Table 1.
ICC for the coded evidence and scenarios in the written decisions.
| Category | ICC | 95% CI |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| lower bound | upper bound | ||
| Incriminating evidence | .949 | .906 | .972 |
| Neutral evidence | .581 | .340 | .751 |
| Exonerating evidence | .911 | .841 | .951 |
| Scenarios implicating Emma | .816 | .682 | .896 |
| Scenarios implicating James’ mistress | .859 | .752 | .921 |
| Scenarios implicating other perpetrators | .792 | .645 | .882 |
Note: ICC = intra-class correlation coefficient; CI = confidence interval.