Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 11;13:883433. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2022.883433

TABLE 2.

Examples of clusters which both reflect (67, 14, 341, 213) and do not reflect (70, 49, 403) their programmatically generated scores. The table includes a cluster identifier (Cluster Number), calculated relatedness score from the NLP analysis (Score), relatedness category from manual review (Category), description of the overarching theme of the cluster (Description), and the ARIC variables in the cluster (Variables). Clusters were selected to highlight cases of agreement and disagreement between programmatic scoring and reviewer category assignment. See Supplemental Table S1 for all clusters.

Cluster Number Score Category Description Variables
67 42.0 Exact lung health history (lung disease) Has a doctor ever said that you had any of the following: chronic lung disease, such as chronic bronchitis, or emphysema? Q10g [Home Interview, exam 1]
[Medical care]. Has a doctor ever said you had any of the following: (read each disease name and code N if No or Never Tested). Q5. Chronic lung disease, such as chronic bronchitis, or emphysema. Q5E [Health/Medical History, exam 2]
14 24.7 Highly Related lung health history (asthma) [Asthma]. Ever had asthma? Q35 [Respiratory Symptoms and Physical Activity Form, exam 1]
[Asthma]. Age asthma started Q37 [Respiratory Symptoms and Physical Activity Form, exam 1]
[Asthma]. Age asthma stopped. Q39 [Respiratory Symptoms and Physical Activity Form, exam 1]
[Wheezing]. Age at first attack. Q18 [Respiratory Symptoms and Physical Activity Form, exam 1]
Has a doctor ever said that you had any of the following: asthma? Q10h [Home Interview, exam 1]
[Medical care]. Has a doctor ever said you had any of the following: (read each disease name and code N if No or Never Tested). Q5. Asthma. Q5F [Health/Medical History, exam 2]
[Medical care]. Has a doctor ever said you had any of the following? Asthma. Q6e [Personal History form, exam 4]
[Asthma]. Still have asthma? Q38 [Respiratory Symptoms and Physical Activity Form, exam 1]
[Wheezing]. Short Of Breath Wheezing Attack? Q17 [Respiratory Symptoms and Physical Activity Form, exam 1]
341 16.4 Related lung health history (cough/wheezing) [Wheezing]. Number years this wheezy or whistling sound been present. Q16 [Respiratory Symptoms and Physical Activity Form, exam 1]
[Cough]. Number years had trouble with phlegm. Q12 [Respiratory Symptoms and Physical Activity Form, exam 1]
213 7.8 Unrelated diet [Other dietary items]. Enter code and specify brand and form below. Q78 [Dietary Intake Form (DTIC), exam 3]
[Other dietary items]. What kind of fat do you usually use for baking? Q77 [Dietary Intake Form (DTIC), exam 3]
70 6.0 Exact medication (cholesterol lowering) Cholesterol lowering medication W/in 2 weeks.: using 2004 Med. code, visit 2 [Cohort, Exam 2]
Used statin (at visit 2) last 2 weeks (0 = no, 1 = yes) based on 2004 Med. code [Cohort, Exam 2]
49 5.7 Exact blood pressure measurements (ankle brachial) Ankle Brachial Index, visit 1, definition 4 [Ankle Brachial Index Data, exam 1]
Ankle-Brachial index return [Ankle Brachial BP (Blood Pressure—ultrasound work station), exam 1]
403 50.0 Related medication [Medication records]. Medication code number. Q12B [Medication Survey Form, exam 2]
[Medication records]. Medication code number. Q11B [Medication Survey Form, exam 2]