Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 19;22(12):4622. doi: 10.3390/s22124622

Table A1.

Summary of reviewed articles.

Art Year Est AP rPoint fMap fmRoom mAlg sAlg mError oError sType
[41] 2021 pMap 168 57 IPIN2016 N DRL 0.92 m RSSI
pMap 589 1452 UTSIndoorLoc Y DRL 1.72 m RSSI
pMap 520 993 UJIIndoorLoc Y DRL 3.06 m Only Building B1 RSSI
[22] 2021 pMap 96 80 JUIndoorLoc Y BayesNet Dempster–Shafer Accuracy = 80% between 3 and 3.6 m RSSI
pMap 520 993 UJIIndoorLoc Y BayesNet Accuracy = 98% in 2 m RSSI
[87] 2021 exp 7 116 1052 m2 Y SISAE (NN) 1.93 m std = 1.34 m RSSI
[44] 2021 exp 1 32 49.9 m2 N CNN 1.76 m CSI
exp 1 45 40 m2 N CNN 1.16 m CSI
exp 1 66 48.8m2 Y CNN 2.54 m CSI
exp 1 15 32 m2 N CNN 0.91 m CSI
[45] 2021 sim 15 158 1160 m2 Y ASDELM (ELM) Accuracy = 85,90% in 1 m CSI
exp 22 47 384 m2 Y ASDELM (ELM) Accuracy = 77% in 1 m CSI
[88] 2021 pMap 520 993 UJIIndoorLoc Y DNNIP Accuracy = 89% building and floor RSSI
[80] 2021 pMap 520 993 UJIIndoorLoc Y CHISEL (CNN) autoencoder 6.95 m Accuracy = 99.6% building, 83.97% floor RSSI
[46] 2021 exp 1 40 131.3 m2 Y BPNN adaptive genetic algorithm Accuracy = 90.47% in 4 m CSI
[30] 2021 pMap 520 993 UJIIndoorLoc Y NNELILS (NN) 67% to 78% localization accuracies RSSI
pMap 96 80 JUIndoorLoc Y NNELILS (NN) 2.2 m to 2.6 m RSSI
[89] 2021 pMap 309 3951 Tampere Y CMDRNN (cnn) 8.26 m std = 1.31 m RSSI
[21] 2021 pMap 520 993 UJIIndoorLoc Y CDAE i CNN 12.4 m RSSI
pMap 152 670 Alcala Tutorial 2017 N CDAE-CNN 1.05 m RSSI
[89] 2021 pMap 520 993 UJIIndoorLoc Y CMDRNN (cnn) 8.26 m std = 1.31 m RSSI
[90] 2021 exp 113 30 3600 m2 Y WiFiNet (cnn) Accuracy = 91.89% in 2 m RSSI
[81] 2021 pMap 520 993 UJIIndoorLoc Y DeepLocBox (NN) 9.07 m RSSI
[33] 2021 exp 15 150 200 m2 Y SVM M-LS 2.7 m RSSI
[47] 2021 exp 1 N/A 14 m2 N NN 0.18 m CSI
exp 2 N/A 18 m2 N NN 0.03 m CSI
exp 2 N/A 6.7 m2 Y NN 0.08 m CSI
[48] 2021 exp 1 317 148.5 m2 Y BLS(NN) 2.54 m CSI
exp 1 176 126 m2 N BLS(NN) 1.48 m CSI
[82] 2021 exp 6 132 460 m2 Y Edgeloc(CapsNet) 99% under 2 m RSSI
pMap 520 993 UJIIndoorLoc Y Edgeloc(CapsNet) 7.93 m RSSI
[91] 2021 exp 1 210 600 m2 Y MLR 4.03 m RSSI
[77] 2021 exp 436 654 WIFINE Y RNN 3.05 m RSSI
[92] 2021 exp 191 349 360 m2 N DNN 1.08 m RSSI
[49] 2021 exp 1 17,486 CTW 2019 challenge N CNN 0.12 m CSI
[93] 2021 exp N/A 292 600 m2 Y CNN 1.86 m Accuracy = 95% in 5.41 m RSSI
exp N/A 262 1360 m2 Y CNN 1.86 m Accuracy = 95% in 5.41 m RSSI
[94] 2021 exp 12 680 6000 m2 N DNN 3.6 m RSSI
exp 12 170 6000 m2 N DNN 3.7 m RSSI
exp 12 40 6000 m2 N DNN 3.8 m RSSI
[95] 2021 exp 4 54 69.35 m2 Y ANN Accuracy = 13.84% < 0.5 m & 23.07% 0.5 < 1 m RSSI
[50] 2020 exp 3 21 45 m2 Y CNN 1.27 m std = 0.68 m CSI
[36] 2020 exp 4 264 112 m2 N RF 1.68 m RSSI
[51] 2020 exp 4 63 75.6 m2 N CNN 1.61 m CSI
exp 4 N/A 44.8 m2 N CNN 1.11 m CSI
exp 4 N/A 16 m2 N CNN 0.98 m CSI
[96] 2020 exp 4 10 169 m2 Y CNN 0.98 m RSSI
[54] 2020 exp 5 34 55 m2 N MLP Regression 0.37 m RMSE = 0.84 m SNR

art: Article; mAlg: Main algorithm used; est: Experimental or pMapulated study; sAlg: Other algorithms used in the study; AP: APs used; mError: Mean Error; rPoint: Reference Points used in offline phase; oError: Other metrics reported in the study; fMap: Size of experimental room or radio-map used; sType: Signal type used; fmRoom: Rooms used in exp/pMap.