Table 3.
Methodological Assessment of Qualitative Studies.
Qualitative interview studies (n = 3) | |||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study ID | Population | Method | Design/analysis | Setting | Aim(s) | Participant(s) | Sample size | Inclusion/exclusion criteria | Duration of treatment (follow-up) | Results | Funding |
Clerici et al 49 | Magic tricks as support to psychological approaches for children with cancer | Psychological interviews with pediatric patients | Qualitative design. Descriptive study of consultations with patients. | Hospital setting | Describe illusionist techniques (magic), suggest utility, and arouse interest | Children who underwent cancer treatment younger than 10 y of age | n = 30 | Children’s difficulty adapting to disease and treatment; relational problems with the hospital team; stressful treatments; problems with compliance to treatment, emotional distress; adaptation problems in survivors; terminal disease; relational problems in the family; psychological problems; psychopathologic conditions | NR | The use of magic in the context of pediatric oncology can represent a useful resource as a complement to traditional psychological support approaches | This study did not receive any funding |
Hu et al 43 | Childhood cancer and acupressure for well-being and positive emotions | Semi-structured interviews lasting 60 to 90 min, and participant observation of the acupuncture sessions | Qualitative design. Interviews were transcribed verbatim. Data were analyzed using grounded theory symbolic (interactionism and phenomenology). | This study was nested within a clinical trial testing the effect of acupressure on children being treated for cancer | Explore whether and how acupressure, when provided by a professional or trained caregiver, was perceived as eliciting a sense of well-being | Acupressure providers (n = 3); primary caregivers of children with cancer (n = 13) | Total sample (n = 16) | Caregivers of children 5 to 21 y of age receiving hospital-based cancer treatment, who have demonstrated engagement in the acupuncture intervention were asked to participate. Caregivers who had a minimal interest were not asked. | NR | Acupressure brought symptom relief, physical relaxation, and comfort to the child and caregiver | Patient-centered outcomes research institute: Pierre’s birthday fund; the National cancer institute: the National center for complementary and alternative medicine |
Nilsson et al 46 * (qualitative arm) | Non-immersive virtual reality (VR) for painful procedures | Semi-structured interviews with 21 children and adolescents following the completion of the intervention. Median time for the interviews was 8.5 min | Qualitative design. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and analyzed using a qualitative content analysis. | This was a qualitative arm nested within a clinical trial testing VR for painful procedures | Examine the participants’ response to the use of VP equipment during painful procedures | Children and adolescents with cancer (n = 21) | Total sample (n = 21) | Children and adolescents 5 to 18 y old, who have undergone painful procedures at least once before | During needle procedures | These interviews showed that non-immersive VR was a positive experience for children undergoing painful procedures | Children’s Cancer Foundation at the Queen Silvia Children’s Hospital, the Sigurd and Elsa Goljes Foundation, the Federation of Swedish County Councils (VG-region), the Ebba Danelius Foundation, and the Wilhelm and Martina Lundgrens Foundation |
Abbreviation: NR: not reported.