Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 21;3(1):240–247. doi: 10.1089/neur.2022.0008

Table 2.

Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria for Source Literature

PICOTS Inclusion Exclusion
Populations All ages
Penetrating brain injury including blast, tangential, and perforating injury from missiles, blast fragments, or low velocity
 • All baseline GCS levels
 • Mixed types of brain injury with at least 85% penetrating if results not reported individually
• Non-human studies
• Injury limited to linear, non-displaced skull fracture or isolated face/neck injuries
• Mixed types of brain injury and results not presented by injury type or <85% penetrating injury
Interventions Pre-hospital, prolonged field care, transport, ED, and trauma center evaluation:
• Initial resuscitation and prevention/mitigation of secondary injury
• On-scene wound management
• Cervical spine immobilization
Surgical management:
• Prevention and treatment of cerebrospinal fluid leaks
• Vascular injuries
• Foreign body removal and prerequisites
• Cranial decompression
Medical management:
• Intracranial pressure monitoring (if distinct from fourth edition)
• Intracranial pressure treatment (hyperosmolar therapy, lumbar drainage, CPP management including BP thresholds, ventilation therapies)
• Seizure prophylaxis
• Antibiotic prophylaxis
• DVT prophylaxis
• Chemoprophylaxis for stroke prevention
 
Comparators Placebo, no intervention, active control, waitlist control, delayed treatment, head-to-head studies None
Outcomes • Mortality
• Neurological function
• Selected morbidity
• Cost
• Satisfaction
• Quality of life
• Sleep
Timing Outcomes up to 1 year post-injury Outcomes >1 year post-injury
Setting Pre-hospital, trauma center, medical, surgical setting in all countries. Battlefield and mass causality as well as civilian • Rehabilitation setting
Study designs • All experimental study designs, observational studies including case series and case report
• Epidemiological studies for salvageability
• Current, well-conducted systematic reviews (may also use systematic reviews to identify studies searches may have missed)
• Abstracts, comments letters
• Non-English language
• Narrative reviews
• Systematic reviews not meeting inclusion criteria

BP, blood pressure; CPP, cerebral perfusion pressure; DVT, deep vein thrombosis; GCS, Glasgow Coma Scale.