Table 2.
Reference | Data Input | Multi‐omic integration | Application | Unsupervised/Supervised | Clustering/subtype | Method | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CCL—Tumour integration | Scoring CCL | Selecting CCL | ||||||
Warren et al (2021) (Celligner) | GE | – | Pan‐cancer | Unsupervised | Subtype | Contrastive PCA + Mutual Nearest Neighbour | Pearson corr. on aligned space | – |
Assignment by k‐NN | ||||||||
Peng et al (2021) (CancerCellNet) | GE | – | Pan‐cancer | Supervised | Subtype | – | Classification score | Multi‐class Random Forest |
“Correct” class: classification score > thr in actual type | ||||||||
Sinha et al (2021) (TumorComparer) |
GE, CNA, Mut | Late | Pan‐cancer (independent) | Unsupervised | Subtype | – | Aggregated ranking of weighted Pearson's corr./Jaccard Index | – |
Zhang & Kschischo (2021) (MFmap) |
GE, CNA, Mut | Intermediate | Pan‐cancer (independent) | Supervised (subtype) | Subtype | ComBat (GE) | Cosine coefficient (latent space) | Neural network classifier on latent space |
Concatenated VAE | ||||||||
Fang et al (2021) | PE | – | Thyroid Carcinoma | Unsupervised | Subtype | – | Pearson's corr. | – |
Najgebauer et al (2020) (CELLector) |
CNA, Mut, HypMet | Early | Pan‐cancer (independent) | Unsupervised | Clustering | – | Signature length times fraction of samples in group | Eclat clustering |
Map by decision tree | ||||||||
Salvadores et al (2020) (HyperTracker) |
GE, HypMet | Late | Pan‐cancer | Supervised | Subtype | ComBat | – | Binomial ridge regression |
“Golden set” from matching data modalities | ||||||||
Batchu et al (2020) | GE | – | Alveolar Rhabdomyosarcoma | Unsupervised | – | – | Spearman's corr. | – |
Yu et al (2019) (CompHealth) |
GE | – | Pan‐cancer (independent) | Unsupervised | Subtype | ComBat | Spearman's corr. | TCGA‐110‐CL panel: 5 highest score per type |
Supervised (subtype) | ||||||||
Liu, et al (2019a) | GE, CNA, Mut | – | Metastatic Breast Cancer | Unsupervised | Subtype | – | Spearman's corr. (GE and CNA) | – |
Ronen et al (2019) (Maui) |
GE, CNA, Mut | Intermediate | Colorectal cancer | Unsupervised | Clustering | Multimodal stacked VAE | Euclidean distance (latent space) | K‐means clustering (latent space) |
at least 1 of 5 NN being tumour | ||||||||
Zhao et al (2017) | GE, CNA, Mut | Late | Pan‐cancer (independent) | Unsupervised | Subtype | Distance weighted discrimination | Kendall Rank corr. (GE and CNA) | Similarity in at least 3 out of 4 modalities |
Gene Ontology enrichment score | ||||||||
Mutation presence | ||||||||
Luebker et al (2017) | CNA, Mut | – | Melanoma | Unsupervised | – | – | Fraction of genome altered | – |
Pearson's corr. (CN) | ||||||||
Vincent & Postovit (2017) | GE | – | Melanoma | Unsupervised | Subtype | – | Pearson's corr. | – |
Sinha et al (2017) | GE, CNA, Mut | – | Renal Cancer | Unsupervised | Clustering/Subtype | ComBat | – | Hierarchical clustering (Spearman corr., CN) |
Supervised (subtype) | PAMR classifier (Spearman corr., GE) | |||||||
Jiang et al (2016) | GE, CNA, Mut, PE | Late | Breast Cancer | Unsupervised | Clustering/Subtype | – | Sum Pearson corr. | Hierarchical clustering (PE, GE) |
Sun & Liu (2015) | GE, CNA | Late | Breast Cancer | Unsupervised | Subtype | – | Aggregated ranking of Spearman's corr. | – |
Vincent et al (2015) | GE | – | Breast Cancer | Unsupervised | Subtype | ‐ | Pearson's corr. (group specific) | ‐ |
Chen et al (2015) | GE | – | Hepatocellar Carcinoma | Unsupervised | – | – | Spearman corr. | – |
Sadanandam et al (2013) | GE | – | Colorectal cancer | Unsupervised | Clustering | Distance weighted discrimination | – | SAM and PAM for feature extraction |
Consensus‐based NMF | ||||||||
Domcke et al (2013) | GE, CNA, Mut | Late | Ovarian Cancer | Unsupervised | Subtype | ‐ | sum: CNA Pearson corr. and Mut presence/absence | GE for validation: hierarchical clustering |
Virtanen et al (2002) | GE | – | Lung Cancer | Unsupervised | Clustering | Lowess normalisation | – | Hierarchical clustering |
Comparison with known label |
CCL, cancer cell line; CNA, copy number alterations; GE, gene expression; HypMetm DNA methylation; Mut, somatic mutations; PE, protein expression.