Table 2.
Summary of articles categorized as observational, organized by specific drug classes, general or specific adverse drug reactions, or both
| Article | EHR Database/Data Source | Sample Size |
Primary EHR Components* |
Findings: Prevalence/Incidence, Risk Factors, Outcome, Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DRUG: Antibiotics (n=15) | ||||
| Apter et al. (2004) 21 | UK General Practice Research Database | 3.4 million | D | 57 out of 3,014 (0.15%) patients who had an allergic-like event after the first prescription experienced another event to the second prescription. |
| Albin et al. (2014) 7 | Internal Medicine Associates Clinic of Mount Sinai Hospital/ Epic EHR | 1,348 | A, D | Documented reactions to penicillin allergy are rash (37%), hives (18.9%), and swelling (11.8%) and was most prevalent in African Americans, then Caucasians and Asians. Risk factors for penicillin allergy: sex (female) |
| May et al. (2016) 22 | Mayo Clinic | 927 | A, D | IV penicillin did not increase risk of allergy in children (OR: 0.84). |
| Crotty et al. (2017) 10 | NSLIJ Huntington Hospital, Huntington, NY | 175 | A, D | 89% of 175 patients who received at least one dose of cefepime, ceftriaxone, cefoxitin, cephalexin, or meropenem had self-reported allergy to penicillin. 20% reported incidence of rash while 63% said unknown reaction. 8 patients had an allergic reaction to penicillin while 2 patients had an adverse drug reaction (ADR) to amoxicillin and piperacillin/tazobactam. Risk factor: history of self-reported allergy can increase risk of cross-sensitivity reactions, type of drug (cephalosporin) |
| West et al. (2019) 12 | ResearchOne, UK | 2.3 million | A, D | The prevalence of penicillin allergy was 5.9%. Risk factors: age (older), sex (female), comorbidities |
| Liang et al. (2020) 13 | Kaiser Permanente Southern California | 6.1 million | A, B | More patients who received parenteral penicillin reported new allergic reactions (0.84%) than those who received oral penicillin (0.74%). 0.097% and 0.065% of parenteral and oral exposures respectively were confirmed anaphylaxis cases. |
| Lager et al. (2009) 6 | University of Michigan Health System | 211 | A, D | Incidence of allergic-type reaction to carbapenem was 11% in patients with reported penicillin allergy, 5.2x greater than those who did not report a penicillin allergy. Risk factor: documented Penicillin allergy |
| Beltran et al. (2015) 8 | Nationwide Children's Hospital Enterprise Data Warehouse (Epic EHR) | 513 | A, D | Cephalosporin resulted in one documented case of nonanaphylactic reaction when used as surgical prophylaxis. Clindamycin, most common cephalosporin, produced an adverse rate of 1.5% in patients with Penicillin allergy. |
| Macy et al. (2015) 23 | Kaiser Permanente Southern California (Health Connect) | 1.0 million | A, B, D | There were higher reports of allergy to cephalosporin among women (0.56%) than among men (0.43%). Anaphylaxis occurred in 5 oral exposures and 8 parenteral exposures. Clostridium difficile infection within 90 days (0.91%), nephropathy (0.15%), and all-cause death within 1 day (0.10%) were most common, serious ADR. No correlation with drug allergy history. |
| Blumenthal et al. (2016) 9 | Partners Healthcare System-Mass General Brigham (Epic EHR) | 96 | A, D | ADR was observed in 21% of inpatient patients who received ceftaroline. No increased risk of ADR for patients with reported B-lactam allergy. |
