Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Jul 15.
Published in final edited form as: Open J Immunol. 2018 Jun 29;8(2):36–80. doi: 10.4236/oji.2018.82004

Table S4.

The parameters of the model.

Parameter Description Value Units Ref.
a w Tumor growth rate (colorectal cancer) 2.31 × 10−1 day−1 [32]
c Rate of NK cell-induced tumor death 5.156 × 10−14 L cell−1 day−1 [32]
d Immune strength coefficient {1.3, 1.6, 2.1} day−1 [32]
1 Immune system strength scaling coefficient {1.1, 1.4, 2} unitless [32]
s Value describing how quickly CD8+ T cells respond to the presence of a tumor {5×10−3, 8×10−3, 4×10−2} L [32]
ξ Rate of NK cell-induced tumor death through antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) 6.5 × 10−6 (0 for panitumumab) L cell−1 day−1 [32]
h 1 Concentration of mAbs necessary for half-maximal increase in ADCC activity 1.25 × 10−6 (0 for panitumumab) mg L−1 [32]
X Determines the percent level of the maximum rate of chemotherapy-induced tumor death of wild-type and mutant cells 0.75 unitless [32]
K T Death rate of wild-type and mutant tumor cells due to chemotherapy (8.1 × 10−1)· X day−1 [25], [32]
K AT Chemotherapy-induced death rate of wild-type and mutant tumors due to mAbs cetuximab and panitumumab 4 × 10−4 L mg−1 day−1 [32]
δ T Chemotherapy efficacy coefficient on wild-type and mutant cancer cells 2 × 10−1 L mg−1 [32]
Y Determines the percent level of the maximum rate of mAb-induced tumor death of wild-type and mutant cells 0.75 unitless [32]
ψ Rate of mAb-induced wild-type and mutant tumor cell death (2.28 × 10−2Y for cetuximab (3.125 × 10−2)· Y for panitumumab L mg−1 day−1 [32]
f Rate of NK cell turnover 1 × 10−2 day−1 [32]
e Rate of NK synthesis from circulating lymphocytes 19f day−1 [32]
g N IL-2 concentration needed for half-maximal NK cell proliferation 2.5036 × 105 IU L−1 [32]
p N Rate of IL-2-induced NK cell proliferation 5.13 × 10−2 day−1 [32]
p Rate of NK cell death due to interaction with the tumor 5.156 × 10−14 cell−1 day−1 [32]
p A Rate of NK cell death due to interaction with mAbs complexes 6.5 × 10−10 (0 for panitumumab) cell−1 day−1 [32]
K N Rate of NK cell depletion due to chemotherapy toxicity 9.048 × 10−1 day−1 [32]
δ N Coefficient of chemotherapy toxicity on NK cells 2 × 10−1 L mg−1 [32]
m Rate of turnover of activated CD8+ T cells 5 × 10−3 day−1 [32]
θ IL-2 concentration required to halve the CD8+ T cell turnover rate 2.5036 × 10−3 IU L−1 [32]
q Rate of CD8+ T cell death due to interaction with the tumor 5.156 × 10−17 cell−1 day−1 [32]
r 1 Rate of activation of CD8+ T cell due to NK cell-lysed tumor cell debris 5.156 × 10−12 cell−1 day−1 [32]
r 2 Rate of CD8+ T cell production from circulating lymphocytes 1 × 10−15 cell−1 day−1 [32]
p I2 Rate of CD8+ T cell activation induced by IL-2 2.4036 day−1 [32]
g I2 Concentration of IL-2 necessary for half-maximal CD8+ T cell activation 2.5036 × 103 IU L−1 [32]
u Rate of inhibition of surplus CD8+ T cells induced by Treg cells in the presence of IL-2 2.3085 × 10−13 L2 cell−2 day−1 [49]
κ Concentration of IL-2 required to halve the immunosuppressive effect of Treg cells on CD8+ T cells 2.5036 × 103 IU L−1 [49]
j Rate of activation of CD8+ T cells due to CD8+ T cell-lysed tumor cell debris 1.245 × 10−4 day−1 [32]
k Tumor size required for half-maximal CD8+ T cell activation by CD8+ T cell-lysed tumor cell debris 2.019 × 107 cells [32]
K L Rate of CD8+ T cell depletion from chemotherapy toxicity 4.524 × 10−1 day−1 [32]
δ L Coefficient of chemotherapy toxicity on CD8+ T cells 2 × 10−1 L mg−1 [32]
β Rate of circulating lymphocyte turnover 6.3 × 10−3 day−1 [32]
α Rate of circulating lymphocyte production (3 × 109β cells L−1 day−1 [32]
K C Rate of lymphocyte depletion from chemotherapy toxicity 5.7 × 10−1 day−1 [32]
δ C Coefficient of chemotherapy toxicity on circulating lymphocytes 2 × 10−1 L mg−1 [32]
μ I2 Rate of excretion and elimination of IL-2 11.7427 day−1 [32]
ω Rate of IL-2 production from CD8+ T cells 7.88 × 10−2 IU cell−1 day−1 [32]
ϕ Rate of IL-2 production from circulating CD4+ and naive CD8+ T cells 1.788 × 10−7 IU cell−1 day−1 [32]
ζ Concentration of IL-2 for half-maximal CD8+ T cell IL-2 production 2.5036 × 103 IU L−1 [32]
γ 1 The rate of excretion and elimination of irinotecan 4.077 × 10−1 day−1 [32]
η Rate of cetuximab and panitumumab turnover and excretion 1.386 × 10−1 for cetuximab 9.242 × 10−2 for panitumumab day−1 [32]
λ Rate of mAb-tumor cell complex formation 8.9 × 10−14 for cetuximab 8.6 × 10−14 for panitumumab mg cell−1 L−1 day−1 [32]
h 2 Concentration of cetuximab or panitumumab for half-maximal EGFR binding 4.45 × 10−5 for cetuximab 4.3 × 10−5 for panitumumab mg L−1 [32]
T K Carrying capacity of wild-type and mutant tumor cells combined in the absence of tumor angiogenesis 1 × 106 cells [50]
g 2 Conversion factor from number of activated endothelial cells to the increase in tumor carrying capacity 1 tumor cellsendothelial cell Est.
