Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 11;10:929473. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.929473

Table 1.

Strategies for promoting and measuring critical thinking in intervention programming.

Area Strategies
Promoting critical thinking Content for children • Use a co-creation method with different stakeholders to design effective interventions
• Ensure lessons are flexible and reflect the changing media environment
• Prioritise the ability to recognise persuasive intent across a range of mediated messages and formats
• Include real-world examples, and allow children to be the content experts
Teaching practices • Integrate critical media literacy into existing subject-area lessons across all grades (from K-12)
• Use a key concepts approach
• Design inquiry-based lessons
• Incorporate hands-on learning activities
• Provide children with the opportunity to make media
• Acknowledge children's positive feelings towards brands and food products
• Acknowledge the instructor's own vulnerability to media
• Foster an environment of critical respect
• Encourage scepticism, not cynicism
• Encourage action and engaged citizenship
Teaching support • Support and facilitate professional development and training on media literacy/critical thinking
• Create curriculum-linked lessons-in-a-box (tool-kits; lesson plans)
• Encourage peer training opportunities
Parent/caregiver involvement • Engage parents/caregivers in media literacy activities
• Provide support to increase parental/caregiver media literacy and facilitate professional development and training on media literacy/critical thinking
Measuring critical thinking Program effectiveness • Use a mixed methods approach
• Use quantitative methods (i.e., pre/post-test) for measuring recognition and understanding (changes in knowledge levels)
• Use qualitative methods to explore analysis and evaluation skills (changes in perceptions/attitudes)
Broader/longer-term impacts • Track reach of program (i.e., number of children exposed)
• Use post-post-evaluations to gauge learning over longer term
• Measure capabilities and confidence of the children's community of trusted adults to support the development and application of critical media literacy skills
Resources Media Literacy & Food Marketing (MLFM) Lesson Plans and Tool-Kits (https://www.ucalgary.ca/food-marketing/knowledge-translation, includes lessons on persuasive elements of food packaging, interactive tool-kits, fact sheets for parents/caregivers).
Making Media for a Healthier U: Nutrition and Advertising Literacy (https://makingmedia.media.illinois.edu/curriculum/waukegan-pilot-nutrition-and-advertising-curriculum-may-2014/, includes lessons on nutrition and advertising literacy, student worksheets, teacher guide).
Project Look Sharp (www.projectlooksharp.org, includes lessons on health and consumer education, and professional development resources for teachers).
ReclameWijs [Advertising-Wise] (https://reclamewijs.ugent.be/, includes interactive media literacy games and vlog content around brand awareness).
MediaSmarts (www.mediasmarts.ca/marketing-consumerism/resources-teachers, includes lessons on food advertising, the nutritional value of foods advertised on television/magazines, and an interactive unit on food marketing on the web)
Apple Schools (www.appleschools.ca/monthly-campaigns-march, includes teacher materials on nutrition and food advertising).