Skip to main content
. 2021 May 13;301:113998. doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2021.113998

Table 1.

Characteristics of samples included in the meta-analysis.

Sample
Study
Geopolitics
Measures
N Sampletype Meanage Female% White% Design Status Country Regime type Democracy index Suicide Behaviors
Acharya et al. (2020) 14 clinical NR 4.16 NR longitudinal article India flawed democracy 6.90 attempts
Ammerman et al. (2020) 907 community 36.43 42.60 76.40 cross-sectional pre-print United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation attempts
Benatti et al. (2020) 79 clinical 39.95 44.30 NR cross-sectional article Italy flawed democracy 7.52 ideation
Benatti et al. (2020)a 44 clinical 39.75 45.50 NR cross-sectional article Italy flawed democracy 7.52 ideation
Bryan et al. (2020) 10,625 community 45.20 50.70 61.90 cross-sectional pre-print United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation attempts
Caballero-Dominguez et al. (2020) 700 community 37.10 68.00 NR cross-sectional article Colombia flawed democracy 7.13 ideation
Cai et al. (2020) 1173 frontline NR 69.80 NR case-control article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Cai et al. (2020) 1173 community 30.50 70.30 NR case-control article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Capuzzi et al. (2020) 225 clinical 44.20 48.40 NR longitudinal article Italy flawed democracy 7.52 attempts
Crasta et al. (2020) 1003 community 40.90 72.50 82.40 cross-sectional article United Statesb flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
Czeisler et al. (2020) 5412 community NR 50.90 63.10 cross-sectional article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
Dragovic et al. (2020) 654 clinical 39.50 54.60 NR longitudinal article Australia full democracy 9.09 ideation self-harm
Enos (2020) 1500 clinical NR NR NR cross-sectional newsletter United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
Every-Palmer et al. (2020) 2010 community NR 52.90 61.20 cross-sectional article New Zealand full democracy 9.26 ideation attempts
Feng et al. (2020) 671 frontline NR 53.90 NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Ferrando et al. (2020) 136 clinical 37.10 45.60 43.40 cross-sectional article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation attempts self-harm
Ferrando et al. (2020)c 65 clinical 13.80 58.50 35.40 cross-sectional article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation attempts self-harm
Fisher et al. (2020) 13,829 community NR 75.50 NR cross-sectional article Australia full democracy 9.09 ideation
Fitzpatrick et al. (2020) 10,368 community NR 51.00 60.40 cross-sectional article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
Graell et al. (2020) 365 clinical 14.62 87.95 NR longitudinal article Spain full democracy 8.29 ideation
Gratz et al. (2020) 500 community 40.00 47.00 85.00 cross-sectional article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
Hamm et al. (2020) 71 clinical 69.00 68.50 76.70 longitudinal article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
Hao et al. (2020) 76 clinical NR NR NR case-control article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Hao et al. (2020)e 185 community 33.10 NR NR case-control article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Hong et al. (2020) 4692 frontline NR 96.90 NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Hou et al. (2020) 527 community NR 0.00 NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation attempts
Hou et al. (2020)d 332 community NR 100.00 NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation attempts
Iob et al. (2020) 44,775 community NR 51.00 88.30 cross-sectional article UK full democracy 8.52 ideation self-harm
Jhanwar et al. (2020) 32 clinical 29.90 65.60 NR longitudinal article India flawed democracy 6.90 attempts
Killgore et al. (2020) 3120 community NR 54.20 NR longitudinal article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
Kim et al. (2020a) 72 frontline 39.20 75.00 NR cross-sectional article South Korea flawed democracy 8.00 ideation
Kim et al. (2020b) 33 clinical 45.00 NR NR cross-sectional article South Korea flawed democracy 8.00 ideation
Lewis (2020) 179 community NR NR NR longitudinal article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
Li et al. (2020) 1970 community 37.81 66.20 NR cross-sectional article Taiwan flawed democracy 7.73 ideation
Mamun et al. (2020a) 834 frontline 30.70 56.00 NR cross-sectional article Bangladesh hybrid regime 5.88 ideation
Mamun et al. (2020a)e 2554 community 29.60 50.40 NR cross-sectional article Bangladesh hybrid regime 5.88 ideation
Mamun et al. (2020b) 10,067 community 29.90 43.90 NR cross-sectional article Bangladesh hybrid regime 5.88 ideation
McAndrew et al. (2020) 152 clinical NR NR NR longitudinal article Ireland full democracy 9.24 ideation self-harm
McIntyre et al. (2020) 576 clinical NR NR NR longitudinal article Ireland full democracy 9.24 self-harm
Molina et al. (2020) 197 community NR NR NR cross-sectional article Cuba authoritarian 2.84 ideation
Nalleballe et al. (2020) 40,469 clinical NR 55.00 37.00 cross-sectional article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
O'Connor et al. (2020) 3077 community NR 55.10 90.50 longitudinal article UK full democracy 8.52 ideation attempts self-harm
Olding et al. (2020) 30 clinical 30.60 10.00 NR longitudinal article UK full democracy 8.52 self-harm
Pignon et al. (2020) 553 clinical NR 47.00 NR longitudinal article France full democracy 8.12 attempts
Ren et al. (2020) 1172 community 22.00 69.30 NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Saiz et al. (2020) 21,207 community 39.70 69.60 NR cross-sectional article Spain full democracy 8.29 ideation
Sharif et al. (2020) 375 frontline NR NR NR cross-sectional article NRf ideation
Smalley et al. (2020) 2477 clinical NR NR NR longitudinal article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
Staples et al. (2020) 5455 clinical 35.40 75.50 NR longitudinal article Australia full democracy 9.09 ideation
Talarowska et al. (2020) 443 community 31.90 78.60 NR cross-sectional article Poland flawed democracy 6.62 ideation
Tan et al. (2020) 673 community 30.80 25.60 NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Teksin et al. (2020) 452 frontline 35.80 66.20 NR cross-sectional article Turkey hybrid regime 4.09 ideation
Wang et al. (2020) 1994 community 22.88 61.64 NR cross-sectional article United States flawed democracy 7.96 ideation
Wathelet et al. (2020) 69,054 community 20.00 72.80 NR cross-sectional article France full democracy 8.12 ideation
Winkler et al. (2020) 3021 community 46.84 52.33 NR longitudinal article Czech Republic flawed democracy 7.69 ideation
Xiaoming et al. (2020) 8817 frontline 33.25 78.00 NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Xin et al. (2020) 23,863 community NR NR NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Xin et al. (2020)g 515 community NR NR NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Zhang et al. (2020) 1241 community 12.60 40.70 NR longitudinal article China authoritarian 2.26 attempts self-harm
Zhao et al. (2020) 106 clinical 35.90 56.60 NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Zhou et al. (2020) 606 frontline NR 81.20 NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation
Zhou et al. (2020)e 1099 community 29.23 NR NR cross-sectional article China authoritarian 2.26 ideation

Note. NR = not reported; N = total number of participants; clinical samples are comprised of help-seeking individuals; mean age is expressed in years; Female% = percentage female; White% = percentage White; Status = publication status of study; Country = participants’ country; Regime type = form of government; Democracy index = democracy index weighted average, based on a nation's electoral process and pluralism, civil liberties, functioning of government, political participation, and political culture (higher scores represent more democratic political regimes); Suicide Behaviors = type of suicide behavior assessed.

a

Patients with worsening obsessive-compulsive disorder symptoms

b

97.3% of sample was from the United States.

c

Child and adolescent sample.

d

Female sample.

e

Community sample.

f

Respondents from 52 countries.

g

Quarantined subsample.