| Alvarez-Arango et al. (2021) 24 | Johns Hopkins Health System Corporation (JHHS) and Mass General Brigham (MGB) (Epic EHR) | 4.5 million | A, D | 0.3% of patients had documented vancomycin allergy with 42.1% reporting immediate phenotypes and 20.7% delayed reactions. 32% hypersensitivity reactions presented as rash and 16% as Red Man Syndrome. |
| Butler et al. (2018) 11 | Seattle Children’s Hospital, University of Washington School of Medicine | 17,496 | B, D | 1% of penicillin allergic patients who received cefazolin experienced perioperative adverse drug reactions, Vancomycin associated with greater rates of ADR as prophylaxis. |
| Fosnot et al. (2021) 25 | UCHealth System-Health Data Compass Data Warehouse project | 690 | A, D | Probable DHRs occurred in 0.9% patients who received cefazolin, 1.4% patients who received clindamycin, and 1.1% patients who received vancomycin, not varying significantly. |
| Macy et al. (2009) 14 | Kaiser Permanente | 1,127 | A | 15.3% of drug allergy reports reported at least one allergy to one antibiotic class. Risk factors: female, older age, drug type (highest incidence w/ sulfa class) |
| Salden et al. (2015) 17 | Academic Health Care Centre Terwijde at Leidsche Rijn Utrecht | 8,288 | A | 2.0% of sample had recorded allergy to B-lactams in Dutch primary care system. Risk factors: age (very young), sex (female), comorbidities (asthma, allergies, skin disorders) |
| DRUG: Cancer therapy-related drugs (n=7) | ||||
| Lal et al. (2009) 26 | University of Texas M. D.- Anderson Cancer Center | 3,746 | D | Weekly paclitaxel infusions result in 1.5% rate of DHRs. |
| Kim et al. (2012) 27 | Seoul National University Bundang Hospital | 393 | D | The prevalence rate of DHRs to oxaliplatin is 10.7%. Risk factors: higher dosage of oxaliplatin and lower dosage of dexamethasone |
| Jung et al. (2014) 28 | Seoul National University Hospital | 658 | B, D | 49.5% of patients who received rituximab experienced infusion related reactions. Risk factors: certain types of lymphoma (CLL, intravascular B cell lymphoma), high dosage and rate of injection in 1st 30 min |
| Levin et al. (2017) 29 | Partners Healthcare System- Mass General Brigham | 67 | A, D | 51% of patients who experienced grade 1 reaction to rituximab can be safely rechallenged. |
| Welborn et al. (2018) 30 | University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center | 17 | D | 70.6% of patients with cutaneous ADE to tremelimumab experienced pruritis. Other reactions include eczematous dermatitis, morbilliform rash, vitiligo, xerosis, acneiform rash, and psoriasiform dermatitis. |
| Shazib et al. (2020) 31 | Dana-Farber/Brigham and Women's Cancer Center | 13 | D | Of 13 patients, 4 had oral-only immune-related ADEs to programmed cell death-1 inhibitors. 10 had lichenoid lesions, 2 with erythema multiforme, 1 with graft vs host disease reactivation, and 8 with or without ulcerations. |
| Keiser et al. (2021) 32 | University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center | 64 | B, D | 91% of patients with cutaneous adverse events to immune checkpoint inhibitors treated with topical steroids, oral antihistamines, or topical antihistamines and 70% recovered from rash over 4 months. |
| DRUG: Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) (n=2) | ||||
| Blumenthal et al. (2017) 33 | Partners HealthCare System (PHS) - Partners Enterprise Allergy Repository (PEAR) | 62,719 | A, B, C, D | 1.7% had an ADR to prescription NSAIDs, 18.3% of which were hypersensitivity reactions. Risk factors: drug hypersensitivity reaction history, sex (female), autoimmune disease, and those who were prescribed the maximum standing NSAIDs dose |
| Li et al. (2021) 34 | Partners HealthCare System | 47,114 | A, B, D | 7.7% of patients with chronic back pain had active aspirin or NSAID adverse reaction. |
