Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 20;13:906153. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.906153

TABLE 14.

Robust test by PSM.

Variable Radius match (r = 0.01)
Nearest neighbor match (1:1)
Nuclear match
ATT Standard error T value ATT Standard error T value ATT Standard error T value
Panel A: Current effect
BA 0.8718 0.007 3.12*** 0.026 0.008 3.22*** 0.8719 0.007 3.40***
SM 0.2839 0.006 23.47*** 0.154 0.010 15.26*** 0.2849 0.006 24.34***
VM 0.3301 0.006 22.79*** 0.160 0.010 15.66*** 0.3310 0.006 23.74***
SMI 0.9390 0.005 6.79*** 0.023 0.007 2.51** 0.9290 0.005 5.92***
CHI 0.1590 0.006 6.59*** 0.038 0.009 4.46*** 0.1593 0.006 6.99***
PP 0.8374 0.007 2.88*** 0.019 0.008 2.35** 0.8276 0.007 3.17***
CC 0.3781 0.008 7.92*** 0.067 0.011 6.04*** 0.3788 0.007 8.79***
Panel B: Long-term effect
BA 0.9728 0.0045 6.96*** 0.029 0.006 4.76*** 0.9727 0.0044 7.14***
SM 0.2278 0.0065 19.44*** 0.136 0.010 13.16*** 0.2281 0.0064 20.19***
VM 0.2637 0.0069 19.68*** 0.149 0.010 14.99*** 0.2641 0.0069 20.43***
SMI 0.9501 0.0046 1.89* 0.005 0.006 0.81 0.9501 0.0045 1.98**
CHI 0.1357 0.0058 7.20*** 0.041 0.009 4.40*** 0.1360 0.0058 7.54***
PP 0.8976 0.0066 3.36*** 0.010 0.009 1.14 0.8977 0.0065 3.62***
CC 0.3862 0.0086 12.52*** 0.092 0.013 7.19*** 0.3862 0.0085 13.04***
Panel C: Dynamic effect
BA 0.0925 0.0091 2.28** 0.023 0.011 2.07** 0.0926 0.0088 2.41**
SM 0.0534 0.0060 5.50*** 0.043 0.011 4.09*** 0.0532 0.0059 5.79***
VM 0.0662 0.0068 5.71*** 0.047 0.011 4.36*** 0.0659 0.0067 5.95***
SMI 0.0017 0.0066 1.61 −0.010 0.008 −1.19 0.0017 0.0064 −1.60
CHI 0.0370 0.0072 1.92* 0.007 0.010 0.65 0.0368 0.0070 1.88*
PP 0.0474 0.0086 2.30** 0.029 0.011 2.75*** 0.4748 0.0083 2.52**
CC 0.0462 0.0088 2.25** 0.037 0.014 2.02** 0.0380 0.0086 2.02**

Figures in brackets are heteroskedasticity-consistent t-statistics. *, **, and *** indicate significance at the 10, 5, and 1% levels, respectively.