Table 7.
Author and Year | Exposure Agent/Aging Technique | Testing Machine Used | Mean Maximum Force at Fracture for Conventional Resin (N) | Mean Maximum Force at Fracture for CAD/CAM Milled Resin (N) | Mean Maximum Force at Fracture for 3D-Printed Resin (N) | Conclusions and/or Suggestions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Reeponmaha et al., 2020 [16] | (A) Thermal Cycling: 5000 cycles at 5–55 °C (B) Cyclic occlusal load: 100 N at 4 Hz for 100,000 cycles |
Universal testing machine | (A) Unifast Trad: 657.87 ± 82.84 (B) Protemp 4: 1125.94 ± 168.07 |
(C) Brylic Solid: 953.60 ± 58.88 | (D) Freeprint Temp: 1004.19 ± 122.18 |
|
Ibrahim et al., 2020 [38] | (A) Thermocycling: 1250 cycles at 5–55 °C (B) Mechanical aging: 50 N, 37,500 cycles |
Universal testing machine | N/A | (A) TelioCAD: 933.46 ± 104.49 |
(B) Next dent C&B resin: 1226.48 ± 48.33 |
|
Suralik et al., 2020 [39] | N/M | Universal Instron machine | (A) Jet:300.61 ± 98.94 | (B) Zirlux Temp: 294.64 ± 60.34 | (C) Freeprint Temp: 408.49 ± 132.16 |
|
Reymus et al., 2020 [40] | Artificial aging: stored in distilled water for 21 days at 37 °C in an incubator. | Universal testing machine | (A) Luxatemp: 551.7 ± 130 |
(B) Telio CAD: 881.4 ± 239.2 | Depending on type of post-curing unit used: [Otoflash (OF), Printbox (PB), Labolight (LL)] (C) Experimental: LL: 585.4 ± 66.8, OF: 746.4 ± 62.1, PB: 874.3 ± 104.0 (D) NextDent C&B LL: 775.9 ± 57.6, OF: 1050.4 ± 133.3, PB: 871.5 ± 398.1 (E) Freeprint temp LL: 777.6 ± 95.9, OF: 638.0 ± 175.5, PB: 598.6 ± 170.1 (F) 3Delta temp LL: 609.6 ± 118.8, OF: 868.2 ± 139.8, PB: 678.4 ± 193.7 |
|
Mayer et al., 2020 [50] | Three different cleaning methods for 3D printed specimens and chewing simulation (vertical load of 50 N and a lateral movement of 0.7 mm for 480,000 masticatory cycles) |
Universal testing machine | N/A | (A) Telio CAD: 1427 ± 77 | (B) Freeprint temp: 623 ± 156, 539 ± 152 & 615 ± 124 ((C) GC Temp PRINT: 878 ± 139, 796 ± 121, 831 ± 260 ((D) Next dent C&B MFH: 750 ± 156, 660 ± 198, 813 ± 157 |
|
Abad-Coronel et al., 2021 [46] | Thermocycling: 5000 cycles, at 5 °C and 55 °C in distilled water | Universal testing machine | N/A | (A) Vipiblock Trilux: 1663.57 ± 130.25 | PriZma 3D Bio Prov: 1437.74 ± 73.41 | FS: CAD/CAM Milled PMMA > 3D-Printed micro-hybrid resins |
Martín-Ortega et al., 2022 [52] | Thermocycling: 525,000 cycles, at 5 °C to 55 °C |
Universal testing machine | N/A | (A) and (C): Vivodent CAD Multi: Anterior group: 988.4 ± 54.8 Posterior group: 423.8 ± 68.0 |
(B) and (D): SHERAprint-cb: Anterior group: 636.5 ± 277.1 Posterior group: 321.3 ± 128.6 N |
FR: CAD/CAM Milled PMMA > 3D-Printed photopolymer resinFR: Anterior group > Posterior group |
Henderson et al., 2022 [51] |
Storage time in incubator (1 day or 30 days). | Universal testing machine | 3M-Paradigm: Loading Rate -Combined 1 and 10 mm/min Storage time: 1 day: 537 ± 117 N 30 Days: 572 ± 139 N |
Solid Shade PMMA Disc: Loading Rate -Combined 1 and 10 mm/Min Storage time: 1 day: 683 ± 115 N 30 Days: 547 ± 92 N |
Dentca Crown and Bridge resin: Loading Rate—Combined 1 and 10 mm/Min Storage time: 1 day: 522 ± 98 N 30 Days: 416 ± 109 N |
FaL: CAD/CAM Milled > Conventional > 3D-Printed |
N: Newton; N/A: Not Applicable; N/M: Not Mentioned; FS: Fracture Strength; FR: Fracture resistance; FL: Fracture load; FaL: Failure Load.