Table I.
Availability and properties of HT glycomics approaches.
Analyte | Pro | Con | Method | Speed | Precision | Structural resolution | Tools for structure and composition assignment | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Glycan | • Generic approach • Methods available for absolute quantification • High sensitivity • Highest precision and robustness • High level of isomer differentiation |
• Sample purity is essential • Information on site- and protein- specificity lost • HT only for N-glycans |
HILIC– UHPLC–FLD |
• 1 sample/ 30 min • 96 samples/ 48 h |
Average CV of the 10 most abundant peaks over 2 96-well plates: 1.6% |
• Differentiation of various constitutional isomers • Sialic acid linkage differentiation for diantennary glycans |
• Retention time • (Tandem) MS • Exoglycosidases |
(Huffman et al. 2014; Adamczyk et al. 2017; Reiding et al. 2019) |
CGE–LIF | • 1 sample/ 45 min • 96 samples/ 3 h with 24-capillary CGE |
Average CV of the 10 most abundant peaks over 2 96-well plates: 6.9% |
• Migration position • Exoglycosidases |
(Callewaert et al. 2004; Ruhaak et al. 2010; Huffman et al. 2014; Reiding et al. 2019) |
||||
MALDI–MS | • 1 sample/ 30 s • 96 samples/ 48 min |
Average CV of the 10 most abundant peaks over 2 96-well plates: 11.5% |
• Sialic acid linkage differentiation for all N-glycans |
• (Tandem) MS | (Reiding et al. 2014, 2019; Vreeker et al. 2018) | |||
Glycopeptides (e.g. IgG and IgA glycosylation) |
• Protein- and site-specific (no pure proteins required) • High sensitivity • N- and O-glycans |
• Optimization of sample preparation often needed • Limited isomer differentiation |
LC–MS | • 1 sample/ 13 min • 96 samples/ 24 h |
Average CV over all IgG1 glycoforms in the analysis of 20 96-well plates: 8.2% |
• No isomer differentiation • Compositional assignment |
• (Tandem) MS | (Huffman et al. 2014; Momcilovic et al. 2020) |
Intact glycoproteins (e.g. ApoCIII) |
• Protein-specific • Often minimal sample preparation • N- and O-glycans • Complete proteoform assessment |
• Rather low sensitivity • No isomer differentiation • Low complexity sample needed • No HT applications yet |
MALDI–MS | • 1 sample/ min • 96 samples/ 1.6 h |
Average CV over all peaks in the analysis of 1 96-well plates: 15% |
• No isomer differentiation • Compositional assignment |
• (Tandem) MS | (Nicolardi et al. 2013; Demus et al. 2021) |