Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 13;18(7):e11017. doi: 10.15252/msb.202211017

Table 2.

Methods/studies that map cell lines to tumours.

Reference Data Input Multi‐omic integration Application Unsupervised/Supervised Clustering/subtype Method
CCL—Tumour integration Scoring CCL Selecting CCL
Warren et al (2021) (Celligner) GE Pan‐cancer Unsupervised Subtype Contrastive PCA + Mutual Nearest Neighbour Pearson corr. on aligned space
Assignment by k‐NN
Peng et al (2021) (CancerCellNet) GE Pan‐cancer Supervised Subtype Classification score Multi‐class Random Forest
“Correct” class: classification score > thr in actual type

Sinha et al (2021)

(TumorComparer)

GE, CNA, Mut Late Pan‐cancer (independent) Unsupervised Subtype Aggregated ranking of weighted Pearson's corr./Jaccard Index

Zhang & Kschischo (2021)

(MFmap)

GE, CNA, Mut Intermediate Pan‐cancer (independent) Supervised (subtype) Subtype ComBat (GE) Cosine coefficient (latent space) Neural network classifier on latent space
Concatenated VAE
Fang et al (2021) PE Thyroid Carcinoma Unsupervised Subtype Pearson's corr.

Najgebauer et al (2020)

(CELLector)

CNA, Mut, HypMet Early Pan‐cancer (independent) Unsupervised Clustering Signature length times fraction of samples in group Eclat clustering
Map by decision tree

Salvadores et al (2020)

(HyperTracker)

GE, HypMet Late Pan‐cancer Supervised Subtype ComBat Binomial ridge regression
“Golden set” from matching data modalities
Batchu et al (2020) GE Alveolar Rhabdomyosarcoma Unsupervised Spearman's corr.

Yu et al (2019)

(CompHealth)

GE Pan‐cancer (independent) Unsupervised Subtype ComBat Spearman's corr. TCGA‐110‐CL panel: 5 highest score per type
Supervised (subtype)
Liu, et al (2019a) GE, CNA, Mut Metastatic Breast Cancer Unsupervised Subtype Spearman's corr. (GE and CNA)

Ronen et al (2019)

(Maui)

GE, CNA, Mut Intermediate Colorectal cancer Unsupervised Clustering Multimodal stacked VAE Euclidean distance (latent space) K‐means clustering (latent space)
at least 1 of 5 NN being tumour
Zhao et al (2017) GE, CNA, Mut Late Pan‐cancer (independent) Unsupervised Subtype Distance weighted discrimination Kendall Rank corr. (GE and CNA) Similarity in at least 3 out of 4 modalities
Gene Ontology enrichment score
Mutation presence
Luebker et al (2017) CNA, Mut Melanoma Unsupervised Fraction of genome altered
Pearson's corr. (CN)
Vincent & Postovit (2017) GE Melanoma Unsupervised Subtype Pearson's corr.
Sinha et al (2017) GE, CNA, Mut Renal Cancer Unsupervised Clustering/Subtype ComBat Hierarchical clustering (Spearman corr., CN)
Supervised (subtype) PAMR classifier (Spearman corr., GE)
Jiang et al (2016) GE, CNA, Mut, PE Late Breast Cancer Unsupervised Clustering/Subtype Sum Pearson corr. Hierarchical clustering (PE, GE)
Sun & Liu (2015) GE, CNA Late Breast Cancer Unsupervised Subtype Aggregated ranking of Spearman's corr.
Vincent et al (2015) GE Breast Cancer Unsupervised Subtype Pearson's corr. (group specific)
Chen et al (2015) GE Hepatocellar Carcinoma Unsupervised Spearman corr.
Sadanandam et al (2013) GE Colorectal cancer Unsupervised Clustering Distance weighted discrimination SAM and PAM for feature extraction
Consensus‐based NMF
Domcke et al (2013) GE, CNA, Mut Late Ovarian Cancer Unsupervised Subtype sum: CNA Pearson corr. and Mut presence/absence GE for validation: hierarchical clustering
Virtanen et al (2002) GE Lung Cancer Unsupervised Clustering Lowess normalisation Hierarchical clustering
Comparison with known label

CCL, cancer cell line; CNA, copy number alterations; GE, gene expression; HypMetm DNA methylation; Mut, somatic mutations; PE, protein expression.