Table 1.
First author (year) | Setting | Sample (N) characteristics | Study methods | Guiding theory | Intervention | Quality appraisal |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Quantitative studies | ||||||
Acri (2019) |
US Poverty‐impacted community |
N = 32 caregivers of children aged 7–11 91% female, 61% mothers 52% Black, 44% White, 67% non‐Hispanic/Latino, 30% household income <$10k/year Substudy of National Institute of Mental Health Study |
Cross‐sectional descriptive Self‐report |
None specified | 4Rs and 2Ss | Level IIIB |
Adaji (2019) |
Nigeria Rural community |
N = 161 mothers in low‐income setting 16.3% pregnant for first time 53.5% had 1–4 children 30.2% had >5 children |
Prospective observational study Self‐report, group facilitator report, and objective measure |
None specified |
Prenatal care program based on centering pregnancy |
Level IIIB |
Booth (2020) |
US Pittsburgh Urban |
N = 185 low‐income adolescent males and their parents Adolescents: 56.44% White, 34.67% Black, 8.89% mixed race Parents: 89.6%–93.5% mothers; 64.89% White, 34.22% African American, <1% mixed race |
Longitudinal descriptive study Secondary data from the Pitt Child & Mother Project Self‐report |
Social disorganized theory | N/A | Level IIIA |
Brisson (2012) |
US Boston, Chicago, and San Antonio Urban |
N = 1495 low‐income mothers (20% poverty rate or more) 43% Black, 48% Hispanic, 8% White |
Longitudinal descriptive study Secondary data from welfare, children, and families: A Three‐cities study Self‐report |
None specified | N/A | Level IIIA |
Brisson (2019) |
US Western United States Urban |
N = 52 families (37 intervention group, 15 nontreatment group) 96% female, 45% Latino, 22% Black, 14% White in 3 low‐income neighborhoods |
Quasi‐experimental study Self‐report |
Ecological system theory |
Your family, your neighborhood (YFYN) |
Level IIB |
McCloskey (2019) |
US 20 large cities Urban |
N = 3876 low‐income mothers, 48% Black, 25.9% Hispanic, 22.5% White |
Cross‐sectional descriptive study secondary data from Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study Self‐report |
Pearlin's stress process model | N/A | Level IIIA |
McLeigh (2018) |
US South Carolina |
N = 483 low‐income primary caregivers of children, 68.4% married, 12.8% separated/divorced 70.3% White, 23.6% Black, 3.7% Hispanic |
Cross‐sectional descriptive study Self‐report and objective data |
None specified | N/A | Level IIIA |
Prendergast (2019) |
US 20 large cities Urban |
N =3529 children and their mothers |
Longitudinal descriptive study Secondary data from Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study Self‐report |
Social ecological model | N/A | Level IIIA |
Yuma‐Guerrero (2017) |
US California |
N = 2750 mothers 31.6% incomes at or below federal poverty line 52.8% Latina, 24.1% White, 6.2% Black |
Cross‐sectional descriptive study Secondary data from the Geographic Research on Wellbeing study Self‐report |
N/A | N/A | Level IIIB |
Qualitative/mixed methods studies | ||||||
Bess (2014) |
US Nashville Urban |
N = 69 parents of Children 0–4 in low‐income neighborhoods, 85% Black, 87% women, 81% single, 84% unemployed | Qualitative | Prilleltensky's model of well‐being | Tied together | Level IIIA |
Curry (2019) |
US Midwest Urban |
N = 59 parent participants of 12 focus groups at six elementary schools Majority mothers |
Qualitative | Social network theory | N/A | Level IIIA |
Davison (2013) |
US Urban |
N = 89 low‐income parents/caregivers of children enrolled in HeadStart 91% female, 52% White, 22% Black, 10% Hispanic |
Mixed‐methods (quantitative measures self‐report) | Family ecological model | N/A | Level IIIC |
Eastwood (2014) |
Australia Sydney Urban |
N = 8 mothers in low‐income community | Qualitative | None specified | N/A | Level IIIB |
Lipman (2010) |
Canada Ontario Urban |
N = 8 Single‐mothers, 50% income <$15,000 | Qualitative | None specified | Community‐based program, unspecified | Level IIIB |
Parsons (2019) |
US Cincinnati Urban |
N = 20 (15 mothers/grandmothers, 5 neighborhood “block captains”) 65% White, 30% Black, 5% mixed race Low‐income neighborhood residents |
Qualitative | None specified | Healthy homes (HH) Block by block (HH) | Level IIIB |