Table 1.
An example of the six versions of the same scenario adapted from Leloup et al. (2018).
|
| ||
|---|---|---|
| VERSION OF THE SCENARIO | NOT INTENTIONAL & NEUTRAL OUTCOME (‘NEUTRAL’) | NOT INTENTIONAL & HARMFUL OUTCOME (‘ACCIDENTAL HARM’) |
|
| ||
| Step 0. Context | Cindy and Valerie decide to have a drink after work. Valerie has to drive her car to go back home. Valerie asks Cindy to order her a non-alcoholic cocktail while she goes to the bathroom. Cindy orders a homemade cocktail for Valerie. | Cindy and Valerie decide to have a drink after work. Valerie has to drive her car to go back home. Valerie asks Cindy to order her a non-alcoholic cocktail while she goes to the bathroom. Cindy orders a homemade cocktail for Valerie. |
|
| ||
| Step 1. Intent | Cindy thought the homemade cocktail was not alcoholic. | Cindy thought the homemade cocktail was not alcoholic. |
|
| ||
| Step 2. Outcome | Valerie is in condition to drive and does not have any accident on the way back home. | Valerie is not in condition to drive and has an accident on the way back home. |
|
| ||
| VERSION OF THE SCENARIO | INTENTIONAL & NEUTRAL OUTCOME (‘ATTEMPTED HARM’) | INTENTIONAL & HARMFUL OUTCOME (‘INTENTIONAL HARM’) |
|
| ||
| Step 0. Context | Cindy and Valerie decide to have a drink after work. Valerie has to drive her car to go back home. Valerie asks Cindy to order her a non-alcoholic cocktail while she goes to the bathroom. Cindy orders a homemade cocktail for Valerie. | Cindy and Valerie decide to have a drink after work. Valerie has to drive her car to go back home. Valerie asks Cindy to order her a non-alcoholic cocktail while she goes to the bathroom. Cindy orders a homemade cocktail for Valerie. |
|
| ||
| Step 1. Intent | Cindy thought the homemade cocktail was alcoholic. | Cindy thought the homemade cocktail was alcoholic. |
|
| ||
| Step 2. Outcome | Valerie is in condition to drive and does not have any accident on the way back home. | Valerie is not in condition to drive and has an accident on the way back home. |
|
| ||
| VERSION OF THE SCENARIO | INTENTIONAL & NOT CAUSED HARMFUL OUTCOME (‘NON-CAUSED BUT INTENTIONAL HARM’) | NOT INTENTIONAL & NOT CAUSED HARMFUL OUTCOME (‘NON-CAUSED & NON-INTENTIONAL HARM’) |
|
| ||
| Step 0. Context | Cindy and Valerie decide to have a drink after work. Valerie has to drive her car to go back home. Valerie asks Cindy to order her a non-alcoholic cocktail while she goes to the bathroom. Cindy orders a homemade cocktail for Valerie. | Cindy and Valerie decide to have a drink after work. Valerie has to drive her car to go back home. Valerie asks Cindy to order her a non-alcoholic cocktail while she goes to the bathroom. Cindy orders a homemade cocktail for Valerie. |
|
| ||
| Step 1. Intent | Cindy thought the homemade cocktail was alcoholic. | Cindy thought the homemade cocktail was not alcoholic. |
|
| ||
| Step 2. Outcome | Valerie is in condition to drive but she hits an animal on the road and has an accident. | Valerie is in condition to drive but she hits an animal on the road and has an accident. |
|
| ||
Note: The first four versions of the scenario (i.e., Neutral; Accidental Harm; Attempted Harm; Intentional Harm) were kept unaltered from the original material (Samson & Leloup, 2018). The last two were created within the same logic but adapted according to the model proposed by Cushman (2008, Experiment 3).