Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 7;12:20451253221104958. doi: 10.1177/20451253221104958

Table 2.

Summary of results of included trials.

Study (country) Intervention Outcome time point Group p Retention
Intervention Control Intervention Control
Aguinaga et al. (USA) 36 Flexibility, Toning and Balance DVD versus Healthy Aging DVD HADS-A 0.30 50% 91%
Baseline 9.3 11.4
6 months 5.3 8.9
Change –4 –2.5
Carmeli et al. (Israel) 37 Aerobic Training versus Non-physical Activities HAM-A a ⩽0.05 75% 75%
Baseline 8 8
6 months 4 8
Change –4 0
Song et al. (China) 34 Tai Chi with Paroxetine versus Paroxetine Only HAM-A <0.05 NS NS
Baseline 19.4 19.7
45 days 10.7 14.5
Change –8.7 –5.2
Villaverde Gutiérrez et al. (Spain) 38 Aerobic and Strength Training versus Inactive Control HAM-A 90% 100%
Minor (6–14)
Baseline 7.33 7.2
6 months 5.27 7.1
Change –2.06 –0.08 <0.01
HAM-A
Major (>14)
Baseline 16.8 16.4
6 months 15.0 17.0
Change –1.74 0.64 <0.05
GDS
Moderate (11–14)
Baseline 12.0 11.9
6 months 9.76 11.9
Change –2.26 0.06 <0.05
GDS
Severe (15–30)
Baseline 17.3 17.2
6 months 13.5 16.9
Change –3.85 –0.38 <0.01

GDS, Geriatric Depression Scale; HADS-A, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale – Anxiety Subscale; HAM-A, Hamilton Anxiety Scale; NS, not stated.

a

HAM-A scale adapted for participants with Intellectual Disability.