Table 2.
ML methods and evaluation metrics results extracted from the literature.
| Ref. | Methods used | Evaluation performance metrics | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Accuracy | Specificity | Sensitivity/recall | F1 | AUC | Precision | TPR | FPR | ||
| [16] | SVM | 98.11 | 0.9574 | 0.8888 | |||||
| NB | 96.22 | 0.93610 | 0.9696 | ||||||
| CNN | 99.53 | 1.0 | 0.9757 | ||||||
| LR | 96.69 | 0.9575 | 0.9696 | ||||||
| KNN | 95.75 | 0.9148 | 0.9696 | ||||||
| ANN | 97.64 | 0.9787 | 0.9757 | ||||||
| [59] | Decision tree | 91.1 | 0.71 | 0.91 | |||||
| [48] | SVM | 100% | |||||||
| NB | 97.017% | ||||||||
| Decision table | 100% | ||||||||
| [19] | Decision tree | FM = 89.1, SM = 89.3 | FM = 89.4, SM = 90.4 | FM = 70.8, SM = 66.6 | |||||
| AD Tree | FM = 88.7, SM = 88.4 | FM = 89.0, SM = 89.2 | FM = 81.8, SM = 72.3 | ||||||
| CDT | FM = 88.2, SM = 90.5 | FM = 89.3, SM = 89.6 | FM = 67.5, SM = 73.3 | ||||||
| J48 | FM = 88.8, SM = 91.7 | FM = 89.7, SM = 94.8 | FM = 73.0, SM = 71.7 | ||||||
| LAD Tree | FM = 89.2, SM = 87.55 | FM = 89.8, SM = 89.6 | FM = 63.3, SM = 55.0 | ||||||
| [62] | DENN | 0.99 | 0.99 | 0.99 | |||||
| NN | 0.94 | 0.94 | 0.94 | ||||||
| RF | 0.92 | 0.91 | 0.91 | ||||||
| SVM | 0.73 | 0.73 | 0.73 | ||||||
| Gradient boosting | 0.85 | 0.85 | 0.85 | ||||||
| [4] | SVM | 0.83 | 0.88 | 0.88 | 0.88 | 0.89 | |||
| NB | 0.89 | 0.84 | 0.91 | 0.91 | 1.0 | ||||
| RF | 0.93 | 1.0 | 0.96 | 0.96 | 0.92 | ||||
| KNN | 0.98 | 0.97 | 0.99 | 0.99 | 1.0 | ||||
| [1] | J48 | 98.44 | 0.984 | 0.984 | 0.984 | ||||
| LMT | 98.44 | 0.984 | 0.984 | 0.984 | |||||
| DS | 97.82 | 0.978 | 0.977 | 0.979 | |||||
| REP Tree | 97.66 | 0.977 | 0.976 | 0.977 | |||||
| NP Tree | 97.98 | 0.980 | 0.979 | 0.980 | |||||
| [53] | DT | Child = 82.76, adolescent = 83.87, adult = 91 | Overall % AVERAG = 84.71 | Overall % AVERAG = 86.45 | |||||
| NB | Child = 93.1, adolescent = 80.65, adult = 97.16 | Overall % AVERAG = 88.98 | Overall % AVERAG = 89.25 | ||||||
| KNN | Child = 86.21, adolescent = 87.1, adult = 93.36 | Overall % AVERAG = 88.90 | Overall % AVERAG = 91.87 | ||||||
| RT | Child = 67.82, adolescent = 77.4, adult = 72.99 | Overall % AVERAG = 62.72 | Overall % AVERAG = 56.43 | ||||||
| Deep learning | Child = 96.55, adolescent = 93.55, adult = 99.05 | Overall % AVERAG = 96.49 | Overall % AVERAG = 96.10 | ||||||
| [61] | LDA | 0.9080 | 0.8667 | 0.9524 | 0.9091 | 0.8696 | |||
| KNN | 0.8851 | 0.8000 | 0.9762 | 0.8913 | 0.8200 | ||||
| [63] | RF | 0.9571 | 0.9821 | 0.8571 | |||||
| [47] | DNN | 86.96 | Nonautism = 0.8000, mildautism = 0.8235, severe autism = 0.9474 | ||||||
| OVR-SVM | 56.52 | Nonautism = 0.571, mildautism = 0.6154, severe autism = 0.4615 | |||||||
| CART | 60.87 | Nonautism = 0.545, mildautism = 0.5556, severe autism = 0.7059 | |||||||
| [46] | LR | 0.97 | 0.97 | 0.97 | |||||
| [57] | DT | Child = 0.8226, adolescent = 0.80, adult = 0.8798 | Child = 0.8710, adolescent = 0.4444, adult = 0.9302 | Child = 0.7742, adolescent = 0.9375, adult = 0.7593 | Child = 0.8136, adolescent = 0.8571, adult = 0.7885 | Child = 0.8225, adolescent = 0.9375, adult = 0.8447 | |||
