Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 4;12(7):e9074. doi: 10.1002/ece3.9074

TABLE A1.

Top‐ranked models two‐species co‐occurrence models for canid candidate sets estimating occupancy (Ψ) of focal species B (ΨB) when the occupancy state of interacting species A (ΨA) is present (ΨBA) or absent (ΨBa), and detection (p) independent or conditional (r) on occupancy or detection. Results for models within 10 ΔAICc of the top model are presented models including uninformative parameters are not shown). Co‐occurrence was considered independent when probability of occupancy for focal species B was constrained to be the same regardless of the occupancy state of interacting species B (ΨAΨBA=ΨBa), and conditional if occupancy of species B was dependent of occupancy state of species A (ΨAΨBAΨBa). Detection of species B was modeled as independent of occupancy or detection of species A (pApB=rBA=rBa), conditional on the occupancy of species A (pApBrBA=rBa), conditional on the detection of species A (pArApB=rBArBa), or conditional on the status and detection of species A (pArApBrBArBa)

Species A – Species B Co‐occurrence submodel Occupancy covariates Conditional detection submodel Detection covariates ΔAICc wgt a K b neg2ll c
Red fox – gray fox Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Independent None 0 0.65 6 1120.25
Independent % forest + differential species response Independent None 2.67 0.17 6 1122.92
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on occupancy and detection None 3.38 0.12 9 1117.36
Independent % forest + species interaction term Conditional on occupancy and detection None 6.22 0.03 9 1120.19
Independent Distance to structure Independent None 7.31 0.02 5 1129.63
Independent Structures/ha Independent None 9.14 0.01 5 1131.46
Independent % forest Independent None 9.26 0.01 5 1131.58
Independent None Independent None 9.59 0.01 4 1133.97
Coyote – gray fox Independent % forest cover Independent Mean temperature 0 0.92 6 2046.75
Independent None Independent Mean temperature 6.37 0.04 5 2055.18
Independent Distance to structure Independent Mean temperature 8.25 0.01 6 2055
Independent Structures/ha Independent Mean temperature 8.37 0.01 6 2055.11
Independent % forest + differential species response Independent None 9.53 0.01 6 2056.28
Independent % forest Independent None 9.6 0.01 5 2058.41
Dog – gray fox Conditional Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on occupancy None 0 0.44 8 1819.23
Conditional Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on occupancy and detection Previous gray fox detection 2.71 0.11 11 1815.59
Conditional % forest + differential species response Conditional on occupancy Previous gray fox detection 2.73 0.11 9 1819.85
Conditional % forest + differential species response Conditional on occupancy and detection Previous gray fox detection 2.78 0.1 11 1815.66
Conditional Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on occupancy and detection None 2.8 0.1 10 1817.81
Conditional % forest + differential species response Conditional on occupancy and detection None 3.15 0.09 10 1818.16
Conditional % forest + differential species response Conditional on occupancy None 3.86 0.06 8 1823.09
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on dog occupancy None 7.19 0.01 7 1828.51
Conditional Distance to structure + differential species response Independent None 8.52 0.01 7 1829.85
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Independent None 9.24 0 6 1832.64
Coyote – red fox Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Independent None 0 0.9 6 1922.02
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on occupancy and detection None 4.65 0.09 9 1920.39
Independent Distance to structure Independent None 8.89 0.01 5 1932.98
Independent Structures/ha Independent None 9.96 0.01 5 1934.04
Domestic dog – red fox Independent Distance to structure Conditional on occupancy Year 0 0.39 8 1666.35
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on occupancy and detection Year 0.15 0.36 11 1660.15
Independent Distance to structure Conditional on occupancy and detection Year 1.43 0.19 10 1663.55
Independent Distance to structure independent Year 3.75 0.06 7 1672.19
Domestic dog – coyote Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on detection Mean temperature 0 0.58 8 2623.81
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on detection None 2.11 0.2 7 2628.01
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on occupancy and detection Mean temperature 3.78 0.09 10 2623.37
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Independent Mean temperature 4.72 0.05 7 2630.62
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on occupancy and detection None 5.74 0.03 9 2627.44
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Independent None 6.43 0.02 6 2634.41
Independent Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on occupancy None 7.63 0.01 7 2633.53
Conditional Distance to structure + differential species response Conditional on detection Mean temperature 9.84 0 8 2633.65
a

Akaike model weight, recalculated following removal of models with uninformative parameters.

b

Number of parameters.

c

2 × negative log‐likelihood.