Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 27;65(4):287–302. doi: 10.5468/ogs.21265

Table 1.

Characteristics of studies included

Study Country Study design Mean MA (years) Mean GA (weeks) Depression scale Depression (%) Sample size
Pregnant (%) Postpartum (%) Total (%)
Ahlers-Schmidt et al. [18] (2020) USA Cohort 25.3 - Diagnosis (58-item electronic survey) - - 9 (7.9) 114
An et al. [19] (2021) China Cross-sectional 30.39 - EPDS (≥10) 0 119 (56.9) 119 (56.9) 209
Basu et al. [20] (2021) 64 countries Cross-sectional 31.3 PHQ-4 (≥6) 1,775 (31) 363 (30.7) 2,138 (31.0) 6,894
Berthelot et al. [21] (2020) Canada Cohort 29.27 24.8 K10 (≥30) 30 (2.38) - 30 (2.38) 1,258
Brik et al. [22] (2021) Spain Cohort 32.3 - EPDS (≥10) 62 (38) - 62 (38) 164
Ceulemans et al. [23] (2021) Ireland, Norway, Switzerland, the Netherlands, and UK Cross-sectional - - EDS (≥13) 533 592 1,125 8,087
Chrzan-Dętkoś et al. [24] (2021) Poland Cross-sectional 31.74 38.88 EPDS (≥10) 0 65 (83.32) 65 (83.32) 78
Dong et al. [25] (2021) China Cross-sectional - - SDS (>50) 79 (50.6) 0 79 (50.6) 156
Durankuş et al. [26] (2020) Turkey Cross-sectional 29.56 7.04 EPDS (≥13) 92 (35.4) 0 92 (35.4) 260
Fallon et al. [27] (2021) UK Cross-sectional 30.9 - EPDS (≥13) 0 264 (43) 264 (43) 614
Farewell et al. [28] (2020) USA Mixed-method pilot - - PHQ-2 (≥3) - - 3 (12) 27
Farrell et al. [29] (2020) Qatar Cross-sectional 30.5 26.1 PHQ-9 (≥5) - - 113 (39.2) 288
Gur et al. [30] (2020) USA Cross-sectional 32.45 24.86 PHQ-2 (>2) 78 (9.9) 0 78 (9.9) 787
Hiiragi et al. [31] (2021) Japan Retrospective cohort - - EPDS (≥9) 0 38 (14) 38 (14) 279
Hui et al. [32] (2021) Hong Kong Retrospective cohort 33.1 - EPDS (≥10) 0 133 (14.4) 133 (14.4) 954
Janevic et al. [33] (2021) USA Cross-sectional - - PHQ-2 (3–6) 0 13 (5.83) 13 (5.83) 223
Jiang et al. [34] (2021) China Cross-sectional 29 - EDS (≥10) 859 (45.9) 0 859 (45.9) 1,873
Khamees et al. [35] (2021) Egypt Cross-sectional 25.08 6.58 EPDS (≥14) 53 (44.2) 0 53 (44.2) 120
King et al. [36] (2021) USA Cohort 33.69 26.79 EPDS (≥11) 144 (42) 0 144 (42) 343
Lebel et al. [37] (2020) Canada Cross-sectional 32.4 22.5 EPDS (≥13) 653 (37) 0 653 (37) 1,764
Li et al. [38] (2021) China Cross-sectional 30.19 - PHQ-9 (≥5) - - 778 (35.34) 2,201
Li et al. [39] (2020) China Cross-sectional - - PHQ-9 (≥5) 29 (64.4) 0 29 (64.4) 45
Liang et al. [40] (2020) China Cross-sectional - - EPDS (≥10) 0 253 (30) 253 (30) 845
Lin et al. [41] (2021) China Cross-sectional 30.51 - PHQ-9 (≥5) 266 (35.4) 0 266 (35.4) 751
Liu et al. [42] (2021) USA Cross-sectional - - EPDS (>13) 260 (36.4) 0 260 (36.4) 715
Lubián López et al. [43] (2021) Spain Cross-sectional - - EPDS (>10) 182 (35.4) 0 182 (35.4) 514
Matsushima and Horiguchi [44] (2022) Japan Cross-sectional - - EPDS (≥13) 303 (17) 0 303 (17) 1,777
Medina-Jimenez et al. [45] (2020) Mexico Cross-sectional 28.1 27.9 EPDS (≥14) 88 (17.5) 0 88 (17.5) 503