| RF | Child = 0.8226, adolescent = 0.88, adult = 0.9180 | Child = 0.8387, adolescent = 0.8889, adult = 0.9690 | Child = 0.8065, adolescent = 0.8750, adult = 0.8148 | Child = 0.8197, adolescent = 0.900, adult = 0.8544 | Child = 0.9433, adolescent = 0.9444, adult = 0.9812 | ||||
| RF (hyperparameter) | Child = 0.9032, adolescent = N/A, adult = 0.9727 | Child = 0.8701, adolescent = N/M, adult = 0.9922 | Child = 0.9355, adolescent = N/A, adult = 0.9259 | Child = 0.9062, adolescent = N/A, adult = 0.9524 | Child = 0.9977, adolescent = N/A, adult = 0.9977 | ||||
| LR | Child = 0.9032, adolescent = 0.92, adult = 0.9836 | Child = 0.8710, adolescent = 0.7778, adult = 0.9845 | Child = 0.9354, adolescent = 1.00, adult = 0.9814 | Child = 0.9062, adolescent = 0.9412, adult = 0.9725 | Child = 0.9865, adolescent = 0.9931, adult = 0.9959 | ||||
| SVM | Child = 0.9677, adolescent = 0.80, adult = 0.9235 | Child = 0.9355, adolescent = 0.4444, adult = 0.9690 | Child = 1.00, adolescent = 1.00, adult = 0.8148 | Child = 0.9688, adolescent = 0.8649, adult = 0.8627 | Child = 0.9896, adolescent = 0.9861, adult = 0.9886 | ||||
| ANN | Child = 0.9516, adolescent = 0.76, adult = 0.9891 | Child = 0.9355, adolescent = 0.8125, adult = 0.9922 | Child = 0.9677, adolescent = 0.9815, adult = 0.9815 | Child = 0.9508, adolescent = 0.8125, adult = 0.9815 | Child = 0.9896, adolescent = 0.9861, adult = 0.9887 | ||||
| [64] | DNN | Dataset1 = 90.4, Dataset2 = 96.08 | Dataset1 = 100, Dataset2 = 97.32 | Dataset1 = 97.89, Dataset2 = 92.68 | |||||
| SVM | Dataset1 = 95.24, Dataset2 = 95.08 | N/A | N/A | ||||||
| [15] | ANN | Toddlers = 0.9896, child = 0.9589, adolescent = 0.903, adult = 0.9901 | Toddlers = 0.9886, child = 0.9593, adolescent = 0.8948, adult = 0.9964 | Toddlers = 0.9886, child = 0.9589, adolescent = 0.9038, adult = 0.9901 | Toddlers = 0.9896, child = 0.9589, adolescent = 0.9038, adult = 0.9901 | Toddlers = 0.9891, child = 0.9591, adolescent = 0.8993, adult = 0.9932 | |||
| RNN | Toddlers = 0.9943, child = 0.9726, adolescent = 0.884, adult = 0.9673 | Toddlers = 0.9924, child = 0.9721, adolescent = 0.8823, adult = 0.9110 | Toddlers = 0.9943, child = 0.9726, adolescent = 0.8846, adult = 0.9673 | Toddlers = 0.9943, child = 0.9726, adolescent = 0.8851, adult = 0.9666 | Toddlers = 0.9933, child = 0.9723, adolescent = 0.8835, adult = 0.9392 | ||||
| DT | Toddlers = 0.9175, child = 0.8938, adolescent = 0.759, adult = 0.9062 | Toddlers = 0.8885, child = 0.8938, adolescent = 0.6817, adult = 0.8450 | Toddlers = 0.9175, child = 0.8938, adolescent = 0.7596, adult = 0.9062 | Toddlers = 0.9174, child = 0.8938, adolescent = 0.7482, adult = 0.9058 | Toddlers = 0.9030, child = 0.8938, adolescent = 0.7207, adult = 0.8756 | ||||
| ELM | Toddlers = 0.9231, child = 0.8973, adolescent = 0.826, adult = 0.9190 | Toddlers = 0.8860, child = 0.8965, adolescent = 0.8363, adult = 8531 | Toddlers = 0.9231, child = 0.8973, adolescent = 0.8269, adult = 0.9190 | Toddlers = 0.9227, child = 0.8972, adolescent = 0.8285, adult = 0.9181 | Toddlers = 0.9046, child = 0.8969, adolescent = 0.8316, adult = 0.8860 | ||||
