Table 5.
Example Evidence of the Effects of Early Life Adversity on Males’ Gene x Environment Interactions & Epigenetics
| Citation | Study Design | Species | N | Early Life Adversity (ELA) | Key Findings | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Timing | Measure | |||||
| Gene-Environment Interactions | |||||||
| Bennett et al., 2002 | E, P | Rhesus macaques | 132 | Maternal separation | Up to 7 months postnatal | N/A | In males and females, adolescents with the short allele for rh5-HTTLPR who were exposed to peer-rearing (vs. mother-reared controls) showed significantly lower CSF concentrations of a serotonin metabolite (5-HIAA) and engaged in less play and more aggressive behaviors than peer-reared monkeys without the short allele |
| Newman et al., 2005 | E, P | Rhesus monkeys | 45 | Maternal absence in infancy | Up to 7 months postnatal | N/A | Mother-reared adolescent males with the low-activity-associated MAOA genotype exhibited higher aggressive responses during competitive interactions and in typical social interactions |
| Cicchetti et al., 2014 | CS | Humans | 1051 | Maltreatment | Birth to age 12 | CPS | Maltreatment history interacted with and OXTR and FKBP5 genotypes to predict child borderline personality symptoms, but females were at greater risk when they had minor alleles and males were at greater risk when they had major alleles. |
| McQuaid et al., 2019 | CS | Humans | 475 | Maltreatment | Childhood | RSR | Childhood maltreatment was associated with depressive symptoms for females regardless of IL-1β SNP genotype, while this relationship was strongest for males carrying the GG IL-1β SNP genotype |
| Min et al., 2017 | CS | Humans | 205 | Maltreatment | Up to age 16 years | RSR | In young adults, RORA gene polymorphisms interacted with childhood maltreatment to predict anxiety sensitivity only in males |
| Zhang et al., 2016 | CS | Humans | 507 | Physical and emotional abuse | Up to age 16 years | RSR | In adolescents, childhood physical and emotional abuse reported interacted with MAOA genotype to predict aggressive behavior among males |
| Epigenetics | |||||||
| Weaver et al., 2004 | E, P | Rats | 24 | Cross-fostering to high- or low-maternal care | Up to day 21 | N/A | Variations in maternal care resulted in changes in DNA methylation in both male and female offspring; effects persisted into adulthood and were reversed by cross-fostering |
| Checknita et al., 2020 | CS | Humans | 194 | Physical or sexual abuse | Childhood | RSR | MAOA genotype interacted with child maltreatment history to predict aggressive behaviors in adult males, and the highest levels of aggression were found among males with high levels of MAOA methylation |
| Cicchetti et al., 2016 | CS | Humans | 548 | Maltreatment | Up to current age (Mean 9.4 years) | CPS | Methylation of ALDH2 was higher in maltreated compared to non-maltreated males, but was lower in maltreated compared to non-maltreated females |
| Essex et al., 2013 | L | Humans | 109 | Parental stress | Infancy and preschool | PR | High parental stress during early childhood was associated with differential DNA methylation at age 15, and patterning of epigenetic marks differed by child sex |
| Labonté et al., 2012 | Postmortem | Humans | 41 | Abuse | Childhood | NR | Compared with non-abused controls, adult males with a history of abuse had differential methylation in promoter regions of several genes in hippocampal neurons |
| McGowan et al., 2009 | Postmortem | Humans | 36 | Maltreatment | Childhood | Proxy-based interview | Hippocampal NR3C1 gene expression was decreased in maltreated individuals compared with non-maltreated controls |
| Roberts et al., 2018 | CS | Humans | 34 | Maltreatment | Up to age 18 | RSR | Childhood maltreatment was associated with sperm DNA methylation in 12 DNA regions, including sites on genes associated with neuronal function, fat cell regulation, and immune function |
Note: SNP, Single nucleotide polymorphism
Study Design: E=Experimental, P=Prospective, L=Longitudinal, CS=Cross-sectional
ELA Measure: CPS=Child Protective Services records; NR=Not reported; PR=Parent report; RSR=Retrospective self-report