Mo et al. [46] (2021) China Cross-sectional - - PHQ-9 (≥5) 1,989 (48.7) 0 1,989 (48.7) 4,087
Molgora et al. [47] (2020) Italy Cross-sectional - - EPDS (≥13) 133 49 182 (31.65) 575
Ng et al. [48] (2020) Singapore Cross-sectional 31.8 - DASS-21 (>9) 59 (18.4) 0 59 (18.4) 324
Nodoushan et al. [49] (2020) Iran Cross-sectional - 39.4 DASS 220 (39.2) 0 220 (39.2) 560
Obata et al. [50] (2021) Japan Cross-sectional - 23.3 EPDS (≥9) 1,608 (31.83) 867 2,475 (31.83) 7,775
Oskovi-Kaplan et al. [51] (2021) Turkey Cross-sectional 26 - EPDS (≥13) 0 33 (14.79) 33 (14.79) 223
Ostacoli et al. [52] (2020) Italy Cross-sectional 34.77 - EPDS (≥11) 0 72 (44.2) 72 (44.2) 163
Pariente et al. [53] (2020) Israel Cohort 29.1 - EPDS (≥10) 0 38 (23.5) 52 (23.5) 223
Perzow et al. [54] (2021) USA Prospective cohort 31.81 - EPDS (≥10) - - 45 (33.3) 135
Racine et al. [55] (2021) Canada Prospective cohort - - CES-D-10 (≥10) 458 (35.21) - 458 (35.21) 1,301
Sade et al. [56] (2020) Israel Cross-sectional - - EPDS (≥10) 84 (25) - 21 (25) 84
Silverman et al. [57] (2020) New York, USA Cohort 27 27.3 EPDS (≥9) - 97 (18.8) 97 (18.8) 516
Suárez-Rico et al. [58] (2021) Mexico Cross-sectional 29.9 EPDS (≥13) - 115 (39.2) 115 (39.2) 293
Sun et al. [59] (2020) Wuhan, China Cross-sectional - - EPDS 234 (31.7) 714 (34.1) 972 (33.71) 2,830
Kahyaoglu Sut and Kucukkaya [60] (2021) Turkey Cross-sectional 28.2 - HADS-D (≥8) 227 (56.3) - 227 (56.3) 403
Thayer et al. [61] (2021) USA Cross-sectional - - EPDS (≥15) 496 (23.6) - 496 (23.6) 2,099
Tsakiridis et al. [62] (2021) Greece Cross-sectional - 25.4 EPDS (≥13) 68 (13.5) - 68 (13.5) 505
Wang et al. [5] (2021) China Cross-sectional - - PHQ-9 (>5) 6,723 (43.6) - 6,723 (43.6) 15,328
Wu et al. [63] (2020) China Cross-sectional - 39.41 EPDS (≥10) 381 (29.6) - 381 (29.6) 1,285
Xu et al. [64] (2021) China Cross-sectional 30.4 - EPDS (≥10) 44 (16.1) - 44 (16.1) 274
Yang et al. [65] (2021) China Cross-sectional - - PHQ-9 (≥5) 8,712 (44.6) - 8,712 (44.6) 19,515
Zanardo et al. [66] (2020) Northeastern Italy Case–control 33.73 - EPDS (>12) - 26 (28.6) 26 (28.6) 91
Zeng et al. [68] (2020) China Cross-sectional 29.2 - EPDS 109 (21.12) 11 (10.1) 625 (19.2) 625
Zhang et al. [67] (2020) China Cross-sectional 28.9 - EPDS (≥10) 1,094 (58) - 1,094 (58) 1,901
Zhou et al. [69] (2021) China Cross-sectional 29.95 - PHQ-9 527 (41.63) - 527 (41.63) 1,266
Zilver et al. [70] (2021) The Netherlands Cohort 32.02 - HADS-D (≥8) 145 (13.2) - 145 (13.2) 1,102

MA, maternal age; GA, gestational age; EPDS, edinburgh postnatal depression scale; PHQ, patient health questionnaire; K-10, kessler psychological distress scale; EDS, Edinburgh depression scale; SDS, self-depression rating scale; DASS, depression anxiety and stress scale; CES-D-10, the 10 item center for epidemiologic studies depression scale; HADS, hospital anxiety and depression scale-depression.