| GB | Toddlers = 0.9782, child = 0.9315, adolescent = 0.8750, adult = 0.9659 | Toddlers = 0.9665, child = 0.9318, adolescent = 0.8335, adult = 0.9306 | Toddlers = 0.9782, child = 0.9315, adolescent = 0.8750, adult = 0.9659 | Toddlers = 0.9781, child = 0.8915, adolescent = 0.8725, adult = 0.9656 | Toddlers = 0.9723, child = 0.9317, adolescent = 0.8542, adult = 0.9482 | ||||
| KNN | Toddlers = 0.9488, child = 0.8904, adolescent = 0.8077, adult = 0.9432 | Toddlers = 0.9398, child = 0.8953, adolescent = 0.7130, adult = 0.9289 | Toddlers = 0.9488, child = 0.8904, adolescent = 0.8077, adult = 0.9432 | Toddlers = 0.9490, child = 0.8901, adolescent = 0.7927, adult = 0.9436 | Toddlers = 0.9443, child = 0.8929, adolescent = 0.7604, adult = 0.9360 | ||||
| LR | Toddlers = 1.0, child = 0.9932, adolescent = 0.951, adult = 0.9986 | Toddlers = 1.0, child = 0.9927, adolescent = 0.9346, adult = 0.9961 | Toddlers = 1.0, child = 0.9932, adolescent = 0.9519, adult = 0.9986 | Toddlers = 1.0, child = 0.9931, adolescent = 0.9516, adult = 0.9986 | Toddlers = 1.0, child = 0.9929, adolescent = 0.9433, adult = 0.9974 | ||||
| MLP | Toddlers = 0.9991, child = 0.9863, adolescent = 0.942, adult = 0.9957 | Toddlers = 0.9996, child = 0.9858, adolescent = 0.9199, adult = 0.9951 | Toddlers = 0.9991, child = 0.9863, adolescent = 0.9423, adult = 0.9957 | Toddlers = 0.9991, child = 0.9863, adolescent = 0.9417, adult = 0.9957 | Toddlers = 0.9993, child = 0.9861, adolescent = 0.9311, adult = 0.9954 | ||||
| NB | Toddlers = 0.9431, child = 0.8664, adolescent = 0.855, adult = 0.9418 | Toddlers = 0.9152, child = 0.8635, adolescent = 0.8380, adult = 0.9150 | Toddlers = 0.9431, child = 0.8664, adolescent = 0.8558, adult = 0.9418 | Toddlers = 0.9428, child = 0.8661, adolescent = 0.8554, adult = 0.9419 | Toddlers = 0.9291, child = 8650, adolescent = 0.8469, adult = 0.9284 | ||||
| RF | Toddlers = 0.9592, child = 0.9110, adolescent = 0.894, adult = 0.9588 | Toddlers = 0.9343, child = 0.9098, adolescent = 0.8630, adult = 0.9112 | Toddlers = 0.9592, child = 0.9110, adolescent = 0.8942, adult = 0.9588 | Toddlers = 0.9590, child = 0.9109, adolescent = 0.8928, adult = 0.9583 | Toddlers = 0.9468, child = 0.9104, adolescent = 0.8786, adult = 0.9350 | ||||
| SVM | Toddlers = 0.9753, child = 0.9452, adolescent = 0.894, adult = 0.9716 | Toddlers = 0.9568, child = 0.9446, adolescent = 0.8545, adult = 0.9393 | Toddlers = 0.9753, child = 0.9452, adolescent = 0.8942, adult = 0.9716 | Toddlers = 0.9752, child = 0.9452, adolescent = 0.8921, adult = 0.9713 | Toddlers = 0.9661, child = 0.9449, adolescent = 0.8744, adult = 0.9555 | ||||
| XGB | Toddlers = 0.9820, child = 0.9555, adolescent = 0.913, adult = 0.9659 | Toddlers = 0.9767, child = 0.9556, adolescent = 0.8755, adult = 0.9406 | Toddlers = 0.9820, child = 0.9555, adolescent = 0.9135, adult = 0.9659 | Toddlers = 0.9820, child = 0.9555, adolescent = 0.9117, adult = 0.9658 | Toddlers = 0.9793, child = 0.9555, adolescent = 0.8945, adult = 0.9533 | ||||