| DRUG: Opioids (n=1) | ||||
| Inglis et al. (2021) 35 | Royal Adelaide Hospital, Australia (Sunrise) | 231,623 | A, C, D | 15.9% of ADR reports were due to opioids, with 64.7% reported as allergy and 35.3% as intolerance. |
| DRUG: Radiocontrast media (RCM)-related compounds (n=4) | ||||
| Dillman et al. (2007) 36 | University of Michigan Health System | 78,353 | D | The reaction frequency to IV gadolinium is 007%. 74% of reactions were mild, 19% were moderate and 7% were severe. 50% had at least one risk factor to IV gadolinium reaction. Risk factors: allergic-like contrast reaction, a prior allergic reaction to a substance other than contrast media, or documented asthma |
| Power et al. (2016) 37 | University Health Network, Toronto | 19,074 | D | The reaction rate to gadobutrol is 0.32% and the per patient reaction basis was 0.43%. Risk factors: previous allergic-like reaction to gadolinium, previous reaction to any substance, history of asthma |
| Young et al. (2019) 38 | NHS Tayside, Health Informatics Centre, University of Dundee | 22,897 | D | 0.01% of patients had DHRs to gadolinium-based contrast agents. |
| Lakshmanadoss et al. (2012) 39 | Johns Hopkins Health System | 234 | D | 71% of patients had previous recorded allergy to iodinated contrast agents, 24% to iodine, and 5% to both. Most patients (77%) had skin rashes or unspecified reaction while 8.5% had anaphylaxis. |
| DRUG: Statin (n=1) | ||||
| Robison et al. (2014) 40 | Intermountain Healthcare system (Murray, UT) | 10,789 | B, D | Patients with statin intolerance had a higher history of hypothyroidism (30.2%) compared to the control group (21.5%). |
| DRUG: Other (n=3) | ||||
| Paisansinsup et al. (2013) 41 | Park Nicollet Health Services EHR | 1,268 | D | 3.79% of patients prescribed allopurinol experienced an ADR. Risk factors: sex (female), older age, diabetes mellitus, diuretic use, presence of tophi associated with possible ADR |
| Hall et al. (2018) 42 | The Health Improvement Network, UK | 70 | C, D | Observed-to-expected ratio was 3.3 and 1.5 for convulsions and thrombocytopenia for those who received Optaflu, a trivalent seasonal influenza vaccine. |
| Laird et al. (2020) 43 | UCHealth System | 868 | B, D | 0.461% of patients who received Fosaprepitant as a prophylaxis for chemotherapy related nausea had a systemic hypersensitivity reaction. |
| Adverse Drug Reaction (ADR): Broad/general overview (n=6) | ||||
| Kidon and See (2004) 44 | KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital, Singapore | 672 | D | 2.2% of pediatric patients had recorded ADR, 70% of which were due to antibiotics, specifically B-lactams. 18.5% were due to NSAIDs in Singapore. Risk factors: older age, male gender, presence of asthma or other chronic disease |
| Macy et al. (2014) 15 | Kaiser Permanente Southern California, Health Connect | 105,61 4 | B, D | The most common allergies in hospitalized patients were due to penicillin (16.7%), other nonantibiotics (12.7%), narcotics (11.7%), sulfonamides antibiotics (10.2%) and NSAIDs (7.1%), which altogether accounted for 58.4% of reported allergies. Risk factors: sex (female), age (older) |
| Saager et al. (2015) 45 | Cleveland Clinic Perioperative Health Documentation System | 264 | D | Overall incidence of intraoperative hypersensitivity reaction was 0.148%. 2 out of 10,000 operations resulted in severe hypersensitivity reactions. |
