Table 1.
Model | Country of development | Development population | Predicted outcome | Predictors | Model type | Estimation method |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bello-Chavolla et al14 | Mexico | All reported confirmed cases of covid-19, including hospital admission, ICU admission, and outpatient treatment. | 30 day mortality | Age, diabetes (type 2), obesity (clinician- defined), pneumonia, chronic kidney disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, immunosuppression | Score | Rounding of Cox regression coefficients (unpenalised) |
Xie et al33 | China | Adults (≥18 years) with confirmed covid-19, admitted in officially designated covid-19 treatment centres | In-hospital mortality | Age, lactate dehydrogenase, lymphocyte count, oxygen saturation | Prediction model | Logistic regression (unpenalised) |
Hu et al34 | China | Patients with severe covid-19 in Tongji Hospital, which specifically accommodated for people with covid-19. Patients directly admitted to intensive care unit were excluded. Patients with certain comorbidities (including cancer, uraemia, aplastic anaemia) were also excluded. Patients with a short hospital stay (<7 days) were excluded | In-hospital mortality | Age, high sensitivity C reactive protein, D-dimer, lymphocyte count | Prediction model | Logistic regression (unpenalised) |
Zhang et al DCS and DCSL models35 | China | Adults (≥18 years) admitted to two hospitals | In-hospital mortality | DCS model: Age, sex, diabetes (unspecified), immunocompromised, malignancy, hypertension, heart disease, chronic kidney disease, cough, dyspnoea DCSL model: Age, sex, chronic lung disease, diabetes (unspecified), malignancy, cough, dyspnoea, neutrophil count, lymphocyte count, platelet count, C reactive protein, creatinine |
Prediction model | Logistic regression (lasso penalty) |
Knight et al 4C Mortality Score36 | UK | Adults (≥18 years) admitted across 260 hospitals | In-hospital mortality | Age, sex, number of comorbidities (chronic cardiac disease, respiratory disease, renal disease, liver disease, neurological conditions; dementia; connective tissue disease; diabetes (type 1 and 2); AIDS/HIV; malignancy, obesity), respiratory rate, oxygen saturation (room air), Glasgow coma scale score, urea, C reactive protein | Score | Rounding of logistic regression coefficients (lasso penalty) |
Wang et al clinical and laboratory models37 | China | Adults (≥18 years) admitted to hospital. Pregnant women were excluded | In-hospital mortality | Clinical model: Age, history of hypertension, history of heart disease Laboratory model: Age, oxygen saturation, neutrophil count, lymphocyte count, high sensitivity C reactive protein, D-dimer, aspartate aminotransferase, glomerular filtration rate |
Prediction model | Logistic regression (unpenalised). Intercept from nomogram |