p 1 Maximum rate of production of TGF-β by hypoxic tumor cells 1 × 105 IU L−1 day−1 Est. from [50]
b 1 Critical tumor size at which the angiogenic switch occurs 1 × 106 cells [50]
S 1 Concentration of TGF-β necessary to reduce the CD8+ T cell killing rate of tumor cells by half 7 × 104 IU L−1 [51]
u 1 Decay rate of TGF-β 10 day−1 [50]
b K Proliferation rate of angiogenic endothelial cells 0.198 day−1 [52]
K max Maximum carrying capacity for blood vessel growth stimulated by TGF-β secreted by tumor cells 5 × 109 cells Est.
g 1 TGF-β concentration that gives a half-maximal proliferation rate of endothelial cells 1 × 104 IU L−1 Est.
d K Growth inhibition coefficient of endothelial cells by tumor cells 5 × 10−8 cell−2/3 day−1 Est. from [53]
λ T Suppressive effect of Treg cells on wild-type and mutant tumor cell kill rate by NK cells 1.59 × 10−9 L cell−1 [45]
w Rate of Treg cell production from circulating lymphocytes 4.698 × 10−4 day−1 [45]
u R Rate of Treg cell turnover 3.851 × 10−2 day−1 [54]
p R Rate of IL-2-induced Treg cell proliferation 3.598 × 10−2 day−1 [49]
g R Concentration of IL-2 necessary for half-maximal activation of Treg cells 11.027 IU L−1 [49]
h R Rate of Treg cell inhibition by Sunitinib 0.227 day−1 [45]
K R Rate of Treg cell depletion from chemotherapy toxicity 5.7 × 10−1 day−1 [45]
α 1 Determines the scope of influence of KRAS-mutant tumor cells Tcp in making tumor cells resistant to chemotherapy and in reducing the sensitizing role of Cetuximab and Panitumumab to chemotherapy 1 × 107 unitless [25]
λ R Efficacy of Sunitinib in inhibiting the immunosuppressive activity of Tregs 50.02 L mg−1 [45]
δ R Chemotherapy toxicity on Tregs 2 × 10−1 L mg−1 [32]
η s Rate of excretion and elimination of Sunitinib 0.277 day−1 [45]
a m Growth rate of mutant tumor cells (colorectal cancer) 2.31 × 10−1 day−1 [32]
μ Maximum mutation rate of wild-type tumor cells 4 × 10−5 day−1 [55]
K M Concentration of Irinotecan chemotherapy that leads to a half-maximal rate of mutation of wild-type tumor cells Tw into irinotecan-resistant tumor cells Ti 1 × 103 mg L−1 Est.
