Table 2. Decellularisation methods for bone grafts*.
Method | Advantages | Drawbacks | |
---|---|---|---|
Chemical | SDS | Complete removal of cellular components | Damages ECM: • Collagen disruption • GAG reduction |
Triton TnBP | Good preservation of the ECM | Poor cell removal efficiency | |
Enzymatic | DNAse | • Not damaging to the ECM • Very efficient in DNA debris elimination |
Difficult to wash off tissues. Works only in combination with treatment disrupting cell membranes |
Trypsin | Efficient cell surface removal | Prolonged exposure can disrupt ECM | |
EDTA | Disrupts cell adhesion to ECM | Inefficient alone, often combined with trypsin | |
Mechanical | Freeze/thaw | Efficient disruption of cell membranes | Does not efficiently remove cellular components & can damage ECM |
Pressure | Increases chemical exposure and debris removal in tissues | High pressures can affect ECM integrity |
Note: *Adapted from Blaudez et al.26 DNAse: deoxyribonuclease; ECM: extracellular matrix; EDTA: ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid;
SDS: sodium dodecyl sulfate; TnBP: tri-n-butyl phosphate.