelines for rational drug design | • No/low membrane permeability due to size, parenteral administration (s.c./i.v.), only extracellular or surface-exposed targets | ||
• Chemically and physically unstable, elaborated storage (sensitive to heat, pH, oxidation) |
Chemically unmodified peptides.