| [54] | KNN | 67.5564 | |||||||
| LR | 72.0238 | ||||||||
| SVM | 70.5952 | ||||||||
| LDA | 72.2024 | ||||||||
| NB | 70.7769 | ||||||||
| Classification and regression tree | 69.1667 | ||||||||
| [60] | WOEM | 99 | 98 | 98 | |||||
| SLFN(ELM) | 96 | 96 | 96 | ||||||
| SVM | 94 | 96.5 | 96.5 | ||||||
| ANN | 90 | 95 | 95 | ||||||
| KNN | 95 | 97 | 97 | ||||||
| [55] | DT | 2K‐fold = 100, 3K‐fold = 100, 4K‐fold = 100, 5K‐fold = 100, 6K‐fold = 100, 7K‐fold = 100, 8K‐fold = 100‐‐fold = 100 | |||||||
| LDA | 2K‐fold = 96.3, 3K‐fold = 96.7, 4K‐fold = 96.7, 5K‐fold = 96.7, 6K‐fold = 96.6, 7K‐fold = 96.9, 8K‐fold = 96.7, 9K‐fold = 96.9, 10K‐fold = 96.9 | ||||||||
| LR | 2K‐fold = 99.7, 3K‐fold = 99.7, 4K‐fold = 99.6, 5K‐fold = 99.6, 6K‐fold = 99.6, 7K‐fold = 99.6, 8K‐fold = 99.6, 9K‐fold = 99.6, 10K‐fold = 99.6 | ||||||||
| SVM | 2K‐fold = 99.3, 3K‐fold = 99.3, 4K‐fold = 98.9, 5K‐fold = 99.3, 6K‐fold = 99.4, 7K‐fold = 99.6, 8K‐fold = 99.4, 9K‐fold = 99.9, 10K‐fold = 99.9 | ||||||||
| KNN | 2K‐old = 92.8, 3K‐fold = 94, 4K‐fold = 93, 5K‐fold = 93.8, 6K‐fold = 92.9, 7K‐fold = 933, 8K‐fold = 94.2, 9K‐fold = 93.9, 10K‐fold = 92.9 | ||||||||
| [44] | RF | Child = 1.0, adolescent = 0.976, adult = 0.992 | Child = 0.993, adolescent = 0.976, adult = 0.993 | Child = 1.0, adolescent = 0.977, adult = 0.993 | |||||
| LR | Child = 0.923, adolescent = 0.881, adult = 0.94 | Child = 0.923, adolescent = 0.881, adult = 0.94 | Child = 0.923, adolescent = 0.908, adult = 0.94 | ||||||
| NB | Child = 0.983, adolescent = 1.0, adult = 0.986 | Child = 0.983, adolescent = 1.0, adult = 0.986 | Child = 0.984, adolescent = 1.0, adult = 0.986 | ||||||
| MCR with average of probabilities | Child = 0.932, adolescent = 0.93, adult = 0.996 | Child = 0.932, adolescent = 0.929, adult = 0.996 | Child = 0.932, adolescent = 0.939, adult = 0.996 | ||||||
| MCR with majority voting | Child = 0.983, adolescent = 1.0, adult = 1.0 | Child = 0.983, adolescent = 1.0, adult = 1.0 | Child = 0.984, adolescent = 1.0, adult = 1.0 | ||||||
| [5] | J48 | Child = 92, adolescent = 81adult = 93, complete = 92 | Child = 93, adolescent = 83, adult = 86, complete = 87 | Child = 91, adolescent = 76, adult = 96, complete = 94 | |||||
| RF | Child = 93, adolescent = 92, adult = 96, complete = 95 | Child = 92, adolescent = 91, adult = 93, complete = 94 | Child = 95, adolescent = 94, adult = 93, complete = 92 | ||||||
| Bayes | Child = 96, adolescent = 92, adult = 97, complete = 96 | Child = 95, adolescent = 91, adult = 93, complete = 92 | Child = 97, adolescent = 95, adult = 98, complete = 98 | ||||||
| Adaboost | Child = 90, adolescent = 89, adult = 94, complete = 92 | Child = 86, adolescent = 86, adult = 87, complete = 84 | Child = 95, adolescent = 95, adult = 93, complete = 92 | ||||||
| PART | Child = 92, adolescent = 85, adult = 94, complete = 95 | Child = 90, adolescent = 86, adult = 88, complete = 94 | Child = 90, adolescent = 86, adult = 87.5, complete = 94 | ||||||
