Table 2.
Points of comparison between chemical and enzymatic esterification reaction
Characteristics | Chemical | Enzymatic |
---|---|---|
Type of catalyst | Chemical catalyst like sulphuric acid, hydrochloric acid, sodium methoxide, para-toluene sulphonic acid etc | Lipases from animal, plant and microorganisms |
Temperature | Reaction is usually carried out at higher temperature (150–200 °C) | Reaction is carried out at moderate temperature below 50 °C |
Bi-product formation | Many undesirable by-products are formed and hence product needs purification | Insignificant or no by-products are formed |
Eco-friendly | No, since it produces many by-products which are toxic in nature | Yes, it is cleaner and eco-friendly |
Challenges | It produces toxic products and final product is dark in color hence processes like bleaching, deodorization, purification is necessary | Little change in temperature, pH of reaction medium affects the activity of enzyme |
Rate of reaction | Rate of reaction is faster; hence less time is required for completion of reaction | Rate of reaction is very slow; hence more time is required for completion of reaction |
Economical aspect | Chemical catalyst are inexpensive, hence the process is economical as compared with enzymatic process | Enzymes are very expensive, which increases the cost of production |