| Zhou et al. (2016) 16 | Partners HealthCare System/ Partners’ Enterprise-wide Allergy Repository (PEAR) | 1.8 million | A, D | 35.5% of patients reported at least one drug allergy with 1.95 allergies/patient. Risk factors: female sex, Caucasian race, antibiotic, statin, and ACE inhibitor use |
| Mendes et al. (2019) 46 | Portuguese Catalogue of Allergies and Other Adverse Reactions (CPARA) | 380 | D | 0.4% inpatients (380 patients) had DHRs over 5-year period, 52.8% of which were associated with antibiotics, mainly beta lactam antibacterial use. 47.6% ADR were skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders and 41.3% were immune system disorders, specifically anaphylactic Reactions (37.4%). |
| Wong et al. (2019) 20 | Partners HealthCare System/ Partners’ Enterprise-wide Allergy Repository (PEAR) | 2.7 million | A, C, D | 13.8% of patient population had documented DHRs. 53.1% were associated with immediate reaction phenotypes. Risk factors: female sex, race/ethnicity, drug type |
| ADR: Anaphylaxis (n=3) | ||||
| Goh et al. (2018) 47 | National University Hospital, KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital, and Tan Tock Seng Hospital, Singapore | 426 | B | 45% of anaphylaxis cases were children in Singapore. Risk factors: food type, drug type |
| Dhopeshwarkar et al. (2019) 48 | Partners HealthCare System/ Partners’ Enterprise-wide Allergy Repository (PEAR) | 1.7 million | A, D | 1.1% of patient population had at least one drug-induced anaphylaxis reaction. Risk factor: female sex, white race, drug type |
| Rangkakulnuwat et al. (2020) 49 | Chiang Mai University (CMU) Hospital, Chiang Mai, Thailand | 433 | B | Overall incidence of anaphylaxis in Asia was 3.9 cases out of 100,000 visits, 84% of which were experienced in adults. Drug-induced anaphylaxis was more common in adults than children (19.8% vs. 8.1%). NSAIDs (7.4%) and antimicrobials were most common culprit drugs. 11.4% of cases had unknown cause. Risk factors: food, drug exposure, age, sex |
| ADR: severe cutaneous adverse reactions (SCAR) (n=6) | ||||
| Ou-Yang et al. (2013) 50 | Taiwan National Health Insurance Research Database | 554 | D | 15.5% of outpatient and hospitalized patients in Taiwan were hospitalized twice due to SJS/TEN. Penicillin and cephalosporin (27%, 27%) were the main culprit agents for 1st hospitalization. |
| Micheletti et al. (2018) 51 | 18 US academic medical centers | 377 | D | 89.7% of SJS/TEN cases were due to medication, mainly trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazole (26.3%) and b- lactams (12.4%). |
| Park et al. (2019) 52 | Multicenter, Gangnam Severance Hospital, South Korea | 745 | D | Allopurinol was the causative drug in 14.2% of SCAR cases. Other culprit drugs are anticonvulsants (22.5%), b-lactams (21.1%) and NSAIDs (10.3%). |
| De Bustros et al. (2021) 53 | Loyola University Medical Center | 163 | D | Anticonvulsants (30%), Trimethoprim-Sulfamethoxazole (19%), Beta-lactams (11%), NSAIDs (8.4%) and allopurinol (8.4%) were identified the most probable culprit in SJS/TEN cases. |
| Zhang et al. (2019) 54 | Penn State Hershey Medical Center | 35 | B, D | 35 patients (5.9% of larger patient cohort) had documented SCAR, including 54.3% of DRESS, 22.8% of SJS, 17.1% of AGEP, 2.9% of TEN and SJS/TEN overlap. |
| Ma et al. (2021) 55 | Chang Gung Memorial Hospital Linkou Branch, Taiwan | 119 | D | Of patients with SJS/TEN and overlap syndrome, 46.2% had severe ocular complications. |
| ADR: Other (n=7) | ||||
| Macy et al. (2012) 18 | Kaiser Permanente Southern California (Health Connect) | 2.4 million | A | 2.1% of health plan members had 3 or more allergies reported and can be diagnosed with multiple drug intolerance syndrome. Risk factors: female sex, age, drug type, anxiety associated |
