Table 2.
Framework synthesis stage | Synthesis steps | Application in this review |
---|---|---|
Stage 1 Developing an initial conceptual framework |
1.Familiarization: Becoming immersed in the data | Undertaken during full-text screening and study selection (both stages), in addition to reading quantitative literature, systematic and narrative reviews for the field, handsearching references |
2.Framework selection: Identification of key themes to inform the framework | Systematic extraction of salient themes and findings from 18 studies identified in Step 1, identification of relevant theory and definitions (see Additional file 3 for full description) | |
Stage 2 Recognising patterns of data through an iterative process of aggregation and configuration |
3.Indexing: Systematically tagging and labelling key themes in the data | Data extracted, labelled, and indexed in NVivo software, using codebook developed from initial conceptual framework. Data not fitting framework analysed inductively |
4.Charting: Devising a series of thematic charts to allow the full pattern across papers to be explored and reviewed | Themes developed and revised iteratively in NVivo. Findings/ themes charted in Excel, patterns across data and studies explored | |
5.Mapping and interpretation: Drawing together the synthesis, consideration of how the themes answer the review question | Conceptual framework developed further to reflect review findings. Relationships between themes mapped and illustrated in Figures using PowerPoint |