| ANN | Child = 92, adolescent = 87, adult = 96, complete = 95.5 | Child = 90, adolescent = 84, adult = 94, complete = 95 | Child = 90, adolescent = 84, adult = 94.5, complete = 95 | ||||||
| SVM | Child = 94, adolescent = 93, adult = 97, complete = 97 | Child = 94, adolescent = 90, adult = 95, complete = 96 | Child = 94, adolescent = 90, adult = 95, complete = 96 | ||||||
| AttSelclasss | Child = 93, adolescent = 85, adult = 96, complete = 97 | Child = 97.5, adolescent = 86, adult = 99, complete = 98 | Child = 97, adolescent = 86, adult = 99, complete = 98 | ||||||
| [42] | FARF (combined Firefly-Random Forest) | 94.32 | 35.10 | ||||||
| RF | 90.78 | 34.09 | |||||||
| [45] | ANN | 83 | 83.5 | 84 | 85 | 83 | |||
| SVM | 91 | 86.5 | 86 | 86 | 86 | ||||
| IANFIS | 98 | 90 | 91 | 92 | 89 | ||||
| [56] | SVM-NP | 95.547 | 0.940 | 0.956 | 0.973 | ||||
| SVM-PK | 100 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | |||||
| SVM-PUK | 100 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | |||||
| SVM-RBF | 99.315 | 0.993 | 0.993 | 0.993 | |||||
| [58] | SVM | Adolescent = 59.6154, child = 53.0822, adult = 69.7443 | |||||||
| Active pruning rules (APR) | Adolescent = 66.3462, child = 60.9589, adult = 73.7216 | ||||||||
| RKFNN | Adolescent = 72.1154, child = 71.2329, adult = 80.2257 | ||||||||
| [65] | BFNNRELU | Child = 98.73, adolescent = 94.32, adult = 97.28 | Child = 0.9678, adolescent = 0.9380, adult = 0.9601 | Child = 0.9716, adolescent = 0.9571, adult = 0.9601 | Child = 0.9697, adolescent = 0.9475, adult = 0.9559 | ||||
| ANFAND | Child = 73.63, adolescent = 81.50, adult = 95.57 | Child = 0.7333, adolescent = 0.9259, adult = 0.8976 | Child = 0.5236, adolescent = 0.6758, adult = 0.8976 | Child = 0.6577, adolescent = 0.8061, adult = 0.9379 | |||||
| SVM | Child = 98.67, adolescent = 89.26, adult = 94.21 | Child = 0.9872, adolescent = 0.8745, adult = 0.8946 | Child = 0.9954, adolescent = 0.9452, adult = 0.8946 | Child = 0.9913, adolescent = 0.9098, adult = 0.9350 | |||||
| MLP | Child = 99.05, adolescent = 90.28, adult = 99.91 | Child = 0.9952, adolescent = 0.9402, adult = 0.9977 | Child = 0.9860, adolescent = 0.8451, adult = 0.9977 | Child = 0.9906, adolescent = 0.8926, adult = 0.9986 | |||||
| NB | Child = 99.82, adolescent = 93.35, adult = 96.51 | Child = 1.0, adolescent = 0.9947, adult = 0.9846 | Child = 1.0, adolescent = 0.9152, adult = 0.9846 | Child = 1.0, adolescent = 0.9459, adult = 0.9781 | |||||
| C4.5 | Child = 94.86, adolescent = 89.13, adult = 91.86 | Child = 0.7854, adolescent = 0.8851, adult = 0.7500 | Child = 0.9987, adolescent = 0.8926, adult = 0.7500 | Child = 0.8920, adolescent = 0.8885, adult = 0.8750 | |||||
| RNT | Child = 91.61, adolescent = 87.88, adult = 95.30 | Child = 0.9108, adolescent = 0.9313, adult = 0.9065 | Child = 0.9210, adolescent = 0.7963, adult = 0.9065 | Child = 0.9259, adolescent = 0.8638, adult = 0.9382 | |||||
| [40] | MCFM | 0.842 | 0.843 | ||||||
| SVM | 0.833 | 0.833 | |||||||
| RF | 0.851 | 0.852 | |||||||
| NB | 0.865 | 0.865 | |||||||
FM: family medical history; SM: subject medical history.