Skip to main content
. 2022 May 30;10(6):1010. doi: 10.3390/healthcare10061010

Table 3.

Thematic analysis of open-ended responses to question 19: “Could you briefly explain why you referred a patient to a choir?” (89 answers).

Theme Occurrences Quote (Example of a Participant)
Targeted domains
Speech and voice 34 “To free his voice, (…) stimulate rhythm and voice projection” (P393)
Social ties 33 “to regain a social link” (P297)
Pleasure 15 “because I thought it was very important for the patient to rediscover the pleasure of singing in a group” (P167)
Language 14 “Because his language is more fluent in singing” (P25)
Well-being 11 “Continuity of the work done in speech-language therapy with the addition of a social, playful and well-being dimension” (P312)
Memory 8 “Patient in the early stage of Alzheimer’s disease seeking to maintain memory” (P304)
Communication 5 “It depends, it can be for a rather functional or rather communicational purpose, or mixed more often!” (P220)
Sense of identity 4 “Young patient (stroke) formerly a singer, with experience in choral singing, needing to restore her self-image and skills (…)” (P388)
Cognitive functions 2 “(…) Cognitive and language stimulation” (P5)
Favorable conditions for the success of this referral
Former choir singer 9 “these were patients who had already practiced choral singing before and who had stopped because of their disorders” (P177)
Singing benefits noticed 5 “Patient (…) showing clear signs of progress when using singing during sessions” (P12)
Available adapted choir 5 “Towards a choir set up by the clinic where I worked, in collaboration with France Parkinson (…)” (P43)
Likes to sing 3 “The patient already had an interest in singing, and liked to sing, so we thought that this would be a good activity” (P239)
Patient’s request 3 “Because patients were asking for more singing and had trouble doing it alone (…)” (P33)
Facilitated inclusion 2 “because I am part of this choir and it was easy for me to include them and enjoy the benefits of socialization” (P99)
Easy to set up 1 “Because easily set up” (P127)
Sufficient recovery 1 “It was a patient (…) who had progressed enough to feel comfortable again in a small country choir” (P229)
Complementary role to conventional speech-language therapy 16 “(…)to complete/enrich the care” (P73)
Disorders
Parkinson’s disease 11 “in a patient with Parkinson’s disease, to maintain skills acquired in rehabilitation” (P76)
Alzheimer’s disease 2 “For a young patient with Alzheimer’s disease in the early stage, the goal is to stimulate memory (…)” (P75)