Table 1.
Reference | Time period | Country | CH incidence | TCH incidence | Likely causes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chiesa et al. (13) | 1997–2010 | Argentina | GIS CH increased in incidence | No significant change | Change in TSH cut points. (partly). Possible contribution of iodine deficiency |
Kara et al (7) | 2008–2010 | Turkey | Two-fold increase in PCH, five-fold increase in TCH since past evaluations with higher TSH cut point (20 mU/L) | 52% cases had TCH. TCH increased from 35% (2008) to 56% (2009–2010) when TSH cut point further decreased | Increased incidence of PCH and TCH partly due to decreased TSH cut points; High overall incidence of TCH possibly due to I- deficiency |
Mitrovic et al. (6) | 1983–2013 | Serbia | Overall CH incidence tripled as TSH cut point decreased. PCH due to ectopy/GIS/goitre doubled, athyreosis stable. | TCH increased from 0 to 35% | Decreased TSH cutoffs; Other yet unidentified factors. |
Mitchell et al. (9) | 1991–1994; 2001–2004 | USA | CH incidence doubled due to increased cases with delayed or mild TSH elevation. Severe CH stable. | TCH stable | Mainly due to enhanced detection of infants with mild disease and premature infants with delayed TSH rise due to altered screening strategy |
McGrath et al. (14) | 1979–2016 | Ireland | Increased incidence of CH from 0.27 (1979–1991) to 0.65 cases per 1000 live births (treated 2005–2016). Mainly mild CH with normal or hyperplastic GIS. | TCH only assessed in final study period | Not due to change in TSH cut points or population ethnicity. Environmental factors, for example, iodine insufficiency, may have contributed |
Hinton et al. (12) | Summary of total and state-specific data 1991–2007 | USA | CH incidence increased in the United States by 3% per year; however, an increase did not occur in all states, at a constant rate, or at the same rate | Not assessed | Race, ethnicity, sex, and low birth weight/preterm birth all affected CH incidence. |
Albert et al. (11) | 1993–2010 | New Zealand | Overall incidence of CH rose from 2.6 to 3.6 per 10 000 live births due to increased GIS CH. | Not assessed | Mainly due to altered population ethnicity. No change in TSH cut points. |
Harris & Pass (10) | 1978–2005 | USA | Overall incidence of CH rose 73% between 1987 and 2002 | Not assessed | Altered demographics account for 36–38% of the increase in incidence of CH. Diagnostic cut points unchanged. |
Deladoey et al. (8) | 1990–2009 | Canada | Incidence of GIS CH doubled, and TD and goitre remained constant. | Not assessed | Decrease in TSH cut pojnt |
Barry et al. (5) | 1982–2012 | France | Annual average increase of 5.1% for GIS, mild and severe. TD constant. | Not assessed | Unlikely due to change in TSH cut points or population ethnicity. Possible contribution of increased preterm birth and iatrogenic iodine overload |
PCH, permanent CH; TD, thyroid dysgenesis.