Table 1:
Summary of studies to date exploring epidural stimulation for blood pressure instability following spinal cord injury.
Orthostatic Hypotension management with Spinal Cord Electrical Stimulation | |||||
Study Author (date) | Number of Subjects/Animal Model | Participant Characteristics (human only) | Spinal Level of Stimulation, Frequency and Current | Measured Outcomes | Major Findings |
Aslan et al. (2018) | N=3 hypotensive humans, N=4 normotensive humans | NLI= C5-T4 AIS= A, B Mean TSI= 2.7 years Mean Age= 26.7 years |
L1-S1 epidural stimulation, 15–35 Hz, unknown mA | Arterial blood pressure during supine and manually assisted sitting. | Stimulation in three individuals with OH resulted in increased arterial blood pressure. Stimulation in four individuals without OH did not cause an increase in blood pressure. |
Darrow et al. (2019) | N=2 humans | NLI= T4, T8 AIS= A Mean TSI= 7.5 years Mean Age= 50 years |
L2-S2 epidural stimulation, 16–400 Hz, 2–15 mA | Arterial blood pressure during tilt challenge | Stimulation in one individual with OH resulted in increased blood pressure, while stimulation in another individual without OH did not affect cardiovascular function. |
Harkema et al. (2018a) | N=4 humans | NLI= C4 AIS= A, B Mean TSI= 6.5 years Mean Age= 30.8 years |
L1-S1 epidural stimulation, 30–60 Hz, unknown mA | Mean arterial blood pressure and heart rate in an upright, seated position. | Stimulation increased mean arterial pressure and decreased or kept heart rate constant. |
Legg Ditterline et al. (2021) | N=4 humans † same individuals as Harkema et al. (2018a) | NLI= C4 AIS= A, B Mean TSI= 6.5 years Mean Age= 30.8 years |
L1-S1 epidural stimulation, unknown Hz, unknown mA | Blood and heart rate variability, as well as baroreflex function with an orthostatic stress test. Circulating norepinephrine levels. | Stimulation increased blood pressure, heart rate variability and baroreceptor effectiveness. Norepinephrine levels unable to be detected at all time points, with and without stimulation. |
Phillips et al. (2018) | N=5 humans | NLI= C5-T2 AIS= A, B Mean TSI= >3 years Mean Age= ? (range 23–32 years) |
T8 transcutaneous stimulation, 30 Hz, up to 70 mA | Beat-to-beat blood pressure, heart rate during supine and manually assisted sitting. Blood flow velocity of MCA and PCA. Subjective rating of nausea/dizziness. | Stimulation increased blood pressure, heart rate, and MCA/PCA flow velocity compared nadir of orthostatic challenge. Decreased subjective ratings. |
Squair et al. (2021) | N=3 rhesus monkeys N=1 human |
NLI= C5 AIS= A TSI= ? Age= 38 years |
T10-L1 epidural stimulation, 120 Hz, 0–7.5 mV variable | Beat-to-beat blood pressure, muscle sympathetic nerve activity, supine and in 70º tilt table. Circulating norepinephrine levels. | Blood pressure increased in proportion to calibrated stimulation. Reported increases in sympathetic nerve activity on microneurography and norepinephrine levels. |
West et al. (2018) | N=1 human | NLI= C5 AIS= B TSI= ? Age= “early 30s” |
T10-L2 epidural stimulation, 35 Hz constant, unknown mA | Beat-to-beat blood pressure, cardiac function in a supine position and then in response to a 60º head-up tilt. | Stimulation increased blood pressure and resolved OH. |
Autonomic Dysreflexia management with Spinal Cord Electrical Stimulation | |||||
Study Author (date) | Number of Subjects/Animal Model | Participant Characteristics (humans only) | Spinal Level of Stimulation, Frequency and Current | Measured Outcomes | Major Findings |
Collins et al. (2002) | N=11 rats | NA | T12-S3 TENS stimulation, 60 Hz, 600 μA | Blood pressure response to graded colon distension triggering AD with and without stimulation. | Attenuated the hemodynamic response to colon distension and decreased the change in arterial blood pressure. |
Richardson et al. (1979) | N=5 humans | NLI*= ? AIS*= ? Mean TSI= 2.0 years Mean Age= 20.6 years |
T12-L3 epidural stimulation, 7–200 Hz, 0.1–14V | Clinical findings only. | Case studies of five individuals with AD. Stimulation prevented further episodes of AD. |
Sachdeva et al. (2021) | N= 43 rats N=1 human |
NLI= C4 AIS= A TSI= 3 years Age= 37 years |
T7–8 transcutaneous stimulation, 30 Hz, 20–30 mA (biphasic pulses) | Beat-to-beat blood pressure, heart rate during digital anorectal stimulation. | Prevention of AD and decrease in systolic pressure with stimulation compared to control. |
NLI = neurological level of injury. AIS = American Spinal Injury Impairment Scale. TSI = time since injury. OH = orthostatic hypotension. MCA = middle cerebral artery. PCA = posterior cerebral artery. AD = autonomic dysreflexia. TENS = transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation.
Based upon clinical data presented, predates AIS.