Table 1.
Article | Samplea | Instrumentb | Sample size | Time frame | # Criteria |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Casey et al. (2012); Lane and Sher (2015)c | NESARC Wave 2 | AUDADIS-IV | 22,177g | Current | 11 |
Dawson et al. (2010) d | NESARC Wave 1 | AUDADIS-IV | 26,946g | Current | 11 |
Saha et al. (2006) d | NESARC Wave 1 | AUDADIS-IV | 22,526h | Current | 10 |
Saha et al. (2007) d | NESARC Wave 1 | AUDADIS-IV | 20,846i | Current | 11 |
Shmulewitz et al. (2010) d | Israeli households | AUDADIS-IV | 1,066 | Current | 11 |
1,160 | Lifetime | 11 | |||
Keyes et al. (2011) | NLAES | AUDADIS-IV | 18,352i | Current | l2 |
Preuss et al. (2014) | WHO/ISBRA | AUDADIS-based | 711 | Lifetime | 11 |
Australia | 104 | ||||
Brazil | 212 | ||||
Canada | 227 | ||||
Finland | 86 | ||||
Japan | 82 | ||||
Mewton et al. (2011a); Proudfoot et al. (2006) | NSMHWB | CIDI V2.0 | 7,746 | Current | 11 |
Mewton et al. (2011b) | NSMHWB | CIDI V2.0 | 853j | Current | 11 |
McCutcheon et al. (2011) | COGA | SSAGA | 8,605 | Lifetime | 9 |
Non-DUI Men | 3,056 | ||||
Non-DUI Women | 3,894 | ||||
DUI Men | 1,330 | ||||
DUI Women | 325 | ||||
Beseler et al. (2010) | College students | Survey-specific | 353 | Current | 10o |
Hagman (2017) c | College Students | Brief DSM-5 AUD Assessment | 923g | Current | 11 |
Hagman and Cohn (2011) | College students | CIDI-SAM | 396 | Current | 11 |
Ehlke et al. (2012) | NSDUH 2009 | SAMHSA | 4,605k | Current | 11 |
Kuerbis et al. (2013b) | NSDUH 2009 | SAMHSA | 3,412l | Current | 11 |
Hagman and Cohn (2013) | NSDUH 2009 | SAMHSA | 3,806m | Current | 11p |
Rose et al. (2012) | NSDUH 2002-2008 | SAMHSA | 9,356n | Current | 11 |
Harford et al. (2009) | NSDUH 2002-2005 | SAMHSA | 133,231 | Current | 11 |
Men, Age 12-17 years | 11,651 | ||||
Men, Age 18-25 years | 27,377 | ||||
Men, Age 26+ years | 25,872 | ||||
Women, Age 12-17 years | l2,304 | ||||
Women, Age 18-25 years | 29,331 | ||||
Women, Age 26+ years | 26,696 | ||||
Srisurapanont et al. (2012) | Thai-NMH Survey | MINI-Thai | 3,718 | Current | 7 |
Men | 3,174 | ||||
Women | 544 | ||||
Adolescents | 272 | ||||
Adults | 3,446 | ||||
Duncan et al. (2011) | MOAFTS | SSAGA | 2,835 | Lifetime | 11 |
Women, Age 18-20 | 1,158 | ||||
Women, Age 21-25 | 1,677 | ||||
Derringer et al. (2013) | MTFS & SAGE | SSAGA | 6,597 | Lifetime | 7 |
Gilder et al. (2011) e | American Indians | SSAGA | 530 | Lifetime | 10 |
Gelhorn et al. (2008) | Mixed Adolescentsf | CIDI-SAM | 5,587 | Lifetime | 11 |
Caetano et al. (2016) c | Puerto Rican adults | CIDI-Spanish | 1,107g | Lifetime | 11 |
Castaldelli-Maia et al. (2015) c | Brazilian adults | CIDI-Portuguese | 936i | Current | 11 |
Bond et al. (2012); Borges et al., 2010, 2011); Cherpitel et al. (2010) | ED patients | CIDI V1.0 | 3,191 | Current | 12 |
Argentina | 662 | ||||
Mexico | 547 | ||||
Poland | 1,098 | ||||
USA | 884 | ||||
Hasin et al. (2012) d | Clinical | PRISM | 543 | Current | 11 |
Langenbucher et al. (2004) | Clinical | CIDI-SAM | 372 | Lifetime | 9 |
Wu et al. (2009) | Clinical | DSM-IV checklist | 462 | Current | 7 |
Wu et al. (2012) | Clinical | DSM-IV checklist | 671 | Current | 7 |
Martin et al. (2006) | Clinical adolescents | SCID | 464 | Lifetime | 11 |
Edwards et al. (2013) | VATSPSUD | SCID | 7,454 | Lifetime | 11 |
Kuerbis et al. (2013a) | SARD | SCID | 461 | Lifetime | 11 |
NESARC = National Epidemiological Study on Alcohol and Related Conditions; NLAES = National Longitudinal Alcohol Epidemiologic Study; WHO/ISBRA = World Health Organization/International Society on Biomedical Research Collaborative Study; NSMHWB = National Survey of Mental Health and Well-Being (Australia); COGA = Collaborative Study on the Genetics of Alcoholism; NSDUH = National Survey on Drug Use and Health; Thai-NMH Survey = Thai National Mental Health Survey; MOAFTS = Missouri Adolescent Female Twin Study; MTFS = Minnesota Twin Family Study; SAGE = Study of Addiction: Genes and Environment; ED = Emergency Department, VATSPSUD = Virginia Adult Twin Study of Psychiatric and Substance Use Disorders; SARD = Substance Abuse Research Demonstration.
AUDADIS-IV = Alcohol Use Disorder and Associated Disabilities Interview Schedule-IV; CIDI = Composite International Diagnostic Interview; SSAGA = Semistructured Assessment for the Genetics of Alcoholism; SAMHSA = Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration; SAM = Substance Abuse Module; MINI-Thai = Mini International Neuropsychiatric Inventory, Thai module; PRISM = Psychiatric Research Interview for Substance and Mental Disorders; SCID = Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV.
Additional studies included in the updated analysis.
We could not confirm the reported metric for the item response theory (IRT) parameters with the authors, but based on the description and software used an IRT parameterization seemed likely. Differential item functioning analysis estimates could also not be acquired, so the aggregate results were used.
We selected the authors’ “once per month” binge drinking criteria for comparison of the IRT thresholds. Using the other criteria resulted in trivially different associations.
Combination of community, adjudicated, and clinical individuals.
Past year drinkers.
≥ 12 Drinks in past year and ever drank 5+ drinks on ≥ 1 occasion.
≥ 12 Drinks in past year.
Young adult (18-24 years) subsample only.
College students.
Age 50+ years.
Noncollege, Age 18-25 years.
Adolescent and young adult drinkers (12-21yrs) only.
Authors created a combined measure of interpersonal and legal problems criteria.
Tolerance severity not reported.