Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 16;9:100028. doi: 10.1016/j.iotech.2021.100028

Table 1.

A key summary of the advantages and disadvantages of the different features

Advantages Disadvantages
Semantics
  • -

    More easily understandable to humans

  • -

    Many semantic features are already included in the radiological workup of specific tumour types

  • -

    Requires an experienced reader to generate and interpret

  • -

    Vulnerable to inter- and intra-observer variability

  • -

    Limited (dimensionality)

Handcrafted radiomics
  • -

    Many features represent intuitive morphological features

  • -

    Features encode morphological information beyond the limits of the human eye

  • -

    Clear process pipeline

  • -

    When the feature extraction is performed expertly, artificial intelligence trained on handcrafted radiomic features can perform just as well as deep learning, especially in smaller datasets

  • -

    Requires less data than deep learning

  • -

    Algorithms contain human bias

  • -

    Delineation is required

  • -

    Influenced by different parameters (scanning equipment, pre-processing, scanning protocol)

Deep learning radiomics
  • -

    Order of magnitude more features

  • -

    No pre-engineered algorithms

  • -

    Often no expert delineation required

  • -

    Can create automatic segmentation

  • -

    Fully automated

  • -

    Greater accuracy in specific tasks compared with traditional computer vision techniques

  • -

    Requires a significant number of samples for training

  • -

    Publically available high-quality well-annotated data in medicine is scarce

  • -

    Black box