Table 6.
Study | Year | Joint | App. | Weight & Load | Element | Attribute | Subject | Speed |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
USA [110] | 2005 |
|
EWB | W (15.5); L (34) | Variable damper | —— | 1 | 0.82 m/s level walking |
USA [111] | 2006 |
|
MA | —— | Springs, clutches, and variable damping | —— | —— | 1.3 m/s level walking |
USA [112] | 2006 |
|
EWB | W (15); L (20); L (40); L (55) | —— | —— | 10 S | 4.83 km/h level walking 8 min |
USA [3] | 2007 |
|
MA EWB |
W (11.7); L (36) | Variable damping and two springs | P (0.002) | 0.92 m/s walking | |
France [113] | 2010 |
|
MA EWB |
—— | Force balancer and driver | —— | —— | Ascend the stairs or slopes |
USA [114] | 2013 |
|
O | W (3) | Actuator and spring module | P (0.0003) TS (109) |
1 | 0.6 m/s walking |
USA [115] | 2014 |
|
O | W (3) | Control module and support spring | TS (60) | 3 | —— |
Korea [116] | 2014 |
|
EWB | W (21); L (35) | Actuator and passive mechanism |
(1.8422)TS (92.25) |
1 | 6 km/h walking |
China [117] | 2015 |
|
MA | —— | Actuator and spring | —— | —— | —— |
Korea [118] | 2015 |
|
EWB MA |
W (23); L (30) | Spring and driver | SC (69.6) | 4 km/h level walking; ascend the stairs |
|
Japan [119] | 2016 | MR ME |
W (9) | Passive components and two drivers |
(100) TS (1000) (15) |
—— | Level walking, squat, stand to sit | |
Netherlands [120] | 2018 |
|
EWB MA |
W (21.8) | Hydraulic piston damping | —— | 9 | 4.5~5.3 km/h walking |
Italian [121] | 2018 |
|
MA MR |
W (4.1) | Elastic belt and clutch | —— | —— | |
Italian [122] | 2019 |
|
MA MR |
W (4.9) | Elastic belt and clutch | —— | 10 straight walks | |
Italian [123] | 2020 |
|
MA | W (4) | Pressure sensor, solenoid valve, and vacuum generator | —— | —— | (2) Walk a straight path of 10 m with 10 min. |
App.: Application. : Hip;: Knee; : Ankle; : Foot; W: Weight (kg); L: Load (kg); : Solider; : Male; : Female; HS: Heath subjects; SP: stroke patient; PSCI: patient with spinal cord injury; SM: simulation model; MA: Movement assistance; MR: Medical rehabilitation; ME: Motivation enhancement; EWB: Enhanced weight bearing; O: Orthosis; SC: Stiffness coefficient(N/mm); TS: Torsional stiffness (Nm/rad); P: Power (kW); : Maximum torque of motor (Nm); : Maximum torque of device (Nm); : Normalized peak power (W/kg); P: Power (kW).