| Banerji et al. (2017) 56 | Partners HealthCare System | 135,000 | A, C, D | Incidence of ACE inhibitor angioedema is 0.07% and 0.23% within the 1st month and 1st year of use, respectively. |
| Read et al. (2017) 57 | Royal Brisbane and Women's Hospital, Gold Coast University Hospital, Australia | 70 | D | Only 9 cases of 70 reported erythema multiforme diagnoses in children met criteria for erythema multiforme, with most being misdiagnosed. |
| Blumenthal et al. (2018) 58 | Partners HealthCare System/ Partners’ Enterprise-wide Allergy Repository (PEAR) | 746,88 8 | A, B, C, D | The overall prevalence rate was multiple drug intolerance syndrome was 6.4% and 1.2% for multiple drug allergy syndrome. Risk factors for MDIS: female sex, older age, greater weight, prior hospitalizations, and multiple medical comorbidities |
| Braswell et al. (2019) 59 | University of Florida, the Medical College of Wisconsin, and Inform Diagnostics Research Institute | 56 | D | Of patients with lichenoid granulomatous dermatitis, most were diagnosed with drug eruption (39.3%, n = 22) and lichenoid keratosis (19.6%, n = 11). |
| Jimenez et al. (2019) 19 | Cleveland Clinic | 2.0 million | D | 70.9% had no allergies; 27.4% had 1-4 allergies; 1.5% had 5-9 allergies; 0.22% had >9 allergies in the patient population. Rates of mental health and somatic syndrome disorder increased with more allergies. Risk factors: female sex |
| Leigh et al. (2019) 60 | University of Pennsylvania Health Systems | 1,218 | A, B, D | Overall incidence of Eosinophilic esophagitis is 0.034% in patient population. There may be a correlation with smoking. |
| BOTH Drug/ADR (n=6) | ||||
| Silverman et al. (2016) 61 | University of Pennsylvania Health Systems | 220 | A | 12.4% of patients without chronic urticaria had self-reported penicillin allergy. there was a 14.5% rate and 4.6% of chronic urticaria in patients with and without self-reported penicillin allergy, respectively. |
| Lin et al. (2017) 62 | Penn State College of Medicine/ Medical Center | 138 | D | In 78 pediatric reactions to vancomycin, 92% were consistent with Red Man Syndrome. Of 60 children prescribed linezolid, 82% were unnecessarily avoiding vancomycin without prior reaction to vancomycin. |
| Coleman et al. (2019) 63 | Yale-New Haven Hospital | 98 | D | Most rashes were associated with immune checkpoint inhibitors: pembrolizumab (35/103 rashes), nivolumab (33/103 rashes), and ipilimumab/nivolumab (17/103 rashes). |
| Jung et al. (2019) 64 | Yonsei University Wonju College of Medicine, South Korea | 1,253 | D | The prevalence of DRESS cases among patients prescribed antituberculosis drugs is 1.2%. Ethambol (53.5%) and rifampin (26.7%) are the most common culprit drugs. |
| Fukasawa et al. (2021) 65 | JMDC Claims Database, Japan | 355 | B, D | In Japan the odds ratio of SJS/TEN for anti-convulsant, including carbamazepine (OR 68.00) and lamotrigine (OR 36.00) were significantly increased. |
| Sim et al. (2021) 66 | Chonnam National University Hospital, South Korea | 27 | D | 48% of 27 patients with drug fever or maculopapular exanthem had Multiple Drug Hypersensitivity Syndrome. Most common culprit agent was ethambutol and rifampin, followed by pyrazinamide and isoniazid. |
(A=Allergy List/Problem List, B=ICD Codes, C=free-text or structured data in the allergy list, D=Other/Unspecified)
Abbreviations: NSAIDs, Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs; RCM, Radiocontrast media; ADR, adverse drug reaction; SCAR, severe cutaneous adverse reactions; DRESS, drug reaction with eosinophilia and systemic symptoms