Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 3;9(6):830. doi: 10.3390/children9060830

Table A3.

Quality of reporting in qualitative studies according to the Comprehensive consolidated criteria for Reporting Qualitative research.

Fahner, 2020 [11] Feraco, 2018 [43] Finlay, 2008[45] Hartley, 2016[44] Noyes, 2013 (MM) [50] Kline, 2012 (MM) [46] Lyon, 2019 (MM) [47] Wiener, 2012 (MM) [48] Wiener, 2008 (MM) [49]
  • 1.

    Interviewer/facilitator

+/- + - +/- - +/- - - +
  • 2.

    Credentials

- + - - - - - + +
  • 3.

    Occupation

- - - - - - - - -
  • 4.

    Gender

- + - - - - - - -
  • 5.

    Experiences or training

- - - - - - +/- - +
  • 6.

    Relationships established

- - - - - - - - -
  • 7.

    Participant knowledge of the interviewer

- - - - - - - - -
  • 8.

    Interviewer characteristics

- - - - - - - - -
  • 9.

    Methodological orientation

+ + + + + + + - +
  • 10.

    Sampling

- + - + + - - - -
  • 11.

    Method of approach

- + - - + - - - -
  • 12.

    Sample size

+ + + + + + + + +
  • 13.

    Non-participation

- +/- - - + +/- +/- - +
  • 14.

    Setting of data collection

- +/- - - +/- - - - -
  • 15.

    Presence of non-participants

- - - - - - + - -
  • 16.

    Description of sample

+ + +/- - +/- + + + +
  • 17.

    Interview guide

- + - + +/- - + - +
  • 18.

    Repeat interview

- - - - - - - - +
  • 19.

    Audio-visual recording

+ + - + + + + - -
  • 20.

    Field notes

- - - - + - - - -
  • 21.

    Duration

- + - - - - + - +
  • 22.

    Data saturation

- - - + - - - - -
  • 23.

    Transcripts returned

- - - - - - - - -
  • 24.

    Number of data coders

- + - - - - - - -
  • 25.

    Description of coding three

- - - - - - - - -
  • 26.

    Derivation of themes

- + - + - - - - -
  • 27.

    Software

- + - - + - - - -
  • 28.

    Participant checking

- - + - - - - - -
  • 29.

    Quotations presented

+ + - + +/- +/- +/- +/- -
  • 30.

    Data and findings consistent

+ + +/- + + + - + +
  • 31.

    Clarity of major themes

+ + - + + - - - -
  • 32.

    Clarify of minor themes

+ - - - - - - - -
Total + 8.5 18 4 10.5 12 6 8.5 4.5 11

+ = criterion was properly described, one point was assigned; +/- = criterion was incompletely described, 0.5 points were assigned; - = criterion was not described, zero points were assigned.