δ TR Efficacy of the second type of chemotherapy drug of killing irinotecan-resistant tumor cells 2 × 10−1 L mg−1 [32]
γ 2 Rate of excretion and elimination of the hypothetical chemotherapy drug 4.077 × 10−1 day−1 [32]
η F Degradation rate of anti-TGF-beta (Fresolimumab) 0.033 day−1 Est. from [56]
b 2 Rate of loss of free TGF-β due to binding with anti-TGF-β 100 L mg−1 day−1 Est. from [56]
b 3 Rate of loss of free anti-TGF-β due to binding with TGF-β 2.5 × 10−13 L IU−1 day−1 Est. from [56]
λ M 0 Differentiation rate of M0 macrophages into an M1 or M2 macrophage 1 × 10−4 day−1 Est. from [31]
λ M 1 Maximal rate at which M2 macrophages switch phenotype to become M1 macrophages 6 × 10−3 day−1 [31]
λ M 2 Maximal rate at which M1 macrophages switch phenotype to become M2 macrophages 6 × 10−3 day−1 Est. from [31]
λ MI 4 Production rate of M2 macrophages due to IL-4 1 × 10−3 day−1 [31]
λ MIγ Production rate of M1 macrophages due to IFN-γ 1 × 10−3 day−1 [31]
λ MIα Production rate of M1 macrophages due to TNF-α 1 × 10−3 day−1 [31]
λ T1M1 Production rate of Th1 cells by M1 macrophages and IL-12 0.23 day−1 [31]
λ TI2 Production rate of Th1 cells by IL-2 1 day−1 [31]
λ T2 Production rate of Th2 cells 0.8 day−1 [31]
λ IγT1 Production rate of IFN-γ by Th1 cells 3.731 × 10−3 IU cell−1 day−1 [31]
λ I12M1 Production rate of IL-12 by M1 macrophages 0.13 IU cell−1 day−1 Est. from [31]
λ I2T1 Production rate of IL-2 by Th1 cells 0.0672 IU cell−1 day−1 [31]
λ TαM1 Production rate of TNF-α by M1 macrophages 13.91 IU cell−1 day−1 [31]
λ I1βM1 Production rate of IL-1β by M1 macrophages 0.1022 IU cell−1 day−1 Est. from [31]
λ I10M 2 Production rate of IL-10 by M2 macrophages 0.02 IU cell−1 day−1 [31]
λ I4T 2 Production rate of IL-4 by Th2 cells 0.0775 IU cell−1 day−1 [31]
λ I4M 2 Production rate of IL-4 by M2 macrophages 0.3094 IU cell−1 day−1 [31]
λ IαM 2 Production rate of IFN-alpha by M2 macrophages 1 × 10−5 IU cell−1 day−1 [31]
λ Treg Production rate of Tregs from Th0 cells due to TGF-β 0.001 day−1 Est.
λ MI10 Production rate of M2 macrophages due to IL-10 1 × 10−3 day−1 Est. from [31]
λ I1βT1 Production rate of IL-1beta by Th1 cells 0.1022 IU cell−1 day−1 Est. from [31]
λ TαT1 Production rate of TNF-alpha by Th1 cells 13.91 IU cell−1 day−1 Est. from [31]
λ I10T2 Production rate of IL-10 by Th2 cells 0.02 IU cell−1 day−1 Est. from [31]
λ I12T1 Production rate of IL-12 by Th1 cells 0.13 IU cell−1 day−1 Est. from [31]
d M1 Death rate of M1 macrophages 0.02 day−1 [31]
d M 2 Death rate of M2 macrophages 0.008 day−1 [31]
d T1 Death rate of Th1 cells 1.97 × 10−1 day−1 [31]
d T2 Death rate of Th2 cells 1.97 × 10−1 day−1 [31]
d Degradation rate of IFN-γ 2.16 day−1 [31]
d Degradation rate of TNF-α 55.45 day−1 [31]
d I1β Degradation rate of IL-1β 6.65 day−1 [31]
d I 4 Degradation rate of IL-4 50 day−1 [31]
d I10 Degradation rate of Il-10 8.32 day−1 [31]
d I12 Degradation rate of IL-12 1.38 day−1 [31]
d Iα Degradation rate of IFN-α 2.16 day−1 Est. from [31]
M 0 Constant source of monocytes 5 × 1010 cells L−1 [31]
T 0 Constant source of naïve T cells 2 × 1010 cells L−1 [31]
K T1 Th1 cell saturation 1 × 1010 cells L−1 [31]
K IFN-γ saturation 2.6 × 106 IU L−1 [31]
K I 2 IL-2 saturation 8 × 106 IU L−1 [31]
K I 4 IL-4 saturation 2.6 × 106 IU L−1 [31]
K I10 IL-10 saturation 3 × 104 IU L−1 Est. from [31]
K I12 IL-12 saturation 1.95 × 108 IU L−1 [31]
K M1 M1 saturation 5 × 1010 cells L−1 [31]
K M 2 M2 saturation 1 × 1011 cells L−1 [31]
K I1β IL-1β saturation 1.3 × 105 IU L−1 [31]
K IFN-α saturation 2.6 × 106 IU L−1 Est. from [31]
K TNF-α saturation 1.3 × 107 IU L−1 [31]
K TGF β TGF-beta saturation 2600 IU L−1 Est. from [31]
g TGF β Concentration of TGF-β for half-maximal activation of Tregs 7 × 104 IU L−1 Est.
δ M1 Death rate of cancer cells by M1 macrophages 1 × 10−9 L cell−1 day−1 Est. from [32]
δ T1 Death rate of cancer cells by Th1 cells. 1 × 10−9 L cell−1 day−1 Est. from [32]
T I10 IL-10 concentration that reduces CTL anti-tumor response by half 3 × 104 IU L−1 Est.
η AI10 Degradation rate of anti-IL-10 3.3 × 10−2 day−1 Est. from [56]
b 4 Rate of loss of free IL-10 due to binding with anti-IL-10 15 L mg−1 day−1 Est. from [56]
b 5 Rate of loss of free anti-IL-10 due to binding with IL-10 1.665 × 10−12 L IU−1 day−1 Est. from [56]