Enzymes |
Metabolites, small molecules |
Catalysis |
Natural or recombinant production |
Yes |
Poor |
Good |
Many enzymes are available for metabolites and substrates; can be extremely sensitive |
Stability might be a concern |
150,152 |
Affinity proteins |
Metabolites, small molecules, proteins, peptides, nucleic acids, lipids |
Direct binding |
Natural or recombinant production |
No |
Poor |
Poor |
Many affinity proteins are available and well-developed assays for them exist; can be extremely sensitive |
Stability might be a concern; considerable effort to create a novel affinity protein |
158,264,265 |
Affinity peptides |
Proteins, peptides, nucleic acids, materials |
Direct binding |
Chemical synthesis |
No |
Good |
Good |
Small size; chemical synthesis enables a wide range of functionalizations; very stable |
Can exhibit poor sensitivity and specificity |
266,267 |
Aptamers |
Metabolites, small molecules, proteins, peptides, nucleic acids, lipids |
Direct binding |
In vitro synthesis or chemical synthesis |
No |
Good |
Good |
Chemical synthesis enables a wide range of functionalizations; some aptamers can be reversibly unfolded |
Stability might be a concern owing to nucleases; might require considerable effort to create a novel aptamer |
159,268 |
CRISPR |
Nucleic acids |
Direct binding or catalysis |
Natural or recombinant production |
Yes: Cas12, Cas13 and Cas14 only |
Poor |
Poor |
Easy to use; highly programmable for nucleic acid targeting |
Probe molecules needed for CRISPR sensing are labile owing to nucleases in sample |
28,36,161,163–165,269,270 |