Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 6;7(7):e007926. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2021-007926

Table 3.

Neonatal and maternal health outcomes and delivery by skilled health workers

7-day death 28-day death Postpartum complication (bleeding) Postpartum complication (fever)
Panel A. Delivery with skilled assistance
First stage (dependent variable: delivery with skilled assistance)
Cum. perc. of treated pop. 0.1171* 0.1171* 0.0975* 0.0975*
(0.0255) (0.0255) (0.0254) (0.0254)
F-statistic 21.1000 21.1000 14.7776 14.7776
R-squared 0.2262 0.2262 0.2309 0.2309
Second stage IV (dependent variable: neonatal and maternal health outcomes)
Delivery with skilled assistance −0.0504 −0.0341 0.1537 −0.2625
(0.0489) (0.0534) (0.2263) (0.2102)
Mean fraction skilled assistance 0.7414 0.7414 0.7657 0.7657
Mean fraction health outcome 0.0262 0.0314 0.1886 0.1612
Panel B. Delivery with doctor assistance
First stage (dependent variable: Delivery with doctor assistance)
Cum. perc. of treated pop. 0.1147* 0.1147* 0.0963* 0.0963*
(0.0292) (0.0292) (0.0286) (0.0286)
F-statistic 15.4854 15.4854 11.3185 11.3185
R-squared 0.3387 0.3387 0.3459 0.3459
Second stage IV (dependent variable: neonatal and maternal health outcomes)
Delivery with doctor assistance −0.0316 −0.0102 0.2620 −0.2515
(0.0588) (0.0625) (0.2614) (0.2363)
Mean fraction doctor assistance 0.6332 0.6332 0.6699 0.6699
Mean fraction health outcome 0.0262 0.0314 0.1909 0.1563
Panel C. Delivery with nurse assistance
First stage (dependent variable: delivery with nurse assistance)
Cum. perc. of treated pop. 0.1413* 0.1413* 0.1171* 0.1171*
(0.0364) (0.0364) (0.0397) (0.0397)
F-statistic 15.0774 15.0774 8.7123 8.7123
R-squared 0.2263 0.2263 0.2337 0.2337
Second stage IV (dependent variable: neonatal and maternal health outcomes)
Delivery with nurse assistance −0.0546 −0.0129 −0.1073 −0.3008
(0.0611) (0.0651) (0.2331) (0.2414)
Mean fraction nurse assistance 0.5318 0.5318 0.5515 0.5515
Mean fraction health outcome 0.0288 0.0347 0.1813 0.1759

Note: Each column in each panel lists estimates from separate regressions. All regressions control for month of birth, year of birth, town fixed effects, neonate characteristics (if the birth is a multiple birth, the sex of the neonate, if the birth is the birth and birth order), mother characteristics (age at delivery (categorical variable), education level (categorical variables), using modern contraceptives, being insured, smoking behaviour, BMI, having a previous miscarriage, abortion, or stillbirth, religion, if the mother belongs to a caste and tribe) and household characteristics (wealth index, if the household has electricity). The F-statistic corresponds to a test of significance of the instrumental variable. The instrumental variable is the cumulative percentage of treated population (population that gained access to a paved road) in a town. Robust SEs clustered at the town level are shown in parentheses.

*Significant at the 1 percentage level.

BMI, body mass index.