Skip to main content
. 2022 Apr 15;31(11):3098–3111. doi: 10.1111/mec.16451

TABLE 1.

Analysis of variance. Multivariate (MANOVA) and univariate (ANOVA) analysis of variance, testing the effect of generation (G), genotype (Gen), treatment (T) and their interaction terms on five fitness‐linked life history traits. The chemical tested are: PFOS (70 ng L−1), diclofenac (2 mg L−1), trimethoprim (2 mg L−1), atrazine (0.2 mg L−1) and arsenic (1,000 µg L−1). Size at maturity (mm), age at maturity (days), fecundity (number of offspring across two broods), interval between broods (time elapsed between broods) and mortality were measured. Each genotype is run in five clonal replicates. Significant p‐values are in bold

MANOVA ANOVA
Size at maturity (mm) Age at maturity (days) Fecundity Interval between broods Mortality
df F p‐Value df Chi‐sq p‐Value Chi‐sq p‐Value Chi‐sq p‐Value Chi‐sq p‐Value Chi‐sq p‐Value
PFOS
Generation (G) 2 9.04 3.2e‐09*** Generation (G) 2 41.68 8.9e‐10*** 41.94 7.8e‐10*** 62.40 2.8e‐14*** 8.10 .02* 6.48 .010891*
Genotype (Gen) 3 4.31 7.4e‐06*** Genotype (Gen) 3 5.14 .16 2.61 .46 29.19 2.0e‐06*** 0.34 .95 16.16 .001052**
Treatment (T) 1 2.69 .04* Treatment (T) 1 19.74 8.8e‐06*** 0.49 .48 4.09 .04304* 0.03 .87 5.18 .022829*
G × Gen 4 1.59 .07 G × Gen 4 18.74 .0009*** 9.17 .06 33.20 1.1e‐06*** 1.29 .86 5.69 .13
G × T 2 3.07 .004** G × T 2 13.29 .001** 23.12 9.5e‐06*** 7.44 .02* 1.72 .42 1.87 .17
Gen × T 3 1.94 .03* Gen × T 3 22.85 4.3e‐05*** 0.54 .91 1.28 .73 1.92 .59 8.98 .029603*
G × Gen × T 4 1.19 .27 G × Gen × T 4 7.03 .13 1.52 .82 4.45 .35 1.29 .86 8 .038836*
DICLOFENAC
Generation (G) 2 14.77 2.1e‐15*** Generation (G) 2 73.63 <2.2e‐16*** 110.90 <2.2e‐16*** 127.47 <2.2e‐16*** 21.35 2.3e‐05*** 7.85 .0197461*
Genotype (Gen) 3 2.67 .002** Genotype (Gen) 3 13.25 .004** 6.34 .10 29.37 1.9e‐06*** 0.50 .92 7.76 .05
Treatment (T) 1 16.24 2.4e‐09*** Treatment (T) 1 44.52 2.5e‐11*** 39.40 3.4e‐10*** 16.32 5.3e‐05*** 0.12 .73 13.45 .0002447***
G × Gen 5 2.37 .001** G × Gen 5 26.05 8.7e‐05*** 17.25 .004** 56.96 5.2e‐11*** 3.43 .63 14.84 .0110460*
G × T 2 10.81 1.0e‐11*** G × T 2 31.09 1.8e‐07*** 83.62 <2.2e‐16*** 21.13 2.6e‐05*** 5.76 .06 21.33 2.331e‐05***
Gen × T 3 2.59 .003** Gen × T 3 13.52 .004** 5.42 .14 2.00 .57 2.82 .42 1.97 .58
G × Gen × T 5 3.51 1.370e‐06*** G × Gen × T 5 25.37 .0001*** 17.25 3.5e‐07*** 8.84 .12 5.35 .37 0 1
TRIMETHOPRIM
Generation (G) 2 16.77 <2.2e‐16*** Generation (G) 2 16.65 .0002*** 87.14 <2.2e‐16*** 92.88 <2.2e‐16*** 21.85 1.8e‐05*** 0.10 .76
Genotype (Gen) 3 4.35 .55 Genotype (Gen) 3 18.29 .0004*** 18.29 .0003827*** 39.90 1.1e‐08*** 1.35 .72 7.01 .14
Treatment (T) 1 1.45 .22 Treatment (T) 1 0.25 .62 0.34 .56 0.07 .79 4.20 .04* 0.94 .33
G × Gen 6 2.31 .0006*** G × Gen 6 21.26 .002** 17.84 .006637** 28.44 7.76e‐05*** 4.19 .65 2.76 .43
G × T 2 2.30 .023* G × T 2 0.90 .64 7.55 .022895* 4.17 .12 1.61 .45 0.04 .85
Gen × T 3 3.39 .0001*** Gen × T 3 29.47 1.8e‐06*** 3.78 .29 16.34 .0001*** 2.43 .49 2.63 .45
G × Gen × T 6 1.75 .02* G × Gen × T 6 16.89 .01** 9.25 .16 12.92 .04* 7.95 .24 9.23 .02639*
ATRAZINE
Generation (G) 2 7.07 .84 Generation (G) 2 44.74 1.9e‐10*** 39.83 2.2e‐09*** 35.42 2e‐08*** 3.88 .14 0.01 .90
Genotype (Gen) 3 1.50 .39 Genotype (Gen) 3 23.06 3.9e‐05*** 3.98 .26 21.28 9.2e‐05*** 0.82 .84 12.87 .004920**
Treatment (T) 1 15.46 1.4e‐07*** Treatment (T) 1 89.50 <2.2e‐16*** 0.52 .47 33.65 6.6e‐09*** 0.18 .68 20.53 5.881e‐06***
G × Gen 2 2.49 .02* G × Gen 2 10.06 .006** 2.35 .31 8.69 .01294* 0.12 .94 4.38 .11
G × T 2 2.19 .04* G × T 2 6.42 .04* 3.55 .17 1.62 .44 0.67 .71 0.14 .71
Gen × T 3 2.24 .55 Gen × T 3 4.18 .24 3.84 .28 1.73 .63 1.54 .67 4.96 .18
G × Gen × T 1 2.76 .04* G × Gen × T 2 7.12 .03* 2.84 .03* 6.52 .04* 0.00 .99 10.2274 .006014**
ARSENIC
Generation (G) 2 14.17 4.233e‐15*** Generation (G) 2 83.76 <2.2e‐16*** 39.14 3.165e‐09*** 0.35 .84 8.26 .0161066* 2.53 .28
Genotype (Gen) 3 4.15 7.332e‐06*** Genotype (Gen) 3 17.58 .0005378*** 134.18 <2.2e‐16*** 38.44 2.284e‐08*** 6.25 .10 1.01 .80
Treatment (T) 1 1.24 .30 Treatment (T) 1 1.81 .18 1.91 .17 0.03 .85 0.08 .77 0.00 .98
G × Gen 6 6.08 3.067e‐15*** G × Gen 6 66.16 2.501e‐12*** 59.61 5.394e‐11*** 22.31 .001066** 27.59 .0001124*** 11.66 .07
G × T 2 3.03 .003557** G × T 2 10.83 .0044538** 8.50 .01425* 2.75 .25 1.34 .51 7.81 .020177*
Gen × T 3 2.61 .002843** Gen × T 3 9.15 .0273738* 10.75 .01314* 3.24 .36 1.34 .72 11.64 .008706**
G × Gen × T 6 3.23 1.387e‐06*** G × Gen × T 6 11.75 .07 38.13 1.061e‐06*** 33.35 8.985e‐06*** 1.33 .97 0 1