Table 1.
Type | Setting | Sample | Outcome | Reference | |
Clinician-initiated | |||||
|
Observational | Single-center study in the United States (Minnesota) | 2152 patients | 52.8% to 93.9% diagnostic agreement for pigmented lesions, 47.7% to 87.3% diagnostic agreement for nonpigmented lesions, 66.7% to 79.8% management agreement for pigmented lesions, and 72% to 86.1% management agreement for nonpigmented lesions | Warshaw et al [1] |
|
Observational | Single-center study in the United States (Wisconsin) | 135 children | 82% agreement between TDa and FTFb diagnosis (95% CI 73%-88%) | Heffner et al [2] |
|
Observational | Web-based app in Sweden | 40 adults | 68% interobserver agreement for TD diagnosis (95% CI 51%-81%), and 88% interobserver agreement for FTF diagnosis (95% CI 73%-96%) | Börve et al [3] |
|
Systematic review | N/Ac | 25 studies | 62% to 89% agreement between TD and FTF diagnosis | Rat et al [4] |
|
Observational | Single-center study in Austria | 18 adults | 89% exact agreement between TD and FTF diagnosis | Massone et al [12] |
|
Observational | Single-center study in the United States (California) | 86 adults | 82% agreement between TD and FTF diagnosis (95% CI 73%-89%) | Lamel et al [13] |
|
Observational | Single-center study in the United States (Ohio) | 318 clinic visits | MDd/DOe: 50% exact diagnostic agreement between TD and office visit, and 29.8% exact diagnostic agreement between TD and walk-in clinic; NPf/PAg: 33.8% exact diagnostic agreement between TD and office visit, and 34% exact diagnostic agreement between TD and walk-in clinic; diagnostic agreement was higher for MD/DO office visits than MD/DO walk-in clinics (P=.021), NP/PA office visits (P=.035), and NP/PA walk-in clinics (P=.022) | Pasadyn et al [15] |
Patient-initiated | |||||
|
Observational | Single-center study in Australia | 55 adults | 69% exact agreement between TD and FTF diagnosis | Boyce et al [5] |
|
Observational | Single-center study in Austria | 263 adults | 49% exact agreement between TD and FTF diagnosish; significant correlation between correct diagnosis and image quality (P<.001) | Weingast et al [8] |
|
Randomized controlled trial | Single-center study in the United States (Pennsylvania) | 40 children | 83% agreement between TD and FTF diagnosis (95% CI 71%-94%) | O’Conner et al [16] |
|
Observational | Single-center study in the Netherlands | 96 adults | 41% exact agreement between TD and FTF diagnosis | Eminović et al [17] |
aTD: teledermatology.
bFTF: face-to-face.
cN/A: not applicable.
dMD: Doctor of Medicine.
eDO: Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine.
fNP: nurse practitioner.
gPA: physician assistant.
hIncludes cases that dermatologists indicated as not possible to diagnose.