Table 1. Diagnosis and prevention of immediate HSRs to ICM presented in each clinical guideline.
Clinical guideline | Diagnosis | Premedication | Change and selection of alternative contrast agent |
---|---|---|---|
American College of Radiology7 | • No specific mention of a diagnostic test. | • Administering oral corticosteroids 12–13 hours before ICM exposure is recommended to patients who have previously experienced immediate HSRs to ICM. | • If culprit ICM is known in patients who have previously experienced immediate HSRs to ICM, a change of the ICM from the culprit to an alternative ICM is recommended. |
• Performing skin tests routinely before CT scan with ICM is not recommended to predict immediate HSRs. | • If it is difficult to perform an ICM-related skin test, administering intravenous corticosteroid 4–5 hours before ICM exposure is recommended to patients who have previously experienced immediate HSRs to ICM. | • No specific mention of alternative ICM selection | |
• No classification for severity of HSRs | |||
European Society of Urogenital Radiology8 | • Consulting to allergist within 1–6 months is recommended for patients with a previous history of moderate to severe HSRs to ICM. | • Premedication is not recommended due to insufficient evidence. | • A change of the ICM from the culprit to an alternative ICM is recommended for patients who have previously experienced immediate HSRs to ICM |
• Performing skin tests in consultation with an allergist can help to select an alternative ICM | |||
European Academy of Allergy and Clinical Immunology (EAACI) position paper9 | • Skin test is recommended in all patients who have previously experienced immediate HSRs to ICM, except for emergent CT scan with ICM. | • Premedication is recommended for patients who have previously experienced immediate HSRs to ICM or have a difficult situation to perform a skin test due to an emergent CT scan with ICM. | • A change of the ICM from the culprit to a skin test-negative alternative ICM is recommended for patients who have previously experienced immediate HSRs to ICM. |
• DPT can be used to identify suitable alternative ICMs in patients with a negative skin test. | • No classification for severity of HSRs | • Patients having experienced ICM-induced anaphylaxis are recommended to avoid CT scans with ICM. If it is necessary to perform a CT scan with ICM, a replacement to an alternative ICM and a preparation of emergency medicine are recommended. | |
Spanish Society of Allergy and Clinical Immunology (SEAIC)10 | • Skin test is highly recommended for patients who have previously experienced immediate HSRs to ICM. | • The preventive effect of pretreatment is controversial. | • A replacement to an alternative ICM by skin test is recommended for patients who have previously experienced immediate HSRs to ICM. |
• DPT is recommended to confirm an alternative ICM. |
HSR, hypersensitivity reaction; ICM, iodinated contrast media; DPT, drug provocation test.