Collagen matrix obtained from bladder submucosa |
Unseeded |
4–20 years |
Successful in 3 of 4 patients |
[47] |
Collagen matrix obtained from bladder submucosa |
Unseeded |
22–61 years |
Successful in 24 of 28 patients |
[79] |
BAM |
Unseeded |
21–59 years |
The success rate was 89% in the case of patients with only one or no previous interventions. The success rate was 33.3% in the case of patients with two or more previous operations. |
[80] |
SIS |
Unseeded |
3–18 years |
Seventy percent of patients were completely dry (85% in females and 43% in males). |
[116] |
SIS |
Unseeded |
61–68 years |
Unsuccessful, perhaps due to non-acellularity of SIS scaffold |
[87] |
SIS |
Unseeded |
20–74 years |
85% success |
[89] |
SIS |
Unseeded |
45–73 years |
80% success |
[90] |
SIS |
Unseeded |
1.5–15 years |
Nine of twelve patients voided normally. Six patients had no further interventions and three had small fistulae. In three patients the graft failed. |
[91] |
Acellular dermal matrix |
Seeded with bladder urothelium cells |
14–44 months |
All patients could void normally. Only one patient developed stricture. Two patients developed a fistula, and one developed an obstruction. |
[93] |
Acellular dermis matrix |
Seeded with UCs |
6–8 years |
Urinary flow curves were bell-shaped in all but one. Patients with severe hypospadias have high complication rates. |
[94] |
PTFE |
Unseeded |
1.5–14 years |
One patient developed fistula and all patients developed mild stenosis. |
[107] |
PGA:PLGA |
Seeded with UCs and SMCs |
10–14 years |
Scaffolds remained functional without fistula and urinary